Introduction

One of several alternatives to evolution by natural selection Mutationism is one of several alternatives to evolution by natural selection that have existed both before and after the publication of Charles Darwin's 1859 book On the Origin of .One of several alternatives to evolution by natural selection Mutationism is one of several alternatives to evolution by natural selection that have existed both before and after the publication of Charles Darwin's 1859 book On the Origin of .

In the theory, mutation was the source of novelty, creating new forms and new species, potentially instantaneously, believing that species evolved and that speciation took place in sudden .In the theory, mutation was the source of novelty, creating new forms and new species, potentially instantaneously, believing that species evolved and that speciation took place in sudden .

Jean Baptiste Lamarck was a gradualist but similar to other scientists of the period had written that saltational evolution was .Jean Baptiste Lamarck was a gradualist but similar to other scientists of the period had written that saltational evolution was .

In 1822, in the second volume of his Philosophie anatomique, Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire endorsed a theory of saltational evolution that "monstrosities could become the founding fathers (or mothers) of new species by instantaneous transition from one form to the ."In 1822, in the second volume of his Philosophie anatomique, Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire endorsed a theory of saltational evolution that "monstrosities could become the founding fathers (or mothers) of new species by instantaneous transition from one form to the ."

Geoffroy wrote that environmental pressures could produce sudden transformations to establish new species .Geoffroy wrote that environmental pressures could produce sudden transformations to establish new species .

Darwin's anti-saltationist gradualism, 1859

In his 1859 book On the Origin of Species, Charles Darwin denied saltational .In his 1859 book On the Origin of Species, Charles Darwin denied saltational .

He argued that evolutionary transformation always proceeds gradually, never in jumps: "natural selection acts solely by accumulating slight successive favourable variations, it can produce no great or sudden modification; it can act only by very short ".He argued that evolutionary transformation always proceeds gradually, never in jumps: "natural selection acts solely by accumulating slight successive favourable variations, it can produce no great or sudden modification; it can act only by very short ".

Darwin continued in this belief throughout his .Darwin continued in this belief throughout his .

Thomas Henry Huxley warned Darwin that he had taken on "an unnecessary difficulty in adopting Natura non facit saltum ["Nature does not take leaps"] so ."Thomas Henry Huxley warned Darwin that he had taken on "an unnecessary difficulty in adopting Natura non facit saltum ["Nature does not take leaps"] so ."

Huxley feared this assumption could discourage naturalists (catastrophists) who believed that major leaps and cataclysms played a significant role in the history of .Huxley feared this assumption could discourage naturalists (catastrophists) who believed that major leaps and cataclysms played a significant role in the history of .

von Kölliker's heterogenesis, 1864

In 1864 Albert von Kölliker revived Geoffroy's theory that evolution proceeds by large steps, under the name of heterogenesis, but this time assuming the influence of a nonmaterial force to direct the course of .In 1864 Albert von Kölliker revived Geoffroy's theory that evolution proceeds by large steps, under the name of heterogenesis, but this time assuming the influence of a nonmaterial force to direct the course of .

Galton's "sports", 1892

Darwin's cousin, Francis Galton, considered Darwin's evidence for evolution, and came to an opposite conclusion about the type of variation on which natural selection must .Darwin's cousin, Francis Galton, considered Darwin's evidence for evolution, and came to an opposite conclusion about the type of variation on which natural selection must .

He carried out his own experiments and published a series of papers and books setting out his .He carried out his own experiments and published a series of papers and books setting out his .

Already by 1869 when he published Hereditary Genius, he believed in evolution by .Already by 1869 when he published Hereditary Genius, he believed in evolution by .

In his 1889 book Natural Inheritance he argued that natural selection would benefit from accepting that the steps need not, as Darwin had stated, be .In his 1889 book Natural Inheritance he argued that natural selection would benefit from accepting that the steps need not, as Darwin had stated, be .

In his 1892 book Finger Prints, he stated directly that "The progress of evolution is not a smooth and uniform progression, but one that proceeds by jerks, through successive 'sports' (as they are called), some of them implying considerable organic changes; and each in its turn being favoured by Natural ".In his 1892 book Finger Prints, he stated directly that "The progress of evolution is not a smooth and uniform progression, but one that proceeds by jerks, through successive 'sports' (as they are called), some of them implying considerable organic changes; and each in its turn being favoured by Natural ".

