Introduction
Discussion about evolution in Oxford, England The 1860 Oxford evolution debate took place at the Oxford University Museum in Oxford, England, on 30 June 1860, seven months after the publication of Charles Darwin's On the Origin of .Discussion about evolution in Oxford, England The 1860 Oxford evolution debate took place at the Oxford University Museum in Oxford, England, on 30 June 1860, seven months after the publication of Charles Darwin's On the Origin of .
Although Huxley and Wilberforce were not the only participants in the discussion, they were reported to be the two dominant .Although Huxley and Wilberforce were not the only participants in the discussion, they were reported to be the two dominant .
Huxley is said to have replied that he would not be ashamed to have a monkey for his ancestor, but he would be ashamed to be connected with a man who used his great gifts to obscure the .Huxley is said to have replied that he would not be ashamed to have a monkey for his ancestor, but he would be ashamed to be connected with a man who used his great gifts to obscure the .
and subsequent accounts were subject to distortion since no verbatim account of the debate .and subsequent accounts were subject to distortion since no verbatim account of the debate .
whereas another suggests he may have said that "it was of little consequence to himself whether or not his grandfather might be called a monkey or ."whereas another suggests he may have said that "it was of little consequence to himself whether or not his grandfather might be called a monkey or ."
Background
The idea of transmutation of species was seen as contrary to religious orthodoxy and a threat to the social order and thus was very controversial in the first half of the nineteenth century, although Radicals seeking to widen democracy and overturn the aristocratic hierarchy welcomed .The idea of transmutation of species was seen as contrary to religious orthodoxy and a threat to the social order and thus was very controversial in the first half of the nineteenth century, although Radicals seeking to widen democracy and overturn the aristocratic hierarchy welcomed .
The scientific community was wary in the absence of a proposed .The scientific community was wary in the absence of a proposed .
The anonymous publication of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, supporting the idea of transmutation of species, in 1844 brought a storm of controversy but attracted wide readership and became a .The anonymous publication of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, supporting the idea of transmutation of species, in 1844 brought a storm of controversy but attracted wide readership and became a .
At the British Association for the Advancement of Science meeting at Oxford in May 1847, the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce used his Sunday sermon at St. Mary's Church on "the wrong way of doing science" to deliver a stinging attack obviously aimed at its author, Robert Chambers, in a church "crowded to suffocation" with archaeologists, geoscientists, astronomers, chemists, physicists, and .At the British Association for the Advancement of Science meeting at Oxford in May 1847, the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce used his Sunday sermon at St. Mary's Church on "the wrong way of doing science" to deliver a stinging attack obviously aimed at its author, Robert Chambers, in a church "crowded to suffocation" with archaeologists, geoscientists, astronomers, chemists, physicists, and .
The scientific establishment also remained skeptical, but the book had convinced a vast popular .The scientific establishment also remained skeptical, but the book had convinced a vast popular .
Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species was published on 24 November 1859 to wide debate and .Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species was published on 24 November 1859 to wide debate and .
Influential biologist Richard Owen wrote an anonymous negative review of the book in the Edinburgh Review and coached Wilberforce, who also wrote an anonymous 17,000 word review in the Quarterly .Influential biologist Richard Owen wrote an anonymous negative review of the book in the Edinburgh Review and coached Wilberforce, who also wrote an anonymous 17,000 word review in the Quarterly .
Thomas Huxley, one of the small group with whom Darwin had shared his theory before publication, emerged as the main public champion of .Thomas Huxley, one of the small group with whom Darwin had shared his theory before publication, emerged as the main public champion of .
He wrote a favourable review of "Origin" in The Times in December 1859, along with several other articles and delivered a lecture at the Royal Institution in February .He wrote a favourable review of "Origin" in The Times in December 1859, along with several other articles and delivered a lecture at the Royal Institution in February .
The reaction of many orthodox churchmen was hostile, but their attention was diverted in February 1860 by a much greater furore over the publication of Essays and Reviews by seven liberal .The reaction of many orthodox churchmen was hostile, but their attention was diverted in February 1860 by a much greater furore over the publication of Essays and Reviews by seven liberal .
Amongst them, the Reverend Baden Powell had already praised evolutionary ideas, and in his essay he commended "Mr. Darwin's masterly volume" for substantiating "the grand principle of the self evolving powers of ".Amongst them, the Reverend Baden Powell had already praised evolutionary ideas, and in his essay he commended "Mr. Darwin's masterly volume" for substantiating "the grand principle of the self evolving powers of ".
Next, Henslow called upon Admiral Robert FitzRoy, who had been Darwin's captain and companion on the voyage of the Beagle twenty five years .Next, Henslow called upon Admiral Robert FitzRoy, who had been Darwin's captain and companion on the voyage of the Beagle twenty five years .
