Introduction
Sudden and large mutational change In biology, saltation is a sudden and large mutational change from one generation to the next, potentially causing single step .Sudden and large mutational change In biology, saltation is a sudden and large mutational change from one generation to the next, potentially causing single step .
This was historically offered as an alternative to .This was historically offered as an alternative to .
Some forms of mutationism were effectively saltationist, implying large discontinuous .Some forms of mutationism were effectively saltationist, implying large discontinuous .
Speciation, such as by polyploidy in plants, can sometimes be achieved in a single and in evolutionary terms sudden .Speciation, such as by polyploidy in plants, can sometimes be achieved in a single and in evolutionary terms sudden .
Evidence exists for various forms of saltation in a variety of .Evidence exists for various forms of saltation in a variety of .
History
Prior to Charles Darwin most evolutionary scientists had been .Prior to Charles Darwin most evolutionary scientists had been .
Jean Baptiste Lamarck was a gradualist but similar to other scientists of the period had written that saltational evolution was .Jean Baptiste Lamarck was a gradualist but similar to other scientists of the period had written that saltational evolution was .
Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire endorsed a theory of saltational evolution that "monstrosities could become the founding fathers (or mothers) of new species by instantaneous transition from one form to the ."Étienne Geoffroy Saint Hilaire endorsed a theory of saltational evolution that "monstrosities could become the founding fathers (or mothers) of new species by instantaneous transition from one form to the ."
Geoffroy wrote that environmental pressures could produce sudden transformations to establish new species .Geoffroy wrote that environmental pressures could produce sudden transformations to establish new species .
In 1864 Albert von Kölliker revived Geoffroy's theory that evolution proceeds by large steps, under the name of .In 1864 Albert von Kölliker revived Geoffroy's theory that evolution proceeds by large steps, under the name of .
With the publication of On the Origin of Species in 1859 Charles Darwin wrote that most evolutionary changes proceeded gradually but he did not deny the existence of .With the publication of On the Origin of Species in 1859 Charles Darwin wrote that most evolutionary changes proceeded gradually but he did not deny the existence of .
From 1860 to 1880 saltation had a minority interest but by 1890 had become a major interest to .From 1860 to 1880 saltation had a minority interest but by 1890 had become a major interest to .
In their paper on evolutionary theories in the 20th century Levit et al wrote: The advocates of saltationism deny the Darwinian idea of slowly and gradually growing divergence of character as the only source of evolutionary .In their paper on evolutionary theories in the 20th century Levit et al wrote: The advocates of saltationism deny the Darwinian idea of slowly and gradually growing divergence of character as the only source of evolutionary .
They would not necessarily completely deny gradual variation, but claim that cardinally new ‘body plans’ come into being as a result of saltations (sudden, discontinuous and crucial changes, for example, the series of ).They would not necessarily completely deny gradual variation, but claim that cardinally new ‘body plans’ come into being as a result of saltations (sudden, discontinuous and crucial changes, for example, the series of ).
The latter are responsible for the sudden appearance of new higher taxa including classes and orders, while small variation is supposed to be responsible for the fine adaptations below the species .The latter are responsible for the sudden appearance of new higher taxa including classes and orders, while small variation is supposed to be responsible for the fine adaptations below the species .
In the early 20th century a mechanism of saltation was proposed as large .In the early 20th century a mechanism of saltation was proposed as large .
It was seen as a much faster alternative to the Darwinian concept of a gradual process of small random variations being acted on by natural .It was seen as a much faster alternative to the Darwinian concept of a gradual process of small random variations being acted on by natural .
It was popular with early geneticists such as Hugo de Vries, who along with Carl Correns helped rediscover Gregor Mendel's laws of inheritance in 1900, William Bateson, a British zoologist who switched to genetics, and early in his career Thomas Hunt .It was popular with early geneticists such as Hugo de Vries, who along with Carl Correns helped rediscover Gregor Mendel's laws of inheritance in 1900, William Bateson, a British zoologist who switched to genetics, and early in his career Thomas Hunt .
Some of these geneticists developed it into the mutation theory of .Some of these geneticists developed it into the mutation theory of .