From 1860 to 1880 saltation had been a minority viewpoint, to the extent that Galton felt his writings were being universally .From 1860 to 1880 saltation had been a minority viewpoint, to the extent that Galton felt his writings were being universally .

By 1890 it became a widely held theory, and his views helped to launch a major .By 1890 it became a widely held theory, and his views helped to launch a major .

Bateson's discontinuous variation, 1894

William Bateson's 1894 book Materials for the Study of Variation, Treated with Especial Regard to Discontinuity in the Origin of Species marked the arrival of mutationist thinking, before the rediscovery of Mendel's .William Bateson's 1894 book Materials for the Study of Variation, Treated with Especial Regard to Discontinuity in the Origin of Species marked the arrival of mutationist thinking, before the rediscovery of Mendel's .

He examined discontinuous variation (implying a form of saltation) where it occurred naturally, following William Keith Brooks, Galton, Thomas Henry Huxley and St. George Jackson .He examined discontinuous variation (implying a form of saltation) where it occurred naturally, following William Keith Brooks, Galton, Thomas Henry Huxley and St. George Jackson .

Hugo de Vries's careful 1901 studies of wild variants of the evening primrose Oenothera lamarckiana showed that distinct new forms could arise suddenly in nature, apparently at random, and could be propagated for many generations without dissipation or .Hugo de Vries's careful 1901 studies of wild variants of the evening primrose Oenothera lamarckiana showed that distinct new forms could arise suddenly in nature, apparently at random, and could be propagated for many generations without dissipation or .

He gave such changes the name ".He gave such changes the name ".

By this, de Vries meant that a new form of the plant was created in a single step (not the same as a mutation in the modern sense); no long period of natural selection was required for speciation, and nor was reproductive .By this, de Vries meant that a new form of the plant was created in a single step (not the same as a mutation in the modern sense); no long period of natural selection was required for speciation, and nor was reproductive .

In the view of the historian of science Peter J. Bowler, De Vries used the term to mean quote|large scale genetic changes capable of producing a new subspecies, or even species, .In the view of the historian of science Peter J. Bowler, De Vries used the term to mean quote|large scale genetic changes capable of producing a new subspecies, or even species, .

In the view of the historian of science Edward Larson, de Vries was the person largely responsible for transforming Victorian era saltationism into early 20th century mutation theory, "and in doing so pushed Darwinism near the verge of extinction as a viable scientific ".In the view of the historian of science Edward Larson, de Vries was the person largely responsible for transforming Victorian era saltationism into early 20th century mutation theory, "and in doing so pushed Darwinism near the verge of extinction as a viable scientific ".

Johannsen's "pure line" experiments, 1903

In the early 1900s, Darwin's mechanism of natural selection was understood by believers in continuous variation, principally the biometricians Walter Weldon and Karl Pearson, to be able to work on a continuously varying characteristic, whereas de Vries argued that selection on such characteristics would be .In the early 1900s, Darwin's mechanism of natural selection was understood by believers in continuous variation, principally the biometricians Walter Weldon and Karl Pearson, to be able to work on a continuously varying characteristic, whereas de Vries argued that selection on such characteristics would be .

Wilhelm Johannsen's "pure line" experiments on Phaseolus vulgaris beans appeared to refute this .Wilhelm Johannsen's "pure line" experiments on Phaseolus vulgaris beans appeared to refute this .

Using the true breeding Princess variety of bean, carefully inbred within weight classes, Johannsen's work appeared to support de .Using the true breeding Princess variety of bean, carefully inbred within weight classes, Johannsen's work appeared to support de .

The offspring had a smooth random .The offspring had a smooth random .

Johanssen believed that his results showed that continuous variability was not inherited, so evolution must rely on discontinuous mutations, as de Vries had .Johanssen believed that his results showed that continuous variability was not inherited, so evolution must rely on discontinuous mutations, as de Vries had .

Johanssen published his work in Danish in a 1903 paper Om arvelighed i samfund og i rene linier (On inheritance in populations and in pure lines), and in his 1905 book Arvelighedslærens Elementer (The Elements of ).Johanssen published his work in Danish in a 1903 paper Om arvelighed i samfund og i rene linier (On inheritance in populations and in pure lines), and in his 1905 book Arvelighedslærens Elementer (The Elements of ).

