Introduction
Responses to Charles Darwin's 1859 book The immediate reactions, from November 1859 to April 1861, to On the Origin of Species, the book in which Charles Darwin described evolution by natural selection, included international debate, though the heat of controversy was less than that over earlier works such as Vestiges of .Responses to Charles Darwin's 1859 book The immediate reactions, from November 1859 to April 1861, to On the Origin of Species, the book in which Charles Darwin described evolution by natural selection, included international debate, though the heat of controversy was less than that over earlier works such as Vestiges of .
Darwin monitored the debate closely, cheering on Thomas Henry Huxley's battles with Richard Owen to remove clerical domination of the scientific .Darwin monitored the debate closely, cheering on Thomas Henry Huxley's battles with Richard Owen to remove clerical domination of the scientific .
While Darwin's illness kept him away from the public debates, he read eagerly about them and mustered support through .While Darwin's illness kept him away from the public debates, he read eagerly about them and mustered support through .
Religious views were mixed, with the Church of England's scientific establishment reacting against the book, while liberal Anglicans strongly supported Darwin's natural selection as an instrument of God's .Religious views were mixed, with the Church of England's scientific establishment reacting against the book, while liberal Anglicans strongly supported Darwin's natural selection as an instrument of God's .
Religious controversy was soon diverted by the publication of Essays and Reviews and debate over the higher .Religious controversy was soon diverted by the publication of Essays and Reviews and debate over the higher .
The most famous confrontation took place at the public 1860 Oxford evolution debate during a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, when the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce argued against Darwin's .The most famous confrontation took place at the public 1860 Oxford evolution debate during a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, when the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce argued against Darwin's .
In the ensuing debate Joseph Hooker argued strongly in favor of Darwinian .In the ensuing debate Joseph Hooker argued strongly in favor of Darwinian .
Thomas Huxley's support of evolution was so intense that the media and public nicknamed him "Darwin's ".Thomas Huxley's support of evolution was so intense that the media and public nicknamed him "Darwin's ".
Huxley became the fiercest defender of the evolutionary theory on the Victorian .Huxley became the fiercest defender of the evolutionary theory on the Victorian .
Both sides came away feeling victorious, but Huxley went on to depict the debate as pivotal in a struggle between religion and science and used Darwinism to campaign against the authority of the clergy in education, as well as daringly advocating the "Ape Origin of ".Both sides came away feeling victorious, but Huxley went on to depict the debate as pivotal in a struggle between religion and science and used Darwinism to campaign against the authority of the clergy in education, as well as daringly advocating the "Ape Origin of ".
Background
Darwin's ideas developed rapidly after returning from the Voyage of the Beagle in .Darwin's ideas developed rapidly after returning from the Voyage of the Beagle in .
By December 1838, he had developed the basic principles of his .By December 1838, he had developed the basic principles of his .
At that time, ideas about the transmutation of species were associated with radical political ideas of the Age of Enlightenment and the French Revolution, and some people, such as Darwin's old instructor Robert Edmond Grant had been ridiculed and marginalized by members of the scientific establishment such as Richard Owen for advocating .At that time, ideas about the transmutation of species were associated with radical political ideas of the Age of Enlightenment and the French Revolution, and some people, such as Darwin's old instructor Robert Edmond Grant had been ridiculed and marginalized by members of the scientific establishment such as Richard Owen for advocating .
Darwin was conscious of the need to answer all likely objections before .Darwin was conscious of the need to answer all likely objections before .
While he continued with research, he had an immense amount of work in hand analyzing and publishing findings from the Beagle expedition, and was repeatedly delayed by .While he continued with research, he had an immense amount of work in hand analyzing and publishing findings from the Beagle expedition, and was repeatedly delayed by .
The Natural history, especially in Britain, at that time was dominated by proponents of natural theology, who saw their science as revealing God's plan, and many of whom, like Darwin's professors Adam Sedgwick and John Stevens Henslow, were ordained clergy in the Church of .The Natural history, especially in Britain, at that time was dominated by proponents of natural theology, who saw their science as revealing God's plan, and many of whom, like Darwin's professors Adam Sedgwick and John Stevens Henslow, were ordained clergy in the Church of .
Darwin found three close .Darwin found three close .
The eminent geologist Charles Lyell, whose books had influenced the young Darwin during the Voyage of the Beagle, befriended Darwin who he saw as a supporter of his ideas of gradual geological processes with continuing divine creation of .The eminent geologist Charles Lyell, whose books had influenced the young Darwin during the Voyage of the Beagle, befriended Darwin who he saw as a supporter of his ideas of gradual geological processes with continuing divine creation of .
By the 1840s Darwin became friends with the young botanist Joseph Dalton Hooker who had followed his father into the science, and after going on a survey voyage used his contacts to eventually find a .By the 1840s Darwin became friends with the young botanist Joseph Dalton Hooker who had followed his father into the science, and after going on a survey voyage used his contacts to eventually find a .
In the 1850s Darwin met Thomas Huxley, an ambitious naturalist who had returned from a long survey trip but lacked the family wealth or contacts to find a career and who joined the progressive group around Herbert Spencer looking to make science a profession, freed from the .In the 1850s Darwin met Thomas Huxley, an ambitious naturalist who had returned from a long survey trip but lacked the family wealth or contacts to find a career and who joined the progressive group around Herbert Spencer looking to make science a profession, freed from the .
This was also a time of intense conflict over religious morality in England, where evangelicalism led to increasing professionalism of clerics who had previously been expected to act as country gentlemen with wide interests, but now were seriously focussed on expanded religious .This was also a time of intense conflict over religious morality in England, where evangelicalism led to increasing professionalism of clerics who had previously been expected to act as country gentlemen with wide interests, but now were seriously focussed on expanded religious .
A new orthodoxy proclaimed the virtues of truth but also inculcated beliefs that the Bible should be read literally and that religious doubt was in itself sinful so should not be .A new orthodoxy proclaimed the virtues of truth but also inculcated beliefs that the Bible should be read literally and that religious doubt was in itself sinful so should not be .
Science was also becoming professional and a series of discoveries cast doubt on literal interpretations of the Bible and the honesty of those denying the .Science was also becoming professional and a series of discoveries cast doubt on literal interpretations of the Bible and the honesty of those denying the .
A series of crises erupted with fierce debate and criticism over issues such as George Combe's The Constitution of Man and the anonymous Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation which converted vast popular audiences to the belief that natural laws controlled the development of nature and .A series of crises erupted with fierce debate and criticism over issues such as George Combe's The Constitution of Man and the anonymous Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation which converted vast popular audiences to the belief that natural laws controlled the development of nature and .
German higher criticism questioned the Bible as a historical document in contrast to the evangelical creed that every word was divinely .German higher criticism questioned the Bible as a historical document in contrast to the evangelical creed that every word was divinely .
Dissident clergymen even began questioning accepted premises of Christian morality, and Benjamin Jowett's 1855 commentary on St. Paul brought a storm of .Dissident clergymen even began questioning accepted premises of Christian morality, and Benjamin Jowett's 1855 commentary on St. Paul brought a storm of .
