Introduction
Evolutionary change in the rates or durations of developmental events, leading to structural changes In evolutionary developmental biology, heterochrony is any genetically controlled difference in the timing, rate, or duration of a developmental process in an organism compared to its ancestors or other .Evolutionary change in the rates or durations of developmental events, leading to structural changes In evolutionary developmental biology, heterochrony is any genetically controlled difference in the timing, rate, or duration of a developmental process in an organism compared to its ancestors or other .
This leads to changes in the size, shape, characteristics and even presence of certain organs and .This leads to changes in the size, shape, characteristics and even presence of certain organs and .
It is contrasted with heterotopy, a change in spatial positioning of some process in the embryo, which can also create morphological .It is contrasted with heterotopy, a change in spatial positioning of some process in the embryo, which can also create morphological .
Heterochrony can be divided into intraspecific heterochrony, variation within a species, and interspecific heterochrony, phylogenetic variation, i. e. variation of a descendant species with respect to an ancestral .Heterochrony can be divided into intraspecific heterochrony, variation within a species, and interspecific heterochrony, phylogenetic variation, i. e. variation of a descendant species with respect to an ancestral .
These changes all affect the start, end, rate or time span of a particular developmental .These changes all affect the start, end, rate or time span of a particular developmental .
The concept of heterochrony was introduced by Ernst Haeckel in 1875 and given its modern sense by Gavin de Beer in .The concept of heterochrony was introduced by Ernst Haeckel in 1875 and given its modern sense by Gavin de Beer in .
History
[[File:Haeckel vs von .[[File:Haeckel vs von .
svg|thumb|upright=1.5|Ernst Haeckel supposed that embryonic development recapitulated an animal's phylogeny, and introduced heterochrony as an exception for individual .svg|thumb|upright=1.5|Ernst Haeckel supposed that embryonic development recapitulated an animal's phylogeny, and introduced heterochrony as an exception for individual .
Modern biology agrees instead with Karl Ernst von Baer's view that development itself varies, such as by changing the timing of different processes, to cause a branching .Modern biology agrees instead with Karl Ernst von Baer's view that development itself varies, such as by changing the timing of different processes, to cause a branching .
As Stephen Jay Gould pointed out, Haeckel's term is now used in a sense contrary to his coinage; Haeckel had assumed that embryonic development (ontogeny) of "higher" animals recapitulated their ancestral development (phylogeny), as when mammal embryos have structures on the neck that resemble fish gills at one .As Stephen Jay Gould pointed out, Haeckel's term is now used in a sense contrary to his coinage; Haeckel had assumed that embryonic development (ontogeny) of "higher" animals recapitulated their ancestral development (phylogeny), as when mammal embryos have structures on the neck that resemble fish gills at one .
This, in his view, necessarily compressed the earlier developmental stages, representing the ancestors, into a shorter time, meaning accelerated .This, in his view, necessarily compressed the earlier developmental stages, representing the ancestors, into a shorter time, meaning accelerated .
The ideal for Haeckel would be when the development of every part of an organism was thus accelerated, but he recognised that some organs could develop with displacements in position (heterotopy, another concept he originated) or time (heterochrony), as exceptions to his .The ideal for Haeckel would be when the development of every part of an organism was thus accelerated, but he recognised that some organs could develop with displacements in position (heterotopy, another concept he originated) or time (heterochrony), as exceptions to his .
He thus intended the term to mean a change in the timing of the embryonic development of one organ with respect to the rest of the same animal, whereas it is now used, following the work of the British evolutionary embryologist Gavin de Beer in 1930, to mean a change with respect to the development of the same organ in the animal's .He thus intended the term to mean a change in the timing of the embryonic development of one organ with respect to the rest of the same animal, whereas it is now used, following the work of the British evolutionary embryologist Gavin de Beer in 1930, to mean a change with respect to the development of the same organ in the animal's .
In 1928, the English embryologist Walter Garstang showed that tunicate larvae shared structures such as the notochord with adult vertebrates, and suggested that the vertebrates arose by paedomorphosis (neoteny) from such a .In 1928, the English embryologist Walter Garstang showed that tunicate larvae shared structures such as the notochord with adult vertebrates, and suggested that the vertebrates arose by paedomorphosis (neoteny) from such a .