Punnett's mimicry, 1915

In 1915, Reginald Punnett argued in his book Mimicry in Butterflies that the 3 morphs (forms) of the butterfly Papilio polytes, which mimic different host species of butterfly, demonstrated discontinuous evolution in .In 1915, Reginald Punnett argued in his book Mimicry in Butterflies that the 3 morphs (forms) of the butterfly Papilio polytes, which mimic different host species of butterfly, demonstrated discontinuous evolution in .

The different forms existed in a stable polymorphism controlled by 2 Mendelian factors ).The different forms existed in a stable polymorphism controlled by 2 Mendelian factors ).

The alleles of these genes were certainly discontinuous, so Punnett supposed that they must have evolved in discontinuous .The alleles of these genes were certainly discontinuous, so Punnett supposed that they must have evolved in discontinuous .

Yule's analysis of Mendelism and continuous variation, 1902

The undermining of mutationism began almost at once, in 1902, as the statistician Udny Yule analysed Mendel's theory and showed that given full dominance of one allele over another, a 3:1 ratio of alleles would be sustained .The undermining of mutationism began almost at once, in 1902, as the statistician Udny Yule analysed Mendel's theory and showed that given full dominance of one allele over another, a 3:1 ratio of alleles would be sustained .

This meant that the recessive allele could remain in the population with no need to invoke .This meant that the recessive allele could remain in the population with no need to invoke .

He also showed that given multiple factors, Mendel's theory enabled continuous variation, as indeed Mendel had suggested, removing the central plank of the mutationist theory, and criticised Bateson's confrontational .He also showed that given multiple factors, Mendel's theory enabled continuous variation, as indeed Mendel had suggested, removing the central plank of the mutationist theory, and criticised Bateson's confrontational .

However, the "excellent" paper did not prevent the Mendelians and the biometricians from falling .However, the "excellent" paper did not prevent the Mendelians and the biometricians from falling .

Nilsson-Ehle's experiments on Mendelian inheritance and continuous variation, 1908

The Swedish geneticist H. Nilsson Ehle demonstrated in 1908, in a paper published in German in a Swedish journal, Einige Ergebnisse von Kreuzungen bei Hafer und Weizen (Observations on Crosses in Oats and Wheat), that continuous variation could readily be produced by multiple Mendelian .The Swedish geneticist H. Nilsson Ehle demonstrated in 1908, in a paper published in German in a Swedish journal, Einige Ergebnisse von Kreuzungen bei Hafer und Weizen (Observations on Crosses in Oats and Wheat), that continuous variation could readily be produced by multiple Mendelian .

He found numerous Mendelian 3:1 ratios, implying a dominant and a recessive allele, in oats and wheat; a 15:1 ratio for a cross of oat varieties with black and white glumes respectively, implying two pairs of alleles (two Mendelian factors); and that crossing a red grained Swedish velvet wheat with a white one gave in the third (F3) generation the complex signature of ratios expected of three factors at once, with 37 grains giving only red offspring, 8 giving 63:1 in their offspring, 12 giving 15:1, and 6 giving .He found numerous Mendelian 3:1 ratios, implying a dominant and a recessive allele, in oats and wheat; a 15:1 ratio for a cross of oat varieties with black and white glumes respectively, implying two pairs of alleles (two Mendelian factors); and that crossing a red grained Swedish velvet wheat with a white one gave in the third (F3) generation the complex signature of ratios expected of three factors at once, with 37 grains giving only red offspring, 8 giving 63:1 in their offspring, 12 giving 15:1, and 6 giving .

There weren't any grains giving all white, but as he had only expected 1 of those in his sample, 0 was not an unlikely .There weren't any grains giving all white, but as he had only expected 1 of those in his sample, 0 was not an unlikely .

Genes could clearly combine in almost infinite combinations: ten of his factors allowed for almost 60,000 different forms, with no need to suppose that any new mutations were .Genes could clearly combine in almost infinite combinations: ten of his factors allowed for almost 60,000 different forms, with no need to suppose that any new mutations were .

The results implied that natural selection would work on Mendelian genes, helping to bring about the unification of Darwinian evolution and .The results implied that natural selection would work on Mendelian genes, helping to bring about the unification of Darwinian evolution and .

Similar work in America by Edward East on maize in 1910 showed the same thing for biologists without access to Nilsson Ehle's .Similar work in America by Edward East on maize in 1910 showed the same thing for biologists without access to Nilsson Ehle's .

