Introduction
Comparison of organism developmental processes Evolutionary developmental biology (informally, evo devo) is a field of biological research that compares the developmental processes of different organisms to infer how developmental processes .Comparison of organism developmental processes Evolutionary developmental biology (informally, evo devo) is a field of biological research that compares the developmental processes of different organisms to infer how developmental processes .
The field grew from 19th century beginnings, where embryology faced a mystery: zoologists did not know how embryonic development was controlled at the molecular .The field grew from 19th century beginnings, where embryology faced a mystery: zoologists did not know how embryonic development was controlled at the molecular .
Charles Darwin noted that having similar embryos implied common ancestry, but little progress was made until the .Charles Darwin noted that having similar embryos implied common ancestry, but little progress was made until the .
Then, recombinant DNA technology at last brought embryology together with molecular .Then, recombinant DNA technology at last brought embryology together with molecular .
A key early discovery was of homeotic genes that regulate development in a wide range of .A key early discovery was of homeotic genes that regulate development in a wide range of .
The field is composed of multiple core evolutionary .The field is composed of multiple core evolutionary .
One is deep homology, the finding that dissimilar organs such as the eyes of insects, vertebrates and cephalopod molluscs, long thought to have evolved separately, are controlled by similar genes such as pax 6, from the evo devo gene .One is deep homology, the finding that dissimilar organs such as the eyes of insects, vertebrates and cephalopod molluscs, long thought to have evolved separately, are controlled by similar genes such as pax 6, from the evo devo gene .
These genes are ancient, being highly conserved among phyla; they generate the patterns in time and space which shape the embryo, and ultimately form the body plan of the .These genes are ancient, being highly conserved among phyla; they generate the patterns in time and space which shape the embryo, and ultimately form the body plan of the .
Another is that species do not differ much in their structural genes, such as those coding for enzymes; what does differ is the way that gene expression is regulated by the toolkit .Another is that species do not differ much in their structural genes, such as those coding for enzymes; what does differ is the way that gene expression is regulated by the toolkit .
These genes are reused, unchanged, many times in different parts of the embryo and at different stages of development, forming a complex cascade of control, switching other regulatory genes as well as structural genes on and off in a precise .These genes are reused, unchanged, many times in different parts of the embryo and at different stages of development, forming a complex cascade of control, switching other regulatory genes as well as structural genes on and off in a precise .
This multiple pleiotropic reuse explains why these genes are highly conserved, as any change would have many adverse consequences which natural selection would .This multiple pleiotropic reuse explains why these genes are highly conserved, as any change would have many adverse consequences which natural selection would .
New morphological features and ultimately new species are produced by variations in the toolkit, either when genes are expressed in a new pattern, or when toolkit genes acquire additional .New morphological features and ultimately new species are produced by variations in the toolkit, either when genes are expressed in a new pattern, or when toolkit genes acquire additional .
Another possibility is the neo Lamarckian theory that epigenetic changes are later consolidated at gene level, something that may have been important early in the history of multicellular .Another possibility is the neo Lamarckian theory that epigenetic changes are later consolidated at gene level, something that may have been important early in the history of multicellular .
Early theories
Philosophers began to think about how animals acquired form in the womb in classical .Philosophers began to think about how animals acquired form in the womb in classical .
Aristotle asserts in his Physics treatise that according to Empedocles, order "spontaneously" appears in the developing .Aristotle asserts in his Physics treatise that according to Empedocles, order "spontaneously" appears in the developing .
In his The Parts of Animals treatise, he argues that Empedocles' theory was .In his The Parts of Animals treatise, he argues that Empedocles' theory was .
In Aristotle's account, Empedocles stated that the vertebral column is divided into vertebrae because, as it happens, the embryo twists about and snaps the column into .In Aristotle's account, Empedocles stated that the vertebral column is divided into vertebrae because, as it happens, the embryo twists about and snaps the column into .
Aristotle argues instead that the process has a predefined goal: that the "seed" that develops into the embryo began with an inbuilt "potential" to become specific body parts, such as .Aristotle argues instead that the process has a predefined goal: that the "seed" that develops into the embryo began with an inbuilt "potential" to become specific body parts, such as .
Further, each sort of animal gives rise to animals of its own kind: humans only have human .Further, each sort of animal gives rise to animals of its own kind: humans only have human .
Recapitulation
A recapitulation theory of evolutionary development was proposed by Étienne Serres in 1824–26, echoing the 1808 ideas of Johann Friedrich .A recapitulation theory of evolutionary development was proposed by Étienne Serres in 1824–26, echoing the 1808 ideas of Johann Friedrich .
They argued that the embryos of 'higher' animals went through or recapitulated a series of stages, each of which resembled an animal lower down the great chain of .They argued that the embryos of 'higher' animals went through or recapitulated a series of stages, each of which resembled an animal lower down the great chain of .