FitzRoy denounced Darwin's book and, "lifting an immense Bible first with both hands and afterwards with one hand over his head, solemnly implored the audience to believe God rather than ".FitzRoy denounced Darwin's book and, "lifting an immense Bible first with both hands and afterwards with one hand over his head, solemnly implored the audience to believe God rather than ".
He was believed to have said: "I believe that this is the Truth, and had I known then what I know now, I would not have taken him [Darwin] aboard the ."He was believed to have said: "I believe that this is the Truth, and had I known then what I know now, I would not have taken him [Darwin] aboard the ."
The last speaker of the day was .The last speaker of the day was .
According to his own account, it was he and not Huxley who delivered the most effective reply to Wilberforce's arguments: "Sam was shut up —had not one word to say in reply, and the meeting was dissolved ".According to his own account, it was he and not Huxley who delivered the most effective reply to Wilberforce's arguments: "Sam was shut up —had not one word to say in reply, and the meeting was dissolved ".
Ruse claims that "everybody enjoyed himself immensely and all went cheerfully off to dinner together ".Ruse claims that "everybody enjoyed himself immensely and all went cheerfully off to dinner together ".
It is said that during the debate, two Cambridge dons happened to be standing near Wilberforce, one of whom was Henry Fawcett, the recently blinded .It is said that during the debate, two Cambridge dons happened to be standing near Wilberforce, one of whom was Henry Fawcett, the recently blinded .
Fawcett was asked whether he thought the bishop had actually read the Origin of .Fawcett was asked whether he thought the bishop had actually read the Origin of .
"Oh no, I would swear he has never read a word of it", Fawcett reportedly replied ."Oh no, I would swear he has never read a word of it", Fawcett reportedly replied .
Wilberforce swung round to him scowling, ready to recriminate, but stepped back and bit his tongue on noting that the protagonist was the blind .Wilberforce swung round to him scowling, ready to recriminate, but stepped back and bit his tongue on noting that the protagonist was the blind .
Notably, all three major participants felt they had had the best of the .Notably, all three major participants felt they had had the best of the .
Wilberforce wrote that, "On Saturday Professor Henslow called on me by name to address the Section on Darwin's .Wilberforce wrote that, "On Saturday Professor Henslow called on me by name to address the Section on Darwin's .
So I could not escape and had quite a long fight with .So I could not escape and had quite a long fight with .
I think I thoroughly beat ."I think I thoroughly beat ."
Huxley claimed "[I was] the most popular man in Oxford for a full four & twenty hours ."Huxley claimed "[I was] the most popular man in Oxford for a full four & twenty hours ."
Hooker wrote that "I have been congratulated and thanked by the blackest coats and whitest stocks in ."Hooker wrote that "I have been congratulated and thanked by the blackest coats and whitest stocks in ."
Both sides immediately claimed victory, but the majority opinion has always been that the debate represented a major victory for the .Both sides immediately claimed victory, but the majority opinion has always been that the debate represented a major victory for the .
In his speech to open the annual event, the President of the Association (Lord Wrottesley) concluded his talk by saying "Let us ever apply ourselves to the task, feeling assured that the more we thus exercise, and by exercising improve our intellectual faculties, the more worthy shall we be, the better shall we be fitted to come nearer to our ."In his speech to open the annual event, the President of the Association (Lord Wrottesley) concluded his talk by saying "Let us ever apply ourselves to the task, feeling assured that the more we thus exercise, and by exercising improve our intellectual faculties, the more worthy shall we be, the better shall we be fitted to come nearer to our ."
Therefore, a case could be made for saying that for the many clerics in the audience, the underlying conflict was between traditional Anglicanism (Wilberforce) and liberal Anglicanism (Essays and ).Therefore, a case could be made for saying that for the many clerics in the audience, the underlying conflict was between traditional Anglicanism (Wilberforce) and liberal Anglicanism (Essays and ).
On the other hand, Oxford academic Dr Diane Purkiss says the debate "was really the first time Christianity had ever been asked to square off against science in a public forum in the whole of its ".On the other hand, Oxford academic Dr Diane Purkiss says the debate "was really the first time Christianity had ever been asked to square off against science in a public forum in the whole of its ".
and it is often regarded as a key moment in the acceptance of .and it is often regarded as a key moment in the acceptance of .
However, at the time it received only a few passing references in newspapers, and Brooke argues that "the event almost completely disappeared from public awareness until it was resurrected in the 1890s as an appropriate tribute to a recently deceased hero of scientific ".However, at the time it received only a few passing references in newspapers, and Brooke argues that "the event almost completely disappeared from public awareness until it was resurrected in the 1890s as an appropriate tribute to a recently deceased hero of scientific ".