Introduction

18th and 19th century evolutionary ideas The Transmutation of species and transformism are 18th and early 19th century ideas about the change of one species into another that preceded Charles Darwin's theory of evolution through natural .18th and 19th century evolutionary ideas The Transmutation of species and transformism are 18th and early 19th century ideas about the change of one species into another that preceded Charles Darwin's theory of evolution through natural .

The French Transformisme was a term used by Jean Baptiste Lamarck in 1809 for his theory, and other 18th and 19th century proponents of pre Darwinian evolutionary ideas included Denis Diderot, Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire, Erasmus Darwin, Robert Grant, and Robert Chambers, the anonymous author of the book Vestiges of the Natural History of .The French Transformisme was a term used by Jean Baptiste Lamarck in 1809 for his theory, and other 18th and 19th century proponents of pre Darwinian evolutionary ideas included Denis Diderot, Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire, Erasmus Darwin, Robert Grant, and Robert Chambers, the anonymous author of the book Vestiges of the Natural History of .

Such ideas were associated with 18th century ideas of Deism and human .Such ideas were associated with 18th century ideas of Deism and human .

Opposition in the scientific community to these early theories of evolution, led by influential scientists like the anatomists Georges Cuvier and Richard Owen, and the geologist Charles Lyell, was .Opposition in the scientific community to these early theories of evolution, led by influential scientists like the anatomists Georges Cuvier and Richard Owen, and the geologist Charles Lyell, was .

The debate over them was an important stage in the history of evolutionary thought and influenced the subsequent reaction to Darwin's .The debate over them was an important stage in the history of evolutionary thought and influenced the subsequent reaction to Darwin's .

Terminology

Transmutation was one of the names commonly used for evolutionary ideas in the 19th century before Charles Darwin published On The Origin of Species ).Transmutation was one of the names commonly used for evolutionary ideas in the 19th century before Charles Darwin published On The Origin of Species ).

Transmutation had previously been used as a term in alchemy to describe the transformation of base metals into .Transmutation had previously been used as a term in alchemy to describe the transformation of base metals into .

Other names for evolutionary ideas used in this period include the development hypothesis (one of the terms used by Darwin) and the theory of regular gradation, used by William Chilton in the periodical press such as The Oracle of .Other names for evolutionary ideas used in this period include the development hypothesis (one of the terms used by Darwin) and the theory of regular gradation, used by William Chilton in the periodical press such as The Oracle of .

Transformation is another word used quite as often as transmutation in this .Transformation is another word used quite as often as transmutation in this .

These early 19th century evolutionary ideas played an important role in the history of evolutionary .These early 19th century evolutionary ideas played an important role in the history of evolutionary .

The proto evolutionary thinkers of the 18th and early 19th century had to invent terms to label their ideas, but it was first Joseph Gottlieb Kölreuter who used the term "transmutation" to refer to species who have had biological changes through .The proto evolutionary thinkers of the 18th and early 19th century had to invent terms to label their ideas, but it was first Joseph Gottlieb Kölreuter who used the term "transmutation" to refer to species who have had biological changes through .

The terminology did not settle down until some time after the publication of the Origin of .The terminology did not settle down until some time after the publication of the Origin of .

The word evolved in a modern sense was first used in 1826 in an anonymous paper published in Robert Jameson's journal and evolution was a relative late comer which can be seen in Herbert Spencer's Social Statics of 1851, and at least one earlier example, but was not in general use until about .The word evolved in a modern sense was first used in 1826 in an anonymous paper published in Robert Jameson's journal and evolution was a relative late comer which can be seen in Herbert Spencer's Social Statics of 1851, and at least one earlier example, but was not in general use until about .

18th and early 19th century

In the 18th century, Jacques Antoine des Bureaux claimed a "genealogical ascent of ".In the 18th century, Jacques Antoine des Bureaux claimed a "genealogical ascent of ".

He argued that through crossbreeding and hybridization in reproduction, "progressive organization" occurred, allowing organisms to change and more complex species to .He argued that through crossbreeding and hybridization in reproduction, "progressive organization" occurred, allowing organisms to change and more complex species to .

Simultaneously, Retif de la Bretonne wrote La decouverte australe par un homme volant (1781) and La philosophie de monsieur Nicolas (1796), which encapsulated his view that more complex species, such as mankind, had developed step by step from "less perfect" .Simultaneously, Retif de la Bretonne wrote La decouverte australe par un homme volant (1781) and La philosophie de monsieur Nicolas (1796), which encapsulated his view that more complex species, such as mankind, had developed step by step from "less perfect" .