By September 1854 Darwin's other books reached a stage where he was able to turn his attention fully to Species, and from this point he was working to publish his .By September 1854 Darwin's other books reached a stage where he was able to turn his attention fully to Species, and from this point he was working to publish his .
On 18 June 1858 he received a parcel from Alfred Russel Wallace enclosing about twenty pages describing an evolutionary mechanism that was similar to Darwin's own .On 18 June 1858 he received a parcel from Alfred Russel Wallace enclosing about twenty pages describing an evolutionary mechanism that was similar to Darwin's own .
Darwin put matters in the hands of his friends Lyell and Hooker, who agreed on a joint presentation to the Linnean Society on 1 July .Darwin put matters in the hands of his friends Lyell and Hooker, who agreed on a joint presentation to the Linnean Society on 1 July .
Their papers were entitled, collectively, On the Tendency of Species to form Varieties; and on the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of .Their papers were entitled, collectively, On the Tendency of Species to form Varieties; and on the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of .
Publication of The Origin of Species
Darwin now worked on an "abstract" trimmed from his Natural Selection .Darwin now worked on an "abstract" trimmed from his Natural Selection .
The publisher John Murray agreed the title as On the Origin of Species through Natural Selection and the book went on sale to the trade on 22 November .The publisher John Murray agreed the title as On the Origin of Species through Natural Selection and the book went on sale to the trade on 22 November .
The stock of 1,250 copies was oversubscribed, and Darwin, still at Ilkley spa town, began corrections for a second .The stock of 1,250 copies was oversubscribed, and Darwin, still at Ilkley spa town, began corrections for a second .
The novelist Charles Kingsley, a Christian socialist country rector, sent him a letter of praise: "It awes me if you be right I must give up much that I have believed", it was "just as noble a conception of Deity, to believe that He created primal forms capable of self development as to believe that He required a fresh act of intervention to supply the lacunas which he himself had ."The novelist Charles Kingsley, a Christian socialist country rector, sent him a letter of praise: "It awes me if you be right I must give up much that I have believed", it was "just as noble a conception of Deity, to believe that He created primal forms capable of self development as to believe that He required a fresh act of intervention to supply the lacunas which he himself had ."
Darwin added these lines to the last chapter, with attribution to "a celebrated author and ".Darwin added these lines to the last chapter, with attribution to "a celebrated author and ".
First reviews
The reviewers were less .The reviewers were less .
Four days before publication, a review in the authoritative Athenaeum (by John Leifchild, published anonymously, as was the custom at that time) was quick to pick out the unstated implications of "men from monkeys" already controversial from Vestiges, saw snubs to theologians, summing up Darwin's "creed" as man "was born yesterday – he will perish tomorrow" and concluded that "The work deserves attention, and will, we have no doubt, meet with .Four days before publication, a review in the authoritative Athenaeum (by John Leifchild, published anonymously, as was the custom at that time) was quick to pick out the unstated implications of "men from monkeys" already controversial from Vestiges, saw snubs to theologians, summing up Darwin's "creed" as man "was born yesterday – he will perish tomorrow" and concluded that "The work deserves attention, and will, we have no doubt, meet with .
Scientific naturalists will take up the author upon his own peculiar ground; and there will we imagine be a severe struggle for at least theoretical .Scientific naturalists will take up the author upon his own peculiar ground; and there will we imagine be a severe struggle for at least theoretical .
Theologians will say —and they have a right to be heard—Why construct another elaborate theory to exclude Deity from renewed acts of ?Theologians will say —and they have a right to be heard—Why construct another elaborate theory to exclude Deity from renewed acts of ?
Why not at once admit that new species were introduced by the Creative energy of the ?Why not at once admit that new species were introduced by the Creative energy of the ?
Why not accept direct interference, rather than evolutions of law, and needlessly indirect or remote ?Why not accept direct interference, rather than evolutions of law, and needlessly indirect or remote ?
Having introduced the author and his work, we must leave them to the mercies of the Divinity Hall, the College, the Lecture Room, and the ."Having introduced the author and his work, we must leave them to the mercies of the Divinity Hall, the College, the Lecture Room, and the ."
At Ilkley, Darwin raged "But the manner in which he drags in immortality, & sets the Priests at me, & leaves me to their mercies, is .At Ilkley, Darwin raged "But the manner in which he drags in immortality, & sets the Priests at me, & leaves me to their mercies, is .
He would on no account burn me; but he will get the wood ready and tell the black beasts how to catch ."He would on no account burn me; but he will get the wood ready and tell the black beasts how to catch ."
Darwin sprained an ankle and his health worsened, as he wrote to friends it was ".Darwin sprained an ankle and his health worsened, as he wrote to friends it was ".
Hooker had been "converted", Lyell was "absolutely gloating" and Huxley wrote "with such tremendous praise", advising that he was sharpening his "beak and claws" to disembowel "the curs who will bark and ".Hooker had been "converted", Lyell was "absolutely gloating" and Huxley wrote "with such tremendous praise", advising that he was sharpening his "beak and claws" to disembowel "the curs who will bark and ".
First response
Richard Owen had been the first to respond to the complimentary copies, courteously claiming that he had long believed that "existing influences" were responsible for the "ordained" birth of .Richard Owen had been the first to respond to the complimentary copies, courteously claiming that he had long believed that "existing influences" were responsible for the "ordained" birth of .
Darwin now had long talks with him, and told Lyell that "Under garb of great civility, he was inclined to be most bitter & sneering against .Darwin now had long talks with him, and told Lyell that "Under garb of great civility, he was inclined to be most bitter & sneering against .
Yet I infer from several expressions, that at bottom he goes immense way with ."Yet I infer from several expressions, that at bottom he goes immense way with ."
Owen was furious at being included among those defending immutability of species, and in effect said that the book offered the best explanation "ever published of the manner of formation of species", though he did not agree with it in all .Owen was furious at being included among those defending immutability of species, and in effect said that the book offered the best explanation "ever published of the manner of formation of species", though he did not agree with it in all .
He still had the gravest doubts that transmutation would bestialise .He still had the gravest doubts that transmutation would bestialise .
It appears that Darwin had assured Owen that he was looking at everything as resulting from designed laws, which Owen interpreted as showing a shared belief in "Creative ".It appears that Darwin had assured Owen that he was looking at everything as resulting from designed laws, which Owen interpreted as showing a shared belief in "Creative ".
Darwin had already made his views clearer to others, telling Lyell that if each step in evolution was providentially planned, the whole procedure would be a miracle and natural selection .Darwin had already made his views clearer to others, telling Lyell that if each step in evolution was providentially planned, the whole procedure would be a miracle and natural selection .
He had also sent a copy to John Herschel, and on 10 December he told Lyell of having "heard by round about channel that Herschel says my Book "is the law of higgledy piggledy".– What this exactly means I do not know, but it is evidently very contemptuous.– If true this is great blow & ."He had also sent a copy to John Herschel, and on 10 December he told Lyell of having "heard by round about channel that Herschel says my Book "is the law of higgledy piggledy".– What this exactly means I do not know, but it is evidently very contemptuous.– If true this is great blow & ."