There was also a debate over accounts of the evolution of mimicry and if they could be explained by gradualism or .There was also a debate over accounts of the evolution of mimicry and if they could be explained by gradualism or .
The geneticist Reginald Punnett supported a saltational theory in his book Mimicry in Butterflies ).The geneticist Reginald Punnett supported a saltational theory in his book Mimicry in Butterflies ).
The mutation theory of evolution held that species went through periods of rapid mutation, possibly as a result of environmental stress, that could produce multiple mutations, and in some cases completely new species, in a single .The mutation theory of evolution held that species went through periods of rapid mutation, possibly as a result of environmental stress, that could produce multiple mutations, and in some cases completely new species, in a single .
This mutationist view of evolution was later replaced by the reconciliation of Mendelian genetics with natural selection into a gradualistic framework for the neo Darwinian .This mutationist view of evolution was later replaced by the reconciliation of Mendelian genetics with natural selection into a gradualistic framework for the neo Darwinian .
It was the emergence of population thinking in evolution which forced many scientists to adopt gradualism in the early 20th .It was the emergence of population thinking in evolution which forced many scientists to adopt gradualism in the early 20th .
According to Ernst Mayr, it wasn't until the development of population genetics in the neo Darwinian synthesis in the 1940s that demonstrated the explanatory power of natural selection that saltational views of evolution were largely .According to Ernst Mayr, it wasn't until the development of population genetics in the neo Darwinian synthesis in the 1940s that demonstrated the explanatory power of natural selection that saltational views of evolution were largely .
Saltation was originally denied by the "modern synthesis" school of neo Darwinism which favoured gradual evolution but has since been accepted due to recent evidence in evolutionary biology (see the current status ).Saltation was originally denied by the "modern synthesis" school of neo Darwinism which favoured gradual evolution but has since been accepted due to recent evidence in evolutionary biology (see the current status ).
In recent years there are some prominent proponents of saltation, including Carl .In recent years there are some prominent proponents of saltation, including Carl .
Woese, and colleagues, suggested that the absence of RNA signature continuum between domains of bacteria, archaea, and eukarya constitutes a primary indication that the three primary organismal lineages materialized via one or more major evolutionary saltations from some universal ancestral state involving dramatic change in cellular organization that was significant early in the evolution of life, but in complex organisms gave way to the generally accepted Darwinian .Woese, and colleagues, suggested that the absence of RNA signature continuum between domains of bacteria, archaea, and eukarya constitutes a primary indication that the three primary organismal lineages materialized via one or more major evolutionary saltations from some universal ancestral state involving dramatic change in cellular organization that was significant early in the evolution of life, but in complex organisms gave way to the generally accepted Darwinian .
The geneticist Barbara McClintock introduced the idea of "jumping genes", chromosome transpositions that can produce rapid changes in the .The geneticist Barbara McClintock introduced the idea of "jumping genes", chromosome transpositions that can produce rapid changes in the .
Saltational speciation, also known as abrupt speciation, is the discontinuity in a lineage that occurs through genetic mutations, chromosomal aberrations or other evolutionary mechanisms that cause reproductively isolated individuals to establish a new species .Saltational speciation, also known as abrupt speciation, is the discontinuity in a lineage that occurs through genetic mutations, chromosomal aberrations or other evolutionary mechanisms that cause reproductively isolated individuals to establish a new species .
Polyploidy, karyotypic fission, symbiogenesis and lateral gene transfer are possible mechanisms for saltational .Polyploidy, karyotypic fission, symbiogenesis and lateral gene transfer are possible mechanisms for saltational .
Known mechanisms
Examples of saltational evolution include cases of stabilized hybrids that can reproduce without crossing (such as allotetraploids) and cases of .Examples of saltational evolution include cases of stabilized hybrids that can reproduce without crossing (such as allotetraploids) and cases of .
Both gene duplication and lateral gene transfer have the capacity to bring about relatively large changes that are .Both gene duplication and lateral gene transfer have the capacity to bring about relatively large changes that are .