On the same theme, the mathematician Ronald Fisher published "The Correlation Between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance" in 1918, again showing that continuous variation could readily be produced by multiple Mendelian .On the same theme, the mathematician Ronald Fisher published "The Correlation Between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance" in 1918, again showing that continuous variation could readily be produced by multiple Mendelian .

It showed, too, that Mendelian inheritance had no essential link with mutationism: Fisher stressed that small variations (per gene) would be sufficient for natural selection to drive .It showed, too, that Mendelian inheritance had no essential link with mutationism: Fisher stressed that small variations (per gene) would be sufficient for natural selection to drive .

Castle's selection experiments on hooded rats, 1911

Starting in 1906, William Castle carried out a long study of the effect of selection on coat colour in .Starting in 1906, William Castle carried out a long study of the effect of selection on coat colour in .

The piebald or hooded pattern was recessive to the grey wild .The piebald or hooded pattern was recessive to the grey wild .

He crossed hooded rats with the black backed Irish type, and then back crossed the offspring with pure hooded .He crossed hooded rats with the black backed Irish type, and then back crossed the offspring with pure hooded .

The dark stripe on the back was .The dark stripe on the back was .

He then tried selecting different groups for bigger or smaller stripes for 5 generations, and found that it was possible to change the characteristics way beyond the initial range of .He then tried selecting different groups for bigger or smaller stripes for 5 generations, and found that it was possible to change the characteristics way beyond the initial range of .

This effectively refuted de Vries's claim that continuous variation could not be inherited permanently, requiring new .This effectively refuted de Vries's claim that continuous variation could not be inherited permanently, requiring new .

By 1911 Castle noted that the results could be explained by Darwinian selection on heritable variation of Mendelian .By 1911 Castle noted that the results could be explained by Darwinian selection on heritable variation of Mendelian .

Morgan's small Mendelian genes in Drosophila, 1912

By 1912, after years of work on the genetics of Drosophila fruit flies, Thomas Hunt Morgan showed that these animals had many small Mendelian factors on which Darwinian evolution could work as if variation was fully .By 1912, after years of work on the genetics of Drosophila fruit flies, Thomas Hunt Morgan showed that these animals had many small Mendelian factors on which Darwinian evolution could work as if variation was fully .

The way was open for geneticists to conclude that Mendelism supported .The way was open for geneticists to conclude that Mendelism supported .

Muller's balanced lethal explanation of Oenothera "mutations", 1918

De Vries's mutationism was dealt a serious if not fatal blow in 1918 by the American geneticist Hermann Joseph .De Vries's mutationism was dealt a serious if not fatal blow in 1918 by the American geneticist Hermann Joseph .

He compared the behaviour of balanced lethals in Drosophila with De Vries's supposed mutations in Oenothera, showing that they could work the same .He compared the behaviour of balanced lethals in Drosophila with De Vries's supposed mutations in Oenothera, showing that they could work the same .

No actual mutations were involved, but infrequent chromosome crossovers accounted for the sudden appearance of traits which had been present in the genes all .No actual mutations were involved, but infrequent chromosome crossovers accounted for the sudden appearance of traits which had been present in the genes all .

Fisher's explanation of polymorphism, 1927

In 1927, Fisher explicitly attacked Punnett's 1915 theory of discontinuous evolution of .In 1927, Fisher explicitly attacked Punnett's 1915 theory of discontinuous evolution of .

Fisher argued that selection acting on genes making small modifications to the butterfly's phenotype (its appearance) would allow the multiple forms of a polymorphism to be .Fisher argued that selection acting on genes making small modifications to the butterfly's phenotype (its appearance) would allow the multiple forms of a polymorphism to be .

Willis's macromutations, 1923

In 1923, the botanist John Christopher Willis proposed that species were formed by large mutations, not gradual evolution by natural selection, and that evolution was driven by orthogenesis, which he called "differentiation", rather than by natural .In 1923, the botanist John Christopher Willis proposed that species were formed by large mutations, not gradual evolution by natural selection, and that evolution was driven by orthogenesis, which he called "differentiation", rather than by natural .

Goldschmidt's hopeful monsters, 1940

[[File:Masatoshi Nei 2013. jpg|thumb|upright|Masatoshi Nei argues that evolution is often mutation .[[File:Masatoshi Nei 2013. jpg|thumb|upright|Masatoshi Nei argues that evolution is often mutation .

However, interest in Goldschmidt's ideas has reawakened in the field of evolutionary developmental .However, interest in Goldschmidt's ideas has reawakened in the field of evolutionary developmental .