Geological time
It was known that the geologic time scale was "incomprehensibly vast", if .It was known that the geologic time scale was "incomprehensibly vast", if .
From 1848 Darwin discussed data with Andrew Ramsay, who had said "it is vain to attempt to measure the duration of even small portions of geological ."From 1848 Darwin discussed data with Andrew Ramsay, who had said "it is vain to attempt to measure the duration of even small portions of geological ."
A chapter of Lyell's Principles of Geology described the enormous amount of erosion involved in forming the .A chapter of Lyell's Principles of Geology described the enormous amount of erosion involved in forming the .
To demonstrate the time available for natural selection to operate, Darwin drew on Lyell's example and Ramsay's data in chapter 9 of On the Origin of Species to estimate that erosion of the Weald's layered dome of Lower Cretaceous rocks "must have required 306,662,400 years; or say three hundred million ."To demonstrate the time available for natural selection to operate, Darwin drew on Lyell's example and Ramsay's data in chapter 9 of On the Origin of Species to estimate that erosion of the Weald's layered dome of Lower Cretaceous rocks "must have required 306,662,400 years; or say three hundred million ."
The "necessary corrections" Darwin made to his drafts for the second edition of the Origin were based on comments from others, particularly Lyell, and added a caveat suggesting a faster rate of erosion of the Weald: "perhaps it would be safer to allow two or three inches per century, and this would reduce the number of years to one hundred and fifty or one hundred million ."The "necessary corrections" Darwin made to his drafts for the second edition of the Origin were based on comments from others, particularly Lyell, and added a caveat suggesting a faster rate of erosion of the Weald: "perhaps it would be safer to allow two or three inches per century, and this would reduce the number of years to one hundred and fifty or one hundred million ."
Copies of the second edition were advertised as ready on 24 December, in advance of official publication on 7 January .Copies of the second edition were advertised as ready on 24 December, in advance of official publication on 7 January .
The Saturday Review of 24 December 1859 strongly criticised the methodology of Darwin's .The Saturday Review of 24 December 1859 strongly criticised the methodology of Darwin's .
On 3 January 1860, Darwin wrote to Hooker about it: "Some of the remarks about the lapse of years are very good, & the Reviewer gives me some good & well deserved raps,—confound it I am sorry to confess the .On 3 January 1860, Darwin wrote to Hooker about it: "Some of the remarks about the lapse of years are very good, & the Reviewer gives me some good & well deserved raps,—confound it I am sorry to confess the .
But it does not at all concern main ."But it does not at all concern main ."
A day later, he said to Lyell "You saw I suppose Saturday Review: argument confined to Geology, but has given me some perfectly just & severe raps on ."A day later, he said to Lyell "You saw I suppose Saturday Review: argument confined to Geology, but has given me some perfectly just & severe raps on ."
In the third edition published on 30 April 1861, Darwin cited the Saturday Review article as reason to remove his calculation .In the third edition published on 30 April 1861, Darwin cited the Saturday Review article as reason to remove his calculation .
Friendly reviews
The December 1859 review in the British Unitarian National Review was written by Darwin's old friend William Carpenter, who was clear that only a world of "order, continuity, and progress" befitted an Omnipotent Deity and that "any theological objection" to a species of slug or a breed of dog deriving from a previous one was "simply absurd" .The December 1859 review in the British Unitarian National Review was written by Darwin's old friend William Carpenter, who was clear that only a world of "order, continuity, and progress" befitted an Omnipotent Deity and that "any theological objection" to a species of slug or a breed of dog deriving from a previous one was "simply absurd" .
He touched on human evolution, satisfied that the struggle for existence tended "inevitably towards the progressive exaltation of the races engaged in ".He touched on human evolution, satisfied that the struggle for existence tended "inevitably towards the progressive exaltation of the races engaged in ".
On Boxing Day (26 December) The Times carried an anonymous .On Boxing Day (26 December) The Times carried an anonymous .
The staff reviewer, "as innocent of any knowledge of science as a babe", gave the task to Huxley, leading Darwin to ask his friend how "did you influence Jupiter Olympus and make him give three and a half columns to pure ?The staff reviewer, "as innocent of any knowledge of science as a babe", gave the task to Huxley, leading Darwin to ask his friend how "did you influence Jupiter Olympus and make him give three and a half columns to pure ?
The old fogies will think the world will come to an ."The old fogies will think the world will come to an ."
Darwin treasured the piece more than "a dozen reviews in common periodicals", but noted "Upon my life I am sorry for Owen he will be so d—d savage, for credit given to any other man, I strongly suspect, is in his eyes so much credit robbed from .Darwin treasured the piece more than "a dozen reviews in common periodicals", but noted "Upon my life I am sorry for Owen he will be so d—d savage, for credit given to any other man, I strongly suspect, is in his eyes so much credit robbed from .
Science is so narrow a field, it is clear there ought to be only one cock of the !".Science is so narrow a field, it is clear there ought to be only one cock of the !".
Hooker also wrote a favourable review, which appeared at the end of December in the Gardener's Chronicle and treated the theory as an extension of horticultural .Hooker also wrote a favourable review, which appeared at the end of December in the Gardener's Chronicle and treated the theory as an extension of horticultural .
Clerical concern, atheist enthusiasm
In his lofty position at the head of Natural History Collections at the British Museum, Owen received numerous complaints about the .In his lofty position at the head of Natural History Collections at the British Museum, Owen received numerous complaints about the .
The .
Adam Sedgwick, geologist at the University of Cambridge who had taken Darwin on his first geology field trip, could not see the point in a world without .Adam Sedgwick, geologist at the University of Cambridge who had taken Darwin on his first geology field trip, could not see the point in a world without .
The missionary David Livingstone could see no struggle for existence on the African .The missionary David Livingstone could see no struggle for existence on the African .
Jeffries Wyman at Harvard saw no truth in chance .Jeffries Wyman at Harvard saw no truth in chance .
The most enthusiastic response came from atheists, with Hewett Watson hailing Darwin as the "greatest revolutionist in natural history of this ".The most enthusiastic response came from atheists, with Hewett Watson hailing Darwin as the "greatest revolutionist in natural history of this ".
The 68 year old Robert Edmund Grant, who had shown him the study of invertebrates when Darwin was a student at the University of Edinburgh and who was still teaching Lamarckian evolution weekly at University College London, brought out a small book on classification dedicated to Darwin: "With one fell sweep of the wand of truth, you have now scattered to the winds the pestilential vapours accumulated by 'species '."The 68 year old Robert Edmund Grant, who had shown him the study of invertebrates when Darwin was a student at the University of Edinburgh and who was still teaching Lamarckian evolution weekly at University College London, brought out a small book on classification dedicated to Darwin: "With one fell sweep of the wand of truth, you have now scattered to the winds the pestilential vapours accumulated by 'species '."