The proposal implied (if it were correct) a shared phylogeny of tunicates and vertebrates, and that heterochrony was a principal mechanism of evolutionary .The proposal implied (if it were correct) a shared phylogeny of tunicates and vertebrates, and that heterochrony was a principal mechanism of evolutionary .
showing that evolution could occur by heterochrony, such as in paedomorphosis, the retention of juvenile features in the .showing that evolution could occur by heterochrony, such as in paedomorphosis, the retention of juvenile features in the .
Mechanisms
thumb|upright=1.7| Diagram of the six types of shift in heterochrony, a change in the timing or rate of any process in embryonic .thumb|upright=1.7| Diagram of the six types of shift in heterochrony, a change in the timing or rate of any process in embryonic .
Predisplacement, hypermorphosis, and acceleration extend development (peramorphosis, in red); postdisplacement, hypomorphosis, and deceleration all These may be combined, e. g. to shift some aspect of development .Predisplacement, hypermorphosis, and acceleration extend development (peramorphosis, in red); postdisplacement, hypomorphosis, and deceleration all These may be combined, e. g. to shift some aspect of development .
Heterochrony can be divided into intraspecific and interspecific .Heterochrony can be divided into intraspecific and interspecific .
Intraspecific heterochrony means changes in the rate or timing of development within a .Intraspecific heterochrony means changes in the rate or timing of development within a .
For example, some individuals of the salamander species Ambystoma talpoideum delay the metamorphosis of the .For example, some individuals of the salamander species Ambystoma talpoideum delay the metamorphosis of the .
Reilly and colleagues argue we can define these variant individuals as paedotypic (with truncated development relative to the ancestral condition), peratypic (with extended development relative to the ancestral condition), or isotypic (reaching the same ancestral shape, but via a different ).Reilly and colleagues argue we can define these variant individuals as paedotypic (with truncated development relative to the ancestral condition), peratypic (with extended development relative to the ancestral condition), or isotypic (reaching the same ancestral shape, but via a different ).
each of which can change in either of two directions, giving six types of perturbations, which can be combined in various .each of which can change in either of two directions, giving six types of perturbations, which can be combined in various .
These ultimately result in extended, shifted, or truncated development of a particular process, such as the action of a single toolkit gene, relative to the ancestral condition or to other conspecifics, depending on whether inter or intraspecific heterochrony is the .These ultimately result in extended, shifted, or truncated development of a particular process, such as the action of a single toolkit gene, relative to the ancestral condition or to other conspecifics, depending on whether inter or intraspecific heterochrony is the .
Identifying which of the six perturbations is occurring is critical in identifying the actual underlying mechanism driving peramorphosis or .Identifying which of the six perturbations is occurring is critical in identifying the actual underlying mechanism driving peramorphosis or .
Giraffes gain their long necks by a different heterochrony, extending the development of their cervical vertebrae; they retain the usual mammalian number of these vertebrae, .Giraffes gain their long necks by a different heterochrony, extending the development of their cervical vertebrae; they retain the usual mammalian number of these vertebrae, .
Detection
Heterochrony can be identified by comparing phylogenetically close species, for example a group of different bird species whose legs differ in their average .Heterochrony can be identified by comparing phylogenetically close species, for example a group of different bird species whose legs differ in their average .
These comparisons are complex because there are no universal ontogenetic .These comparisons are complex because there are no universal ontogenetic .
The method of event pairing attempts to overcome this by comparing the relative timing of two events at a .The method of event pairing attempts to overcome this by comparing the relative timing of two events at a .
This method detects event heterochronies, as opposed to allometric .This method detects event heterochronies, as opposed to allometric .
It is cumbersome to use because the number of event pair characters increases with the square of the number of events .It is cumbersome to use because the number of event pair characters increases with the square of the number of events .
Event pairing can however be automated, for instance with the PARSIMOV .Event pairing can however be automated, for instance with the PARSIMOV .
A recent method, continuous analysis, rests on a simple standardization of ontogenetic time or sequences, on squared change parsimony and phylogenetic independent .A recent method, continuous analysis, rests on a simple standardization of ontogenetic time or sequences, on squared change parsimony and phylogenetic independent .