Polyploidy (most common in plants but not unknown in animals) is saltational: a significant change (in gene numbers) can result in speciation in a single .Polyploidy (most common in plants but not unknown in animals) is saltational: a significant change (in gene numbers) can result in speciation in a single .
Claimed instances
Evidence of phenotypic saltation has been found in the centipede and some scientists have suggested there is evidence for independent instances of saltational evolution in sphinx .Evidence of phenotypic saltation has been found in the centipede and some scientists have suggested there is evidence for independent instances of saltational evolution in sphinx .
Saltational changes have occurred in the buccal cavity of the roundworm Caenorhabditis .Saltational changes have occurred in the buccal cavity of the roundworm Caenorhabditis .
Some processes of epigenetic inheritance can also produce changes that are .Some processes of epigenetic inheritance can also produce changes that are .
There has been a controversy over whether mimicry in butterflies and other insects can be explained by gradual or saltational .There has been a controversy over whether mimicry in butterflies and other insects can be explained by gradual or saltational .
According to Norrström (2006) there is evidence for saltation in some cases of .According to Norrström (2006) there is evidence for saltation in some cases of .
The endosymbiotic theory is considered to be a type of saltational .The endosymbiotic theory is considered to be a type of saltational .
Symonds and Elgar, 2004 have suggested that pheromone evolution in bark beetles is characterized by large saltational .Symonds and Elgar, 2004 have suggested that pheromone evolution in bark beetles is characterized by large saltational .
The mode of evolution of sex pheromones in Bactrocera has occurred by rapid saltational changes associated with speciation followed by gradual divergence .The mode of evolution of sex pheromones in Bactrocera has occurred by rapid saltational changes associated with speciation followed by gradual divergence .
Saltational speciation has been recognized in the genus Clarkia (Lewis, ).Saltational speciation has been recognized in the genus Clarkia (Lewis, ).
It has been suggested (Carr, 1980, 2000) that the Calycadenia pauciflora could have originated directly from an ancestral race through a single saltational event involving multiple chromosome .It has been suggested (Carr, 1980, 2000) that the Calycadenia pauciflora could have originated directly from an ancestral race through a single saltational event involving multiple chromosome .
Specific cases of homeosis in flowers can be caused by saltational .Specific cases of homeosis in flowers can be caused by saltational .
In a study of divergent orchid flowers (Bateman and DiMichele, 2002) wrote how simple homeotic morphs in a population can lead to newly established forms that become fixed and ultimately lead to new .In a study of divergent orchid flowers (Bateman and DiMichele, 2002) wrote how simple homeotic morphs in a population can lead to newly established forms that become fixed and ultimately lead to new .
They described the transformation as a saltational evolutionary process, where a mutation of key developmental genes leads to a profound phenotypic change, producing a new evolutionary lineage within a .They described the transformation as a saltational evolutionary process, where a mutation of key developmental genes leads to a profound phenotypic change, producing a new evolutionary lineage within a .
Explanations
Reviewing the history of macroevolutionary theories, the American evolutionary biologist Douglas J. Futuyma notes that since 1970, two very different alternatives to Darwinian gradualism have been proposed, both by Stephen Jay Gould: mutationism, and punctuated .Reviewing the history of macroevolutionary theories, the American evolutionary biologist Douglas J. Futuyma notes that since 1970, two very different alternatives to Darwinian gradualism have been proposed, both by Stephen Jay Gould: mutationism, and punctuated .
Gould's macromutation theory gave a nod to his predecessor with an envisaged "Goldschmidt break" between evolution within a species and .Gould's macromutation theory gave a nod to his predecessor with an envisaged "Goldschmidt break" between evolution within a species and .
His advocacy of Goldschmidt was attacked with "highly unflattering comments" and .His advocacy of Goldschmidt was attacked with "highly unflattering comments" and .
Futuyma concludes, following other biologists reviewing the field such as K. Sterelny and A. Minelli, that essentially all the claims of evolution driven by large mutations could be explained within the Darwinian evolutionary .Futuyma concludes, following other biologists reviewing the field such as K. Sterelny and A. Minelli, that essentially all the claims of evolution driven by large mutations could be explained within the Darwinian evolutionary .