Nei's mutation-driven evolution, 1987

Contemporary biologists accept that mutation and selection both play roles in evolution; the mainstream view is that while mutation supplies material for selection in the form of variation, all non random outcomes are caused by natural .Contemporary biologists accept that mutation and selection both play roles in evolution; the mainstream view is that while mutation supplies material for selection in the form of variation, all non random outcomes are caused by natural .

Masatoshi Nei argues instead that the production of more efficient genotypes by mutation is fundamental for evolution, and that evolution is often mutation .Masatoshi Nei argues instead that the production of more efficient genotypes by mutation is fundamental for evolution, and that evolution is often mutation .

Nei's book received thoughtful reviews; while Wright rejected Nei's thinking as mistaken, Brookfield, Galtier, Weiss, Stoltzfus, Gould's macromutation theory gave a nod to his predecessor with an envisaged "Goldschmidt break" between evolution within a species and .Nei's book received thoughtful reviews; while Wright rejected Nei's thinking as mistaken, Brookfield, Galtier, Weiss, Stoltzfus, Gould's macromutation theory gave a nod to his predecessor with an envisaged "Goldschmidt break" between evolution within a species and .

His advocacy of Goldschmidt was attacked with "highly unflattering comments" and Alan .His advocacy of Goldschmidt was attacked with "highly unflattering comments" and Alan .

Futuyma concludes, following other biologists reviewing the field such as K. Sterelny and A. Minelli, that essentially all the claims of evolution driven by large mutations could be explained within the Darwinian evolutionary .Futuyma concludes, following other biologists reviewing the field such as K. Sterelny and A. Minelli, that essentially all the claims of evolution driven by large mutations could be explained within the Darwinian evolutionary .

James A. Shapiro's claim that molecular genetics undermines Darwinism has been described as mutationism and an extreme view by the zoologist Andy .James A. Shapiro's claim that molecular genetics undermines Darwinism has been described as mutationism and an extreme view by the zoologist Andy .

Cases of mutation bias are cited by mutationism advocates of the extended evolutionary synthesis who have argued that mutation bias is an entirely novel evolutionary .Cases of mutation bias are cited by mutationism advocates of the extended evolutionary synthesis who have argued that mutation bias is an entirely novel evolutionary .

This viewpoint has been criticized by Erik .This viewpoint has been criticized by Erik .

A 2019 review by Svensson and David Berger concluded that "we find little support for mutation bias as an independent force in adaptive evolution, although it can interact with selection under conditions of small population size and when standing genetic variation is limited, entirely consistent with standard evolutionary ."A 2019 review by Svensson and David Berger concluded that "we find little support for mutation bias as an independent force in adaptive evolution, although it can interact with selection under conditions of small population size and when standing genetic variation is limited, entirely consistent with standard evolutionary ."

In contrast to Svensson and Berger a 2023 review by Arlin Stoltzfus and colleagues concluded that there is strong empirical evidence and theoretical arguments that mutation bias has predictable effects on genetic changes fixed in .In contrast to Svensson and Berger a 2023 review by Arlin Stoltzfus and colleagues concluded that there is strong empirical evidence and theoretical arguments that mutation bias has predictable effects on genetic changes fixed in .

Historiography

Biologists at the start of the 20th century broadly agreed that evolution occurred, but felt that the mechanisms suggested by Darwin, including natural selection, would be .Biologists at the start of the 20th century broadly agreed that evolution occurred, but felt that the mechanisms suggested by Darwin, including natural selection, would be .

Large mutations looked likely to drive evolution quickly, and avoided the difficulty which had rightly worried Darwin, namely that blending inheritance would average out any small favourable .Large mutations looked likely to drive evolution quickly, and avoided the difficulty which had rightly worried Darwin, namely that blending inheritance would average out any small favourable .

Further, large saltatory mutation, able to create species in a single step, offered a ready explanation of why the fossil record should contain large discontinuities and times of rapid .Further, large saltatory mutation, able to create species in a single step, offered a ready explanation of why the fossil record should contain large discontinuities and times of rapid .