Paedomorphosis
thumb| Axolotls retain gills and fins as adults; these are juvenile features in most .thumb| Axolotls retain gills and fins as adults; these are juvenile features in most .
Paedomorphosis can be the result of neoteny, the retention of juvenile traits into the adult form as a result of retardation of somatic development, or of progenesis, the acceleration of developmental processes such that the juvenile form becomes a sexually mature .Paedomorphosis can be the result of neoteny, the retention of juvenile traits into the adult form as a result of retardation of somatic development, or of progenesis, the acceleration of developmental processes such that the juvenile form becomes a sexually mature .
This means that in progenesis, germ cell growth is accelerated relative to normal or in neoteny; while somatic cell growth is normal in progenesis, but retarded in .This means that in progenesis, germ cell growth is accelerated relative to normal or in neoteny; while somatic cell growth is normal in progenesis, but retarded in .
Neoteny retards the development of the organism into an adult, and has been described as "eternal ".Neoteny retards the development of the organism into an adult, and has been described as "eternal ".
In this form of heterochrony, the developmental stage of childhood is itself extended, and certain developmental processes that normally take place only during childhood (such as accelerated brain growth in humans), is also extended throughout this .In this form of heterochrony, the developmental stage of childhood is itself extended, and certain developmental processes that normally take place only during childhood (such as accelerated brain growth in humans), is also extended throughout this .
Neoteny has been implicated as a developmental cause for a number of behavior changes, as a result of increased brain plasticity and extended .Neoteny has been implicated as a developmental cause for a number of behavior changes, as a result of increased brain plasticity and extended .
Progenesis (or paedogenesis) can be observed in the axolotl (Ambystoma ).Progenesis (or paedogenesis) can be observed in the axolotl (Ambystoma ).
Axolotls reach full sexual maturity while retaining their fins and gills (in other words, still in the juvenile form of their ).Axolotls reach full sexual maturity while retaining their fins and gills (in other words, still in the juvenile form of their ).
They will remain in aquatic environments in this truncated developmental form, rather than moving onto land as other sexually mature salamander .They will remain in aquatic environments in this truncated developmental form, rather than moving onto land as other sexually mature salamander .
This is thought to be a form of hypomorphosis (earlier ending of development) that is both hormonally and genetically .This is thought to be a form of hypomorphosis (earlier ending of development) that is both hormonally and genetically .
Paedomorphosis by progenesis may play a critical role in avian cranial .Paedomorphosis by progenesis may play a critical role in avian cranial .
The skulls and beaks of living, adult birds retain the anatomy of the juvenile theropod dinosaurs from which they .The skulls and beaks of living, adult birds retain the anatomy of the juvenile theropod dinosaurs from which they .
Extant birds have large eyes and brains relative to the rest of the skull; a condition seen in adult birds that represents (broadly speaking) the juvenile stage of a .Extant birds have large eyes and brains relative to the rest of the skull; a condition seen in adult birds that represents (broadly speaking) the juvenile stage of a .
A juvenile avian ancestor (as typified by Coelophysis) would have a short face, large eyes, a thin palate, narrow jugal bone, tall and thin postorbitals, restricted adductors, and a short and bulbous .A juvenile avian ancestor (as typified by Coelophysis) would have a short face, large eyes, a thin palate, narrow jugal bone, tall and thin postorbitals, restricted adductors, and a short and bulbous .
As an organism such as this aged, they would change greatly in their cranial morphology to develop a robust skull with larger, overlapping .As an organism such as this aged, they would change greatly in their cranial morphology to develop a robust skull with larger, overlapping .
Birds, however, retain this juvenile .Birds, however, retain this juvenile .
These signalling pathways are known to play roles in facial patterning in other vertebrate .These signalling pathways are known to play roles in facial patterning in other vertebrate .
This retention of the juvenile ancestral state has driven other changes in the anatomy that result in a light, highly kinetic (moveable) skull composed of many small, non overlapping .This retention of the juvenile ancestral state has driven other changes in the anatomy that result in a light, highly kinetic (moveable) skull composed of many small, non overlapping .
This is believed to have facilitated the evolution of cranial kinesis in birds Another example of peramorphosis is seen in insular (island) .This is believed to have facilitated the evolution of cranial kinesis in birds Another example of peramorphosis is seen in insular (island) .