Widespread interest
In January 1860, Darwin told Lyell of a reported incident at Waterloo Bridge Station: "I never till to day realised that it was getting widely distributed; for in a letter from a lady today to Emma, she says she heard a man enquiring for it at Railway !!!In January 1860, Darwin told Lyell of a reported incident at Waterloo Bridge Station: "I never till to day realised that it was getting widely distributed; for in a letter from a lady today to Emma, she says she heard a man enquiring for it at Railway !!!
at Waterloo Bridge; & the Bookseller said that he had none till new .at Waterloo Bridge; & the Bookseller said that he had none till new .
was out.— The Bookseller said he had not read it but had heard it was a very remarkable !!!"was out.— The Bookseller said he had not read it but had heard it was a very remarkable !!!"
Asa Gray in the United States
In December 1859 the botanist Asa Gray negotiated with a Boston publisher for publication of an authorised American version, however, he learnt that two New York publishing firms were already planning to exploit the absence of international copyright to print .In December 1859 the botanist Asa Gray negotiated with a Boston publisher for publication of an authorised American version, however, he learnt that two New York publishing firms were already planning to exploit the absence of international copyright to print .
Darwin wrote in January, "I never dreamed of my Book being so successful with general readers: I believe I should have laughed at the idea of sending the sheets to ."Darwin wrote in January, "I never dreamed of my Book being so successful with general readers: I believe I should have laughed at the idea of sending the sheets to ."
and asked Gray to keep any .
Gray managed to negotiate a 5 per cent royalty with Appleton's of New York, who got their edition out in mid January, and the other two .Gray managed to negotiate a 5 per cent royalty with Appleton's of New York, who got their edition out in mid January, and the other two .
In a May letter Darwin mentioned a print run of 2,500 copies, but it is not clear if this was the first printing alone as there were four that .In a May letter Darwin mentioned a print run of 2,500 copies, but it is not clear if this was the first printing alone as there were four that .
When sending his Historical preface and corrections for the American edition in February, Darwin thanked Asa Gray for his comments, as "a Review from a man, who is not an entire convert, if fair & moderately favourable, is in all respects the best kind of .When sending his Historical preface and corrections for the American edition in February, Darwin thanked Asa Gray for his comments, as "a Review from a man, who is not an entire convert, if fair & moderately favourable, is in all respects the best kind of .
About weak points I .About weak points I .
The eye to this day gives me a cold shudder, but when I think of the fine known gradations, my reason tells me I ought to conquer the cold ."The eye to this day gives me a cold shudder, but when I think of the fine known gradations, my reason tells me I ought to conquer the cold ."
In April he continued, "It is curious that I remember well time when the thought of the eye made me cold all over, but I have got over this stage of the complaint, & now small trifling particulars of structure often make me very .In April he continued, "It is curious that I remember well time when the thought of the eye made me cold all over, but I have got over this stage of the complaint, & now small trifling particulars of structure often make me very .
The sight of a feather in a peacock's tail, whenever I gaze at it, makes me !"The sight of a feather in a peacock's tail, whenever I gaze at it, makes me !"
A month later Darwin emphasised that he was bewildered by the theological aspects and "had no intention to write atheistically, but could not see, as plainly as others do, & as I shd wish to do, evidence of design & beneficence on all sides of .A month later Darwin emphasised that he was bewildered by the theological aspects and "had no intention to write atheistically, but could not see, as plainly as others do, & as I shd wish to do, evidence of design & beneficence on all sides of .
There seems to me too much misery in the .There seems to me too much misery in the .
I cannot persuade myself that a beneficent and omnipotent God would have designedly created the Ichneumonidae with the express intention of their feeding within the living bodies of caterpillars" – expressing his particular revulsion at the Ichneumonidae family of parasitic wasps that lay their eggs in the larvae and pupae of other insects so that their parasitoid young have a ready source of .I cannot persuade myself that a beneficent and omnipotent God would have designedly created the Ichneumonidae with the express intention of their feeding within the living bodies of caterpillars" – expressing his particular revulsion at the Ichneumonidae family of parasitic wasps that lay their eggs in the larvae and pupae of other insects so that their parasitoid young have a ready source of .
He therefore could not believe in the necessity of design, but rather than attributing the wonders of the universe to brute force was "inclined to look at everything as resulting from designed laws, with the details, whether good or bad, left to the working out of what we may call .He therefore could not believe in the necessity of design, but rather than attributing the wonders of the universe to brute force was "inclined to look at everything as resulting from designed laws, with the details, whether good or bad, left to the working out of what we may call .
Not that this notion at all satisfies .Not that this notion at all satisfies .
I feel most deeply that the whole subject is too profound for the human .I feel most deeply that the whole subject is too profound for the human .
A dog might as well speculate on the mind of Newton" – referring to Isaac .A dog might as well speculate on the mind of Newton" – referring to Isaac .
Erasmus and Martineau
Darwin's brother Erasmus reported on 23 November that their cousin Henry Holland was reading the book and in "a dreadful state of indecision", sure that explaining the eye would be "utterly impossible", but after reading it "he hummed & hawed & perhaps it was partly ".Darwin's brother Erasmus reported on 23 November that their cousin Henry Holland was reading the book and in "a dreadful state of indecision", sure that explaining the eye would be "utterly impossible", but after reading it "he hummed & hawed & perhaps it was partly ".
Erasmus himself thought it "the most interesting book I ever read ", and sent a copy to his old flame Miss Harriet Martineau who, at 58, was still reviewing from her home in the Lake .Erasmus himself thought it "the most interesting book I ever read ", and sent a copy to his old flame Miss Harriet Martineau who, at 58, was still reviewing from her home in the Lake .
Martineau sent her thanks, adding that she had previously praised "the quality & conduct of your brother's mind, but it is an unspeakable satisfaction to see here the full manifestation of its earnestness & simplicity, its sagacity, its industry, & the patient power by .Martineau sent her thanks, adding that she had previously praised "the quality & conduct of your brother's mind, but it is an unspeakable satisfaction to see here the full manifestation of its earnestness & simplicity, its sagacity, its industry, & the patient power by .
it has collected such a mass of facts, to transmute them by such sagacious treatment into such portentious .it has collected such a mass of facts, to transmute them by such sagacious treatment into such portentious .
I .I .
much like to know how large a proportion of our scientific men believe he has found a sound ."much like to know how large a proportion of our scientific men believe he has found a sound ."
Writing to her fellow Malthusian (and atheist) George Holyoake she enthused, "What a book it !Writing to her fellow Malthusian (and atheist) George Holyoake she enthused, "What a book it !
– overthrowing (if true) revealed Religion on the one hand, & Natural (as far as Final Causes & Design are concerned) on the .– overthrowing (if true) revealed Religion on the one hand, & Natural (as far as Final Causes & Design are concerned) on the .
The range & mass of knowledge take away one's ."The range & mass of knowledge take away one's ."
To Fanny Wedgwood she wrote, "I rather regret that C. D. went out of his way two or three times to speak of "The Creator" in the popular sense of the First Cause His subject is the 'Origin of Species' & not the origin of Organisation; & it seems a needless mischief to have opened the latter speculation at all – There !To Fanny Wedgwood she wrote, "I rather regret that C. D. went out of his way two or three times to speak of "The Creator" in the popular sense of the First Cause His subject is the 'Origin of Species' & not the origin of Organisation; & it seems a needless mischief to have opened the latter speculation at all – There !