These discoveries were often framed by supporters of the mid 20th century modern synthesis, such as Julian Huxley and Ernst Mayr, as a controversy between the early geneticists—the "Mendelians"—including Bateson, Johannsen, de Vries, Morgan, and Punnett, who advocated Mendelism and mutation, and were understood as opponents of Darwin's original gradualist view, and the biometricians such as Pearson and Weldon, who opposed Mendelism and were more faithful to .These discoveries were often framed by supporters of the mid 20th century modern synthesis, such as Julian Huxley and Ernst Mayr, as a controversy between the early geneticists—the "Mendelians"—including Bateson, Johannsen, de Vries, Morgan, and Punnett, who advocated Mendelism and mutation, and were understood as opponents of Darwin's original gradualist view, and the biometricians such as Pearson and Weldon, who opposed Mendelism and were more faithful to .

In this version, little progress was made during the eclipse of Darwinism, and the debate between mutationist geneticists such as de Vries and biometricians such as Pearson ended with the victory of the modern synthesis between about 1918 and .In this version, little progress was made during the eclipse of Darwinism, and the debate between mutationist geneticists such as de Vries and biometricians such as Pearson ended with the victory of the modern synthesis between about 1918 and .

According to this account, the new population genetics of the 1940s demonstrated the explanatory power of natural selection, while mutationism, alongside other non Darwinian approaches such as orthogenesis and structuralism, was essentially .According to this account, the new population genetics of the 1940s demonstrated the explanatory power of natural selection, while mutationism, alongside other non Darwinian approaches such as orthogenesis and structuralism, was essentially .

This view became dominant in the second half of the 20th century, and was accepted by both biologists and .This view became dominant in the second half of the 20th century, and was accepted by both biologists and .

A more recent view, advocated by the historians Arlin Stoltzfus and Kele Cable, is that Bateson, de Vries, Morgan and Punnett had by 1918 formed a synthesis of Mendelism and .A more recent view, advocated by the historians Arlin Stoltzfus and Kele Cable, is that Bateson, de Vries, Morgan and Punnett had by 1918 formed a synthesis of Mendelism and .

The understanding achieved by these geneticists spanned the action of natural selection on alleles (alternative forms of a gene), the Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, the evolution of continuously varying traits (like height), and the probability that a new mutation will become .The understanding achieved by these geneticists spanned the action of natural selection on alleles (alternative forms of a gene), the Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, the evolution of continuously varying traits (like height), and the probability that a new mutation will become .

In this view, the early geneticists accepted natural selection alongside mutation, but rejected Darwin's non Mendelian ideas about variation and heredity, and the synthesis began soon after .In this view, the early geneticists accepted natural selection alongside mutation, but rejected Darwin's non Mendelian ideas about variation and heredity, and the synthesis began soon after .

The traditional claim that Mendelians rejected the idea of continuous variation outright is simply false; as early as 1902, Bateson and Edith Saunders wrote that "If there were even so few as, say, four or five pairs of possible allelomorphs, the various homo and hetero zygous combinations might, on seriation, give so near an approach to a continuous curve, that the purity of the elements would be ".The traditional claim that Mendelians rejected the idea of continuous variation outright is simply false; as early as 1902, Bateson and Edith Saunders wrote that "If there were even so few as, say, four or five pairs of possible allelomorphs, the various homo and hetero zygous combinations might, on seriation, give so near an approach to a continuous curve, that the purity of the elements would be ".

Historians have interpreted the history of mutationism in different .Historians have interpreted the history of mutationism in different .

genetics led logically to the modern synthesis and mutationism was one of several anti Darwinian "blind alleys" separate from the main line leading from Darwin to the .genetics led logically to the modern synthesis and mutationism was one of several anti Darwinian "blind alleys" separate from the main line leading from Darwin to the .

A revisionist view is that mutationists accepted both mutation and selection, with broadly the same roles they have today, and early on accepted and indeed offered a correct explanation for continuous variation based on multiple genes, paving the way for gradual .A revisionist view is that mutationists accepted both mutation and selection, with broadly the same roles they have today, and early on accepted and indeed offered a correct explanation for continuous variation based on multiple genes, paving the way for gradual .

At the time of the Darwin centennial in Cambridge in 1909, mutationism and Lamarckism were contrasted with natural selection as competing ideas; 50 years later, at the 1959 University of Chicago centennial of the publication of On the Origin of Species, mutationism was no longer seriously .At the time of the Darwin centennial in Cambridge in 1909, mutationism and Lamarckism were contrasted with natural selection as competing ideas; 50 years later, at the 1959 University of Chicago centennial of the publication of On the Origin of Species, mutationism was no longer seriously .