De la Bretonne believed that living forms undergo constant .De la Bretonne believed that living forms undergo constant .

Although he believed in constant change, he took a very different approach from Diderot: chance and blind combinations of atoms, in de la Bretonne's opinion, were not the cause of .Although he believed in constant change, he took a very different approach from Diderot: chance and blind combinations of atoms, in de la Bretonne's opinion, were not the cause of .

De la Bretonne argued that all species had developed from more primitive organisms, and that nature aimed to reach .De la Bretonne argued that all species had developed from more primitive organisms, and that nature aimed to reach .

Diderot drew from Leonardo da Vinci ’s comparison of the leg structure of a human and a horse as proof of the interconnectivity of .Diderot drew from Leonardo da Vinci ’s comparison of the leg structure of a human and a horse as proof of the interconnectivity of .

He saw this experiment as demonstrating that nature could continually try out new .He saw this experiment as demonstrating that nature could continually try out new .

Additionally, Diderot argued that organic molecules and organic matter possessed an inherent consciousness, which allowed the smallest particles of organic matter to organize into fibers, then a network, and then .Additionally, Diderot argued that organic molecules and organic matter possessed an inherent consciousness, which allowed the smallest particles of organic matter to organize into fibers, then a network, and then .

The idea that organic molecules have consciousness was derived from both Maupertuis and Lucretian .The idea that organic molecules have consciousness was derived from both Maupertuis and Lucretian .

Overall, Diderot ’s musings all fit together as a "composite transformist philosophy", one dependent on the randomness inherent to nature as a transformist .Overall, Diderot ’s musings all fit together as a "composite transformist philosophy", one dependent on the randomness inherent to nature as a transformist .

Erasmus believed that life had one origin, a common ancestor, which he referred to as the "filament" of .Erasmus believed that life had one origin, a common ancestor, which he referred to as the "filament" of .

He used his understanding of chemical transmutation to justify the spontaneous generation of this .He used his understanding of chemical transmutation to justify the spontaneous generation of this .

His geological study of Derbyshire and the sea shells and fossils which he found there helped him to come to the conclusion that complex life had developed from more primitive forms (Laniel ).His geological study of Derbyshire and the sea shells and fossils which he found there helped him to come to the conclusion that complex life had developed from more primitive forms (Laniel ).

Erasmus was an early proponent of what we now refer to as "adaptations", albeit through a different transformist mechanism – he argued that sexual reproduction could pass on acquired traits through the father’s contribution to the .Erasmus was an early proponent of what we now refer to as "adaptations", albeit through a different transformist mechanism – he argued that sexual reproduction could pass on acquired traits through the father’s contribution to the .

These changes, he believed, were mainly driven by the three great needs of life: lust, food, and .These changes, he believed, were mainly driven by the three great needs of life: lust, food, and .

Erasmus proposed that these acquired changes gradually altered the physical makeup of organisms as a result of the desires of plants and .Erasmus proposed that these acquired changes gradually altered the physical makeup of organisms as a result of the desires of plants and .

Notably, he describes insects developing from plants, a grand example of one species transforming into .Notably, he describes insects developing from plants, a grand example of one species transforming into .

Lamarck

Jean Baptiste Lamarck proposed a hypothesis on the transmutation of species in Philosophie Zoologique ).Jean Baptiste Lamarck proposed a hypothesis on the transmutation of species in Philosophie Zoologique ).

Lamarck did not believe that all living things shared a common .Lamarck did not believe that all living things shared a common .

Rather he believed that simple forms of life were created continuously by spontaneous .Rather he believed that simple forms of life were created continuously by spontaneous .

He also believed that an innate life force, which he sometimes described as a nervous fluid, drove species to become more complex over time, advancing up a linear ladder of complexity that was related to the great chain of .He also believed that an innate life force, which he sometimes described as a nervous fluid, drove species to become more complex over time, advancing up a linear ladder of complexity that was related to the great chain of .

Lamarck also recognized that species were adapted to their .Lamarck also recognized that species were adapted to their .

He explained this observation by saying that the same nervous fluid driving increasing complexity, also caused the organs of an animal (or a plant) to change based on the use or disuse of that organ, just as muscles are affected by .He explained this observation by saying that the same nervous fluid driving increasing complexity, also caused the organs of an animal (or a plant) to change based on the use or disuse of that organ, just as muscles are affected by .

He argued that these changes would be inherited by the next generation and produce slow adaptation to the .He argued that these changes would be inherited by the next generation and produce slow adaptation to the .