I have delivered my ."I have delivered my ."
Clerical reaction
The .
Adam Sedgwick had received his copy "with more pain than ."Adam Sedgwick had received his copy "with more pain than ."
Without Creation showing divine love, "humanity, to my mind, would suffer a damage that might brutalise it, and sink the human race " He indicated that unless Darwin accepted God's revelation in nature and scripture, Sedgwick would not meet Darwin in heaven, a sentiment that upset .Without Creation showing divine love, "humanity, to my mind, would suffer a damage that might brutalise it, and sink the human race " He indicated that unless Darwin accepted God's revelation in nature and scripture, Sedgwick would not meet Darwin in heaven, a sentiment that upset .
The .
John Stevens Henslow, the botany professor whose natural history course Charles had joined thirty years earlier, gave faint praise to the Origin as "a stumble in the right direction" but distanced himself from its conclusions, "a question past our finding out " The Anglican establishment predominantly opposed .John Stevens Henslow, the botany professor whose natural history course Charles had joined thirty years earlier, gave faint praise to the Origin as "a stumble in the right direction" but distanced himself from its conclusions, "a question past our finding out " The Anglican establishment predominantly opposed .
Palmerston, who became Prime Minister in June 1859, mooted Darwin's name to Queen Victoria as a candidate for the Honours List with the prospect of a .Palmerston, who became Prime Minister in June 1859, mooted Darwin's name to Queen Victoria as a candidate for the Honours List with the prospect of a .
While Prince Albert supported the idea, after the publication of the Origin Queen Victoria's ecclesiastical advisers, including the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce, dissented and the request was .While Prince Albert supported the idea, after the publication of the Origin Queen Victoria's ecclesiastical advisers, including the Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce, dissented and the request was .
Some Anglicans were more in favour, and Huxley reported of Kingsley that "He is an excellent Darwinian to begin with, and told me a capital story of his reply to Lady Aylesbury who expressed astonishment at his favouring such a heresy – 'What can be more delightful to me Lady Aylesbury, than to know that your Ladyship & myself sprang from the same toad .'Some Anglicans were more in favour, and Huxley reported of Kingsley that "He is an excellent Darwinian to begin with, and told me a capital story of his reply to Lady Aylesbury who expressed astonishment at his favouring such a heresy – 'What can be more delightful to me Lady Aylesbury, than to know that your Ladyship & myself sprang from the same toad .'
Whereby the frivolous old woman shut up, in doubt whether she was being chaffed or adored for her ."Whereby the frivolous old woman shut up, in doubt whether she was being chaffed or adored for her ."
There was no official comment from the Vatican for several decades, but in 1860 a council of the German Catholic bishops pronounced that the belief that "man as regards his body, emerged finally from the spontaneous continuous change of imperfect nature to the more perfect, is clearly opposed to Sacred Scripture and to the ."There was no official comment from the Vatican for several decades, but in 1860 a council of the German Catholic bishops pronounced that the belief that "man as regards his body, emerged finally from the spontaneous continuous change of imperfect nature to the more perfect, is clearly opposed to Sacred Scripture and to the ."
This defined the range of official Catholic discussion of evolution, which has remained almost exclusively concerned with human .This defined the range of official Catholic discussion of evolution, which has remained almost exclusively concerned with human .
Geological time and Phillips
Darwin's had estimated that erosion of the Weald would take 300 million years, but in the second edition of On the Origin of Species published on 7 January 1860 he accepted that it would be safer to allow 150 million to 200 million .Darwin's had estimated that erosion of the Weald would take 300 million years, but in the second edition of On the Origin of Species published on 7 January 1860 he accepted that it would be safer to allow 150 million to 200 million .
Geologists knew the earth was ancient, but had felt unable to put realistic figures on the duration of past geological .Geologists knew the earth was ancient, but had felt unable to put realistic figures on the duration of past geological .
Darwin's book provided a new impetus to quantifying geological .Darwin's book provided a new impetus to quantifying geological .
His most prominent critic, John Phillips, had investigated how temperatures increased with depth in the 1830s, and was convinced that, contrary to Lyell and Darwin's uniformitarianism, the Earth was cooling over the long .His most prominent critic, John Phillips, had investigated how temperatures increased with depth in the 1830s, and was convinced that, contrary to Lyell and Darwin's uniformitarianism, the Earth was cooling over the long .
Between 1838 and 1855 he tried various ways of quantifying the timing of stratified deposits, without .Between 1838 and 1855 he tried various ways of quantifying the timing of stratified deposits, without .
On 17 February 1860, Phillips used his presidential address to the Geological Society of London to accuse Darwin of "abuse of ".On 17 February 1860, Phillips used his presidential address to the Geological Society of London to accuse Darwin of "abuse of ".
He said 300 million years was an "inconceivable number" and that, depending on assumptions, erosion of the Weald could have taken anything from 12,000 years to at most 1,332,000 years, well below Darwin's .He said 300 million years was an "inconceivable number" and that, depending on assumptions, erosion of the Weald could have taken anything from 12,000 years to at most 1,332,000 years, well below Darwin's .
When giving the May 1860 Rede Lecture, Phillips produced his own first published estimates of the duration of the whole stratigraphic record, using rates of sedimentation to calculate it at around 96 million .When giving the May 1860 Rede Lecture, Phillips produced his own first published estimates of the duration of the whole stratigraphic record, using rates of sedimentation to calculate it at around 96 million .
Natural persecution
Most reviewers wrote with great respect, deferring to Darwin's eminent position in science though finding it hard to understand how natural selection could work without a divine .Most reviewers wrote with great respect, deferring to Darwin's eminent position in science though finding it hard to understand how natural selection could work without a divine .
There were hostile comments, at the start of May he commented to Lyell that he had "received in a Manchester Newspaper a rather a good squib, showing that I have proved 'might is right', & therefore that Napoleon is right & every cheating Tradesman is also ".There were hostile comments, at the start of May he commented to Lyell that he had "received in a Manchester Newspaper a rather a good squib, showing that I have proved 'might is right', & therefore that Napoleon is right & every cheating Tradesman is also ".
The Saturday Review reported that "The controversy excited by the appearance of Darwin's remarkable work on the Origin of Species has passed beyond the bounds of the study and lecture room into the drawing room and the public ."The Saturday Review reported that "The controversy excited by the appearance of Darwin's remarkable work on the Origin of Species has passed beyond the bounds of the study and lecture room into the drawing room and the public ."
The older generation of Darwin's tutors were rather negative, and later in May he told his cousin Fox that "the attacks have been falling thick & heavy on my now case hardened hide.— Sedgwick & Clarke opened regular battery on me lately at Cambridge .The older generation of Darwin's tutors were rather negative, and later in May he told his cousin Fox that "the attacks have been falling thick & heavy on my now case hardened hide.— Sedgwick & Clarke opened regular battery on me lately at Cambridge .
.