Their characteristics include gigantism, wider cheek and teeth, reduced litter size, and longer .Their characteristics include gigantism, wider cheek and teeth, reduced litter size, and longer .
Their relatives that inhabit continental environments are much .Their relatives that inhabit continental environments are much .
Insular rodents have evolved these features to accommodate the abundance of food and resources they have on their .Insular rodents have evolved these features to accommodate the abundance of food and resources they have on their .
These factors are part of a complex phenomenon termed Island syndrome or Foster's .These factors are part of a complex phenomenon termed Island syndrome or Foster's .
The mole salamander, a close relative to the axolotl, displays both paedomorphosis and .The mole salamander, a close relative to the axolotl, displays both paedomorphosis and .
The larva can develop in either .The larva can develop in either .
Population density, food, and the amount of water may have an effect on the expression of .Population density, food, and the amount of water may have an effect on the expression of .
A study conducted on the mole salamander in 1987 found it evident that a higher percentage of individuals became paedomorphic when there was a low larval population density in a constant water level as opposed to a high larval population density in drying .A study conducted on the mole salamander in 1987 found it evident that a higher percentage of individuals became paedomorphic when there was a low larval population density in a constant water level as opposed to a high larval population density in drying .
This had an implication that led to hypotheses that selective pressures imposed by the environment, such as predation and loss of resources, were instrumental to the cause of these .This had an implication that led to hypotheses that selective pressures imposed by the environment, such as predation and loss of resources, were instrumental to the cause of these .
These ideas were reinforced by other studies, such as peramorphosis in the Puerto Rican tree .These ideas were reinforced by other studies, such as peramorphosis in the Puerto Rican tree .
Another reason could be generation time, or the lifespan of the species in .Another reason could be generation time, or the lifespan of the species in .
When a species has a relatively short lifespan, natural selection favors evolution of paedomorphosis (e. g. Axolotl: 7–10 ).When a species has a relatively short lifespan, natural selection favors evolution of paedomorphosis (e. g. Axolotl: 7–10 ).
Conversely, in long lifespans natural selection favors evolution of peramorphosis (e. g. Irish Elk: 20–22 ).Conversely, in long lifespans natural selection favors evolution of peramorphosis (e. g. Irish Elk: 20–22 ).
such as the lengthening of the fingers by adding extra phalanges in dolphins to form their flippers, sexual dimorphism, and the polymorphism seen between insect .
thumb|A 1901 comparison of a frog tadpole (a vertebrate) and a tunicate larva; in 1928 Walter Garstang proposed that vertebrates derived from such a larva by .thumb|A 1901 comparison of a frog tadpole (a vertebrate) and a tunicate larva; in 1928 Walter Garstang proposed that vertebrates derived from such a larva by .
In humans
Several heterochronies have been described in humans, relative to the .Several heterochronies have been described in humans, relative to the .
In chimpanzee fetuses, brain and head growth starts at about the same developmental stage and grow at a rate similar to that of humans, but growth stops soon after birth, whereas humans continue brain and head growth several years after .In chimpanzee fetuses, brain and head growth starts at about the same developmental stage and grow at a rate similar to that of humans, but growth stops soon after birth, whereas humans continue brain and head growth several years after .
This particular type of heterochrony, hypermorphosis, involves a delay in the offset of a developmental process, or what is the same, the presence of an early developmental process in later stages of .This particular type of heterochrony, hypermorphosis, involves a delay in the offset of a developmental process, or what is the same, the presence of an early developmental process in later stages of .
Humans have some 30 different neotenies in comparison to the chimpanzee, retaining larger heads, smaller jaws and noses, and shorter limbs, features found in juvenile .Humans have some 30 different neotenies in comparison to the chimpanzee, retaining larger heads, smaller jaws and noses, and shorter limbs, features found in juvenile .
Related concepts
The term "heterokairy" was proposed in 2003 by John Spicer and Warren Burggren to distinguish plasticity in timing of the onset of developmental events at the level of an individual (heterokairy) or population ).The term "heterokairy" was proposed in 2003 by John Spicer and Warren Burggren to distinguish plasticity in timing of the onset of developmental events at the level of an individual (heterokairy) or population ).