It was this secondary mechanism of adaptation through the inheritance of acquired characteristics that became closely associated with his name and would influence discussions of evolution into the 20th .It was this secondary mechanism of adaptation through the inheritance of acquired characteristics that became closely associated with his name and would influence discussions of evolution into the 20th .

Ideas after Lamarck

The German Abraham Gottlob Werner believed in geological .The German Abraham Gottlob Werner believed in geological .

Specifically, Werner argued that the Earth undergoes irreversible and continuous .Specifically, Werner argued that the Earth undergoes irreversible and continuous .

The Edinburgh school, a radical British school of comparative anatomy, fostered a lot of debate around natural .The Edinburgh school, a radical British school of comparative anatomy, fostered a lot of debate around natural .

Edinburgh, which included the surgeon Robert Knox and the anatomist Robert Grant, was closely in touch with Lamarck's school of French Transformationism, which contained scientists such as Étienne Geoffroy Saint .Edinburgh, which included the surgeon Robert Knox and the anatomist Robert Grant, was closely in touch with Lamarck's school of French Transformationism, which contained scientists such as Étienne Geoffroy Saint .

Grant developed Lamarck's and Erasmus Darwin's ideas of transmutation and evolutionism, investigating homology to prove common .Grant developed Lamarck's and Erasmus Darwin's ideas of transmutation and evolutionism, investigating homology to prove common .

As a young student Charles Darwin joined Grant in investigations of the life cycle of marine .As a young student Charles Darwin joined Grant in investigations of the life cycle of marine .

He also studied geology under professor Robert Jameson whose journal published an anonymous paper in 1826 praising "Mr. Lamarck" for explaining how the higher animals had "evolved" from the "simplest worms" – this was the first use of the word "evolved" in a modern .He also studied geology under professor Robert Jameson whose journal published an anonymous paper in 1826 praising "Mr. Lamarck" for explaining how the higher animals had "evolved" from the "simplest worms" – this was the first use of the word "evolved" in a modern .

Professor Jameson was a Wernerian, which allowed him to consider transformation theories and foster the interest in transformism among his .Professor Jameson was a Wernerian, which allowed him to consider transformation theories and foster the interest in transformism among his .

Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation

The computing pioneer Charles Babbage published his unofficial Ninth Bridgewater Treatise in 1837, putting forward the thesis that God had the omnipotence and foresight to create as a divine legislator, making laws (or programs) which then produced species at the appropriate times, rather than continually interfering with ad hoc miracles each time a new species was .The computing pioneer Charles Babbage published his unofficial Ninth Bridgewater Treatise in 1837, putting forward the thesis that God had the omnipotence and foresight to create as a divine legislator, making laws (or programs) which then produced species at the appropriate times, rather than continually interfering with ad hoc miracles each time a new species was .

In 1844 the Scottish publisher Robert Chambers anonymously published an influential and extremely controversial book of popular science entitled Vestiges of the Natural History of .In 1844 the Scottish publisher Robert Chambers anonymously published an influential and extremely controversial book of popular science entitled Vestiges of the Natural History of .

This book proposed an evolutionary scenario for the origins of the solar system and life on .This book proposed an evolutionary scenario for the origins of the solar system and life on .

It claimed that the fossil record showed an ascent of animals with current animals being branches off a main line that leads progressively to .It claimed that the fossil record showed an ascent of animals with current animals being branches off a main line that leads progressively to .

It implied that the transmutations led to the unfolding of a preordained orthogenetic plan woven into the laws that governed the .It implied that the transmutations led to the unfolding of a preordained orthogenetic plan woven into the laws that governed the .

In this sense it was less completely materialistic than the ideas of radicals like Robert Grant, but its implication that humans were just the last step in the ascent of animal life incensed many conservative .In this sense it was less completely materialistic than the ideas of radicals like Robert Grant, but its implication that humans were just the last step in the ascent of animal life incensed many conservative .

Both conservatives like Adam Sedgwick, and radical materialists like Thomas Henry Huxley, who disliked Chambers' implications of preordained progress, were able to find scientific inaccuracies in the book that they could .Both conservatives like Adam Sedgwick, and radical materialists like Thomas Henry Huxley, who disliked Chambers' implications of preordained progress, were able to find scientific inaccuracies in the book that they could .

Darwin himself openly deplored the author's "poverty of intellect", and dismissed it as a "literary ".Darwin himself openly deplored the author's "poverty of intellect", and dismissed it as a "literary ".