& dear old Henslow defended me in grand style, saying that my investigations were perfectly ."& dear old Henslow defended me in grand style, saying that my investigations were perfectly ."
While defending Darwin's honest motives and belief that "he was exalting & not debasing our views of a Creator, in attributing to him a power of imposing laws on the Organic World by which to do his work, as effectually as his laws imposed upon the inorganic had done it in the Mineral Kingdom", Henslow had not disguised his own opinion that "Darwin has pressed his hypothesis too ".While defending Darwin's honest motives and belief that "he was exalting & not debasing our views of a Creator, in attributing to him a power of imposing laws on the Organic World by which to do his work, as effectually as his laws imposed upon the inorganic had done it in the Mineral Kingdom", Henslow had not disguised his own opinion that "Darwin has pressed his hypothesis too ".
In June, Karl Marx saw the book as a "bitter satire" that showed "a basis in natural science for class struggle in history", in which "Darwin recognizes among beasts and plants his English ".In June, Karl Marx saw the book as a "bitter satire" that showed "a basis in natural science for class struggle in history", in which "Darwin recognizes among beasts and plants his English ".
Darwin remarked to Lyell, "I must be a very bad explainer Several Reviews, & several letters have shown me too clearly how little I am .Darwin remarked to Lyell, "I must be a very bad explainer Several Reviews, & several letters have shown me too clearly how little I am .
I suppose natural selection was bad term; but to change it now, I think, would make confusion worse .I suppose natural selection was bad term; but to change it now, I think, would make confusion worse .
Nor can I think of better; Natural preservation would not imply a preservation of particular varieties & would seem a truism; & would not bring man's & nature's selection under one point of .Nor can I think of better; Natural preservation would not imply a preservation of particular varieties & would seem a truism; & would not bring man's & nature's selection under one point of .
I can only hope by reiterated explanations finally to make matter ."I can only hope by reiterated explanations finally to make matter ."
It was too illegible for Lyell, and Darwin later apologised "I am utterly ashamed & groan over my hand .It was too illegible for Lyell, and Darwin later apologised "I am utterly ashamed & groan over my hand .
It was Natural .It was Natural .
Natural persecution is what the author ought to ."Natural persecution is what the author ought to ."
Essays and Reviews
Around February 1860 liberal theologians entered the fray, when seven produced a manifesto titled Essays and .Around February 1860 liberal theologians entered the fray, when seven produced a manifesto titled Essays and .
These Anglicans included Oxford professors, country clergymen, the headmaster of Rugby school and a .These Anglicans included Oxford professors, country clergymen, the headmaster of Rugby school and a .
Their declaration that miracles were irrational stirred up unprecedented anger, drawing much of the fire away from .Their declaration that miracles were irrational stirred up unprecedented anger, drawing much of the fire away from .
Essays sold 22,000 copies in two years, more than the Origin sold in twenty years, and sparked five years of increasingly polarised debate with books and pamphlets furiously contesting the .Essays sold 22,000 copies in two years, more than the Origin sold in twenty years, and sparked five years of increasingly polarised debate with books and pamphlets furiously contesting the .
The most scientific of the seven was the Reverend Baden Powell, who held the Savilian chair of geometry at the University of .The most scientific of the seven was the Reverend Baden Powell, who held the Savilian chair of geometry at the University of .
Referring to "Mr Darwin's masterly volume" and restating his argument that God is a lawgiver, miracles break the lawful edicts issued at Creation, therefore belief in miracles is atheistic, he wrote that the book "must soon bring about an entire revolution in opinion in favour of the grand principle of the self evolving powers of ."Referring to "Mr Darwin's masterly volume" and restating his argument that God is a lawgiver, miracles break the lawful edicts issued at Creation, therefore belief in miracles is atheistic, he wrote that the book "must soon bring about an entire revolution in opinion in favour of the grand principle of the self evolving powers of ."
He drew attacks, with Sedgwick accusing him of "greedily" adopting nonsense and Tory reviews saying he was joining "the infidel ".He drew attacks, with Sedgwick accusing him of "greedily" adopting nonsense and Tory reviews saying he was joining "the infidel ".
He would have been on the platform at the British Association debate, facing the bishop, but died of a heart attack on 11 .He would have been on the platform at the British Association debate, facing the bishop, but died of a heart attack on 11 .
The British Association debate
The most famous confrontation took place at a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science in Oxford on Saturday 30 June .The most famous confrontation took place at a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science in Oxford on Saturday 30 June .
While there was no formal debate organised on the issue, Professor John William Draper of New York University was to talk on Darwin and social progress at a routine "Botany and Zoology" .While there was no formal debate organised on the issue, Professor John William Draper of New York University was to talk on Darwin and social progress at a routine "Botany and Zoology" .
The new museum hall was crowded with clergy, undergraduates, Oxford dons and gentlewomen anticipating that Samuel Wilberforce, the Bishop of Oxford, would speak to repeat the savage trouncing he had given in 1847 to the Vestiges published anonymously by Robert .The new museum hall was crowded with clergy, undergraduates, Oxford dons and gentlewomen anticipating that Samuel Wilberforce, the Bishop of Oxford, would speak to repeat the savage trouncing he had given in 1847 to the Vestiges published anonymously by Robert .
Owen lodged with Wilberforce the night before, but Wilberforce would have been well prepared as he had just reviewed the Origin for the Tory Quarterly for a fee of .Owen lodged with Wilberforce the night before, but Wilberforce would have been well prepared as he had just reviewed the Origin for the Tory Quarterly for a fee of .
Huxley was not going to wait for the meeting, but met Chambers who accused him of "deserting them" and changed his .Huxley was not going to wait for the meeting, but met Chambers who accused him of "deserting them" and changed his .
Darwin was taking treatment at Dr. Lane's new hydropathic establishment at Sudbrooke Park, Petersham, near Richmond in .Darwin was taking treatment at Dr. Lane's new hydropathic establishment at Sudbrooke Park, Petersham, near Richmond in .
From Hooker's account, Draper " droned on for an hour", then for half an hour "Soapy Sam" Wilberforce replied with the eloquence that had earned him his .From Hooker's account, Draper " droned on for an hour", then for half an hour "Soapy Sam" Wilberforce replied with the eloquence that had earned him his .
This time the climate of opinion had changed and the ensuing debate was more evenly matched, with Hooker being particularly successful in defence of Darwin's .This time the climate of opinion had changed and the ensuing debate was more evenly matched, with Hooker being particularly successful in defence of Darwin's .
In response to what Huxley took as a jibe from Wilberforce as to whether it was on Huxley's grandfather's or grandmother's side that he was descended from an ape, Huxley made a reply which he later recalled as being that "[if asked] would I rather have a miserable ape for a grandfather or a man highly endowed by nature and possessed of great means and influence and yet who employs these faculties and that influence for the mere purpose of introducing ridicule into a grave scientific discussion I unhesitatingly affirm my preference for the ".In response to what Huxley took as a jibe from Wilberforce as to whether it was on Huxley's grandfather's or grandmother's side that he was descended from an ape, Huxley made a reply which he later recalled as being that "[if asked] would I rather have a miserable ape for a grandfather or a man highly endowed by nature and possessed of great means and influence and yet who employs these faculties and that influence for the mere purpose of introducing ridicule into a grave scientific discussion I unhesitatingly affirm my preference for the ".
No verbatim record was taken: eyewitness accounts exist, and vary .No verbatim record was taken: eyewitness accounts exist, and vary .
Robert FitzRoy, who had been the captain of during Darwin's voyage, was there to present a paper on .Robert FitzRoy, who had been the captain of during Darwin's voyage, was there to present a paper on .
During the debate FitzRoy, seen by Hooker as "a grey haired Roman nosed elderly gentleman", stood in the centre of the audience and "lifting an immense Bible first with both and afterwards with one hand over his head, solemnly implored the audience to believe God rather than ".During the debate FitzRoy, seen by Hooker as "a grey haired Roman nosed elderly gentleman", stood in the centre of the audience and "lifting an immense Bible first with both and afterwards with one hand over his head, solemnly implored the audience to believe God rather than ".
As he admitted that the Origin of Species had given him "acutest pain" the crowd shouted him .As he admitted that the Origin of Species had given him "acutest pain" the crowd shouted him .
Hooker's "blood boiled, I felt myself a dastard; now I saw my advantage –I swore to myself I would smite that Amalekite Sam hip and thigh", (he was invited up to the platform and) "there and then I smacked him amid rounds of applause proceeded to demonstrate that he could never have read your book wound up with a very few observations on the old and new hypotheses Sam was shut up and the meeting was dissolved forthwith leaving you [Darwin] master of the field after 4 hours ."Hooker's "blood boiled, I felt myself a dastard; now I saw my advantage –I swore to myself I would smite that Amalekite Sam hip and thigh", (he was invited up to the platform and) "there and then I smacked him amid rounds of applause proceeded to demonstrate that he could never have read your book wound up with a very few observations on the old and new hypotheses Sam was shut up and the meeting was dissolved forthwith leaving you [Darwin] master of the field after 4 hours ."
Both sides came away claiming victory, with Hooker and Huxley each sending Darwin rather contradictory triumphant .Both sides came away claiming victory, with Hooker and Huxley each sending Darwin rather contradictory triumphant .
Supporters of Darwinism seized on this meeting as a sign that the idea of evolution could not be suppressed by authority, and would be defended vigorously by its .Supporters of Darwinism seized on this meeting as a sign that the idea of evolution could not be suppressed by authority, and would be defended vigorously by its .
Liberal clerics were also satisfied that literal belief in all aspects of the Bible was now questioned by science; they were sympathetic to some of the ideas in Essays and .Liberal clerics were also satisfied that literal belief in all aspects of the Bible was now questioned by science; they were sympathetic to some of the ideas in Essays and .
William Whewell wrote to his friend James David Forbes that "Perhaps the Bishop was not prudent to venture into a field where no eloquence can supersede the need for precise .William Whewell wrote to his friend James David Forbes that "Perhaps the Bishop was not prudent to venture into a field where no eloquence can supersede the need for precise .
The young naturalists declared themselves in favour of Darwin ’s views which tendency I saw already at Leeds two years .The young naturalists declared themselves in favour of Darwin ’s views which tendency I saw already at Leeds two years .
I am sorry for it, for I reckon Darwin’s book to be an utterly unphilosophical ."I am sorry for it, for I reckon Darwin’s book to be an utterly unphilosophical ."
Wilberforce's Quarterly review
In late July Darwin read Wilberforce's review in the .In late July Darwin read Wilberforce's review in the .
Wilberforce also attacked Essays and Reviews in the Quarterly Review, and in a letter to The Times, signed by the Archbishop of Canterbury and 25 bishops, which threatened the theologians with the ecclesiastical .Wilberforce also attacked Essays and Reviews in the Quarterly Review, and in a letter to The Times, signed by the Archbishop of Canterbury and 25 bishops, which threatened the theologians with the ecclesiastical .
Darwin quoted a proverb: "A bench of bishops is the devil's flower garden", and joined others including Lyell, though not Hooker and Huxley, in signing a counter letter supporting Essays and Reviews for trying to "establish religious teachings on a firmer and broader ".Darwin quoted a proverb: "A bench of bishops is the devil's flower garden", and joined others including Lyell, though not Hooker and Huxley, in signing a counter letter supporting Essays and Reviews for trying to "establish religious teachings on a firmer and broader ".
Despite this alignment of pro evolution scientists and Unitarians with liberal churchmen, two of the authors were indicted for heresy and lost their jobs by .Despite this alignment of pro evolution scientists and Unitarians with liberal churchmen, two of the authors were indicted for heresy and lost their jobs by .
He sent a copy to Darwin, who thanked him, though "sorry, but not surprised, to see that you are dead against ".He sent a copy to Darwin, who thanked him, though "sorry, but not surprised, to see that you are dead against ".
On 20 November, Darwin told Lyell of his revisions for a third edition of the Origin, including removing his estimate of the time it took for the Weald to erode: "The confounded Wealden calculation, to be struck .On 20 November, Darwin told Lyell of his revisions for a third edition of the Origin, including removing his estimate of the time it took for the Weald to erode: "The confounded Wealden calculation, to be struck .
& a note to be inserted to effect that I am convinced of its inaccuracy from Review in Saturday R. & from Phillips, as I see in Table of Contents that he attacks ."& a note to be inserted to effect that I am convinced of its inaccuracy from Review in Saturday R. & from Phillips, as I see in Table of Contents that he attacks ."
He later told Lyell that "Having burnt my own fingers so consumedly with the Wealden, I am fearful for you", and advised caution: " for Heaven sake take care of your fingers; to burn them severely, as I have done, is very ."He later told Lyell that "Having burnt my own fingers so consumedly with the Wealden, I am fearful for you", and advised caution: " for Heaven sake take care of your fingers; to burn them severely, as I have done, is very ."
The third edition, as published on 30 April 1861, stated "The computation of time required for the denudation of the Weald .The third edition, as published on 30 April 1861, stated "The computation of time required for the denudation of the Weald .
I have been convinced of its inaccuracy in several respects by an excellent article in the 'Saturday Review,' Dec. 24, ."I have been convinced of its inaccuracy in several respects by an excellent article in the 'Saturday Review,' Dec. 24, ."
He wrote to Asa Gray and used the example of fantail pigeons to argue against Gray's belief "that variation has been led along certain beneficial lines", with the implication of Creationism rather than Natural .He wrote to Asa Gray and used the example of fantail pigeons to argue against Gray's belief "that variation has been led along certain beneficial lines", with the implication of Creationism rather than Natural .
Over the winter he organised a third edition of the Origin, adding an introductory historical .Over the winter he organised a third edition of the Origin, adding an introductory historical .
Asa Gray had published three supportive articles in the Atlantic .Asa Gray had published three supportive articles in the Atlantic .