However, the high profile of the public debate over Vestiges, with its depiction of evolution as a progressive process, and its popular success, would greatly influence the perception of Darwin's theory a decade .However, the high profile of the public debate over Vestiges, with its depiction of evolution as a progressive process, and its popular success, would greatly influence the perception of Darwin's theory a decade .

It also influenced some younger naturalists, including Alfred Russel Wallace, to take an interest in the idea of .It also influenced some younger naturalists, including Alfred Russel Wallace, to take an interest in the idea of .

Ideological motivations for theories of transmutation

The proponents of transmutation were almost all inclined to Deism—the idea, popular among many 18th century Western intellectuals that God had initially created the universe, but then left it to operate and develop through natural law rather than through divine .The proponents of transmutation were almost all inclined to Deism—the idea, popular among many 18th century Western intellectuals that God had initially created the universe, but then left it to operate and develop through natural law rather than through divine .

Thinkers like Erasmus Darwin saw the transmutation of species as part of this development of the world through natural law, which they saw as a challenge to traditional .Thinkers like Erasmus Darwin saw the transmutation of species as part of this development of the world through natural law, which they saw as a challenge to traditional .

They also believed that human history was progressive, which was another idea becoming increasingly popular in the 18th .They also believed that human history was progressive, which was another idea becoming increasingly popular in the 18th .

They saw progress in human history as being mirrored by the development of life from the simple to the complex over the history of the .They saw progress in human history as being mirrored by the development of life from the simple to the complex over the history of the .

This connection was very clear in the work of Erasmus Darwin and Robert .This connection was very clear in the work of Erasmus Darwin and Robert .

Opposition to transmutation

Ideas about the transmutation of species were strongly associated with the anti Christen materialism and radical political ideas of the Enlightenment and were greeted with hostility by more conservative .Ideas about the transmutation of species were strongly associated with the anti Christen materialism and radical political ideas of the Enlightenment and were greeted with hostility by more conservative .

Cuvier attacked the ideas of Lamarck and Geoffroy Saint Hilaire, agreeing with Aristotle that species were .Cuvier attacked the ideas of Lamarck and Geoffroy Saint Hilaire, agreeing with Aristotle that species were .

Cuvier believed that the individual parts of an animal were too closely correlated with one another to allow for one part of the anatomy to change in isolation from the others, and argued that the fossil record showed patterns of catastrophic extinctions followed by re population, rather than gradual change over .Cuvier believed that the individual parts of an animal were too closely correlated with one another to allow for one part of the anatomy to change in isolation from the others, and argued that the fossil record showed patterns of catastrophic extinctions followed by re population, rather than gradual change over .

He also noted that drawings of animals and animal mummies from Egypt, which were thousands of years old, showed no signs of change when compared with modern .He also noted that drawings of animals and animal mummies from Egypt, which were thousands of years old, showed no signs of change when compared with modern .

The strength of Cuvier's arguments and his reputation as a leading scientist helped keep transmutational ideas out of the scientific mainstream for .The strength of Cuvier's arguments and his reputation as a leading scientist helped keep transmutational ideas out of the scientific mainstream for .

In Britain, where the philosophy of natural theology remained influential, William Paley wrote the book Natural Theology with its famous watchmaker analogy, at least in part as a response to the transmutational ideas of Erasmus .In Britain, where the philosophy of natural theology remained influential, William Paley wrote the book Natural Theology with its famous watchmaker analogy, at least in part as a response to the transmutational ideas of Erasmus .

Geologists influenced by natural theology, such as Buckland and Sedgwick, made a regular practice of attacking the evolutionary ideas of Lamarck and Grant, and Sedgwick wrote a famously harsh review of The Vestiges of the Natural History of .Geologists influenced by natural theology, such as Buckland and Sedgwick, made a regular practice of attacking the evolutionary ideas of Lamarck and Grant, and Sedgwick wrote a famously harsh review of The Vestiges of the Natural History of .

Although the geologist Charles Lyell opposed scriptural geology, he also believed in the immutability of species, and in his Principles of Geology (1830–1833) he criticized and dismissed Lamarck's theories of .Although the geologist Charles Lyell opposed scriptural geology, he also believed in the immutability of species, and in his Principles of Geology (1830–1833) he criticized and dismissed Lamarck's theories of .

Instead, he advocated a form of progressive creation, in which each species had its "centre of creation" and was designed for this particular habitat, but would go extinct when this habitat .Instead, he advocated a form of progressive creation, in which each species had its "centre of creation" and was designed for this particular habitat, but would go extinct when this habitat .