Darwin persuaded Gray to publish them as a pamphlet, and was delighted when Gray came up with the title of Natural Selection Not Inconsistent with Natural .Darwin persuaded Gray to publish them as a pamphlet, and was delighted when Gray came up with the title of Natural Selection Not Inconsistent with Natural .
Darwin paid half the cost, imported 250 copies into Britain and as well as advertising it in periodicals and sending 100 copies out to scientists, reviewers, and theologians (including Wilberforce), he included in the Origin a recommendation for it, available to be purchased for .Darwin paid half the cost, imported 250 copies into Britain and as well as advertising it in periodicals and sending 100 copies out to scientists, reviewers, and theologians (including Wilberforce), he included in the Origin a recommendation for it, available to be purchased for .
.
from Trübner's in Paternoster .
The Huxleys became close family friends, frequently visiting Down .The Huxleys became close family friends, frequently visiting Down .
When their 3 year old son died of scarlet fever they were badly .When their 3 year old son died of scarlet fever they were badly .
Henrietta Huxley brought their three infants to Down in March 1861 where Emma helped to console her, while Huxley continued with his working men's lectures at the Royal School of Mines, writing that "My working men stick with me wonderfully, the house fuller than ever, By next Friday evening they will all be convinced that they are ."Henrietta Huxley brought their three infants to Down in March 1861 where Emma helped to console her, while Huxley continued with his working men's lectures at the Royal School of Mines, writing that "My working men stick with me wonderfully, the house fuller than ever, By next Friday evening they will all be convinced that they are ."
Arguments with Owen
Huxley's arguments with Owen continued in the Athenaeum so that each Saturday Darwin could read the latest .Huxley's arguments with Owen continued in the Athenaeum so that each Saturday Darwin could read the latest .
Owen tried to smear Huxley by portraying him as an "advocate of man's origins from a transmuted ape", and one of his contributions was titled "Ape Origin of Man as Tested by the ".Owen tried to smear Huxley by portraying him as an "advocate of man's origins from a transmuted ape", and one of his contributions was titled "Ape Origin of Man as Tested by the ".
This backfired, as Huxley had already delighted Darwin by speculating on "pithecoid man" – ape like man, and was glad of the invitation to publicly turn the anatomy of brain structure into a question of human .This backfired, as Huxley had already delighted Darwin by speculating on "pithecoid man" – ape like man, and was glad of the invitation to publicly turn the anatomy of brain structure into a question of human .
He was determined to indict Owen for perjury, promising "before I have done with that mendacious humbug I will nail him out, like a kite to a barn door, an example to all evil ."He was determined to indict Owen for perjury, promising "before I have done with that mendacious humbug I will nail him out, like a kite to a barn door, an example to all evil ."
Darwin egged him on from Down, writing "Oh Lord what a thorn you must be in the poor dear man's ".Darwin egged him on from Down, writing "Oh Lord what a thorn you must be in the poor dear man's ".
Their campaign ran over two years and was devastatingly successful, with each "slaying" being followed by a recruiting drive for the Darwinian .Their campaign ran over two years and was devastatingly successful, with each "slaying" being followed by a recruiting drive for the Darwinian .
The spite .The spite .
When Huxley joined the Zoological Society Council in 1861, Owen left, and in the following year Huxley moved to stop Owen from being elected to the Royal Society Council as "no body of gentlemen" should admit a member "guilty of wilful & deliberate ."When Huxley joined the Zoological Society Council in 1861, Owen left, and in the following year Huxley moved to stop Owen from being elected to the Royal Society Council as "no body of gentlemen" should admit a member "guilty of wilful & deliberate ."
Lyell was troubled both by Huxley's belligerence and by the question of ape ancestry, but got little sympathy from Darwin who teased him that "Our ancestor was an animal which breathed water, had a swim bladder, a great swimming tail, an imperfect skull, and undoubtedly was a !Lyell was troubled both by Huxley's belligerence and by the question of ape ancestry, but got little sympathy from Darwin who teased him that "Our ancestor was an animal which breathed water, had a swim bladder, a great swimming tail, an imperfect skull, and undoubtedly was a !
Here is a pleasant genealogy for ."Here is a pleasant genealogy for ."
Lyell began work on a book examining human .Lyell began work on a book examining human .
Geological time: William Thomson (Lord Kelvin)
Like the geologist John Phillips, the physicist William Thomson (later ennobled as Baron Kelvin of Largs, thus becoming Lord Kelvin) had considered since the 1840s that the physics of thermodynamics required that the Earth was cooling from an initial molten .Like the geologist John Phillips, the physicist William Thomson (later ennobled as Baron Kelvin of Largs, thus becoming Lord Kelvin) had considered since the 1840s that the physics of thermodynamics required that the Earth was cooling from an initial molten .
This contradicted Lyell's uniformitarian concept of unchanging processes over deep geological time, which Darwin shared and had assumed would allow ample time for the slow process of natural .This contradicted Lyell's uniformitarian concept of unchanging processes over deep geological time, which Darwin shared and had assumed would allow ample time for the slow process of natural .
In June 1861 Thomson asked Phillips how geologists felt about Darwin's "prodigious durations for geological ".In June 1861 Thomson asked Phillips how geologists felt about Darwin's "prodigious durations for geological ".
and mentioned his own preliminary calculation that the Sun was 20 million years old, with the Earth at most 200 to 1,000 million years .
Phillips discussed his own published view that stratified rocks went back 96 million years, and dismissed Darwin's original estimate that the Weald had taken 300 million years to .Phillips discussed his own published view that stratified rocks went back 96 million years, and dismissed Darwin's original estimate that the Weald had taken 300 million years to .
In September 1861 Thomson produced a paper "On the age of the Sun's heat" which estimated that the Sun was between 100 and 500 million years old, and in 1862 he used assumptions on the rate of cooling from a molten condition to estimate the age of the Earth at 98 million .In September 1861 Thomson produced a paper "On the age of the Sun's heat" which estimated that the Sun was between 100 and 500 million years old, and in 1862 he used assumptions on the rate of cooling from a molten condition to estimate the age of the Earth at 98 million .
The dispute continued for the rest of Darwin's .The dispute continued for the rest of Darwin's .
Continued debate
The reception of Darwin's ideas continued to arouse scientific and religious debates, and wide public .The reception of Darwin's ideas continued to arouse scientific and religious debates, and wide public .
Satirical cartoonists seized on animal ancestry in relation to other topical issues, drawing on a long tradition of identifying animal traits in .Satirical cartoonists seized on animal ancestry in relation to other topical issues, drawing on a long tradition of identifying animal traits in .
In Britain mass circulation magazines were droll rather than cruel, and thus presented Darwin's theory in an unthreatening .In Britain mass circulation magazines were droll rather than cruel, and thus presented Darwin's theory in an unthreatening .
Due to illness, Darwin began growing a beard in 1862, and when he reappeared in public in 1866 with a bushy beard, caricatures centred on Darwin and his new look contributed to a trend in which all forms of evolutionism were identified with .Due to illness, Darwin began growing a beard in 1862, and when he reappeared in public in 1866 with a bushy beard, caricatures centred on Darwin and his new look contributed to a trend in which all forms of evolutionism were identified with .