For example, the brain of a human embryo looked first like that of a fish, then in turn like that of a reptile, bird, and mammal before becoming clearly .For example, the brain of a human embryo looked first like that of a fish, then in turn like that of a reptile, bird, and mammal before becoming clearly .
The embryologist Karl Ernst von Baer opposed this, arguing in 1828 that there was no linear sequence as in the great chain of being, based on a single body plan, but a process of epigenesis in which structures .The embryologist Karl Ernst von Baer opposed this, arguing in 1828 that there was no linear sequence as in the great chain of being, based on a single body plan, but a process of epigenesis in which structures .
Von Baer instead recognized four distinct animal body plans: radiate, like starfish; molluscan, like clams; articulate, like lobsters; and vertebrate, like .Von Baer instead recognized four distinct animal body plans: radiate, like starfish; molluscan, like clams; articulate, like lobsters; and vertebrate, like .
Zoologists then largely abandoned recapitulation, though Ernst Haeckel revived it in .Zoologists then largely abandoned recapitulation, though Ernst Haeckel revived it in .
Evolutionary morphology
From the early 19th century through most of the 20th century, embryology faced a .From the early 19th century through most of the 20th century, embryology faced a .
Animals were seen to develop into adults of widely differing body plan, often through similar stages, from the egg, but zoologists knew almost nothing about how embryonic development was controlled at the molecular level, and therefore equally little about how developmental processes had .Animals were seen to develop into adults of widely differing body plan, often through similar stages, from the egg, but zoologists knew almost nothing about how embryonic development was controlled at the molecular level, and therefore equally little about how developmental processes had .
Charles Darwin argued that a shared embryonic structure implied a common .Charles Darwin argued that a shared embryonic structure implied a common .
For example, Darwin cited in his 1859 book On the Origin of Species the shrimp like larva of the barnacle, whose sessile adults looked nothing like other arthropods; Linnaeus and Cuvier had classified them as .For example, Darwin cited in his 1859 book On the Origin of Species the shrimp like larva of the barnacle, whose sessile adults looked nothing like other arthropods; Linnaeus and Cuvier had classified them as .
Darwin also noted Alexander Kowalevsky's finding that the tunicate, too, was not a mollusc, but in its larval stage had a notochord and pharyngeal slits which developed from the same germ layers as the equivalent structures in vertebrates, and should therefore be grouped with them as .Darwin also noted Alexander Kowalevsky's finding that the tunicate, too, was not a mollusc, but in its larval stage had a notochord and pharyngeal slits which developed from the same germ layers as the equivalent structures in vertebrates, and should therefore be grouped with them as .
19th century zoology thus converted embryology into an evolutionary science, connecting phylogeny with homologies between the germ layers of .19th century zoology thus converted embryology into an evolutionary science, connecting phylogeny with homologies between the germ layers of .
Zoologists including Fritz Müller proposed the use of embryology to discover phylogenetic relationships between .Zoologists including Fritz Müller proposed the use of embryology to discover phylogenetic relationships between .
Müller demonstrated that crustaceans shared the Nauplius larva, identifying several parasitic species that had not been recognized as .Müller demonstrated that crustaceans shared the Nauplius larva, identifying several parasitic species that had not been recognized as .
Müller also recognized that natural selection must act on larvae, just as it does on adults, giving the lie to recapitulation, which would require larval forms to be shielded from natural .Müller also recognized that natural selection must act on larvae, just as it does on adults, giving the lie to recapitulation, which would require larval forms to be shielded from natural .
In 1917, D'Arcy Thompson wrote a book on the shapes of animals, showing with simple mathematics how small changes to parameters, such as the angles of a gastropod's spiral shell, can radically alter an animal's form, though he preferred a mechanical to evolutionary .In 1917, D'Arcy Thompson wrote a book on the shapes of animals, showing with simple mathematics how small changes to parameters, such as the angles of a gastropod's spiral shell, can radically alter an animal's form, though he preferred a mechanical to evolutionary .
But without molecular evidence, progress .But without molecular evidence, progress .
He modelled catalysed chemical reactions using partial differential equations, showing that patterns emerged when the chemical reaction produced both a catalyst (A) and an inhibitor (B) that slowed down production of .He modelled catalysed chemical reactions using partial differential equations, showing that patterns emerged when the chemical reaction produced both a catalyst (A) and an inhibitor (B) that slowed down production of .
If A and B then diffused at different rates, A dominated in some places, and B in .If A and B then diffused at different rates, A dominated in some places, and B in .
The Russian biochemist Boris Belousov had run experiments with similar results, but was unable to publish them because scientists thought at that time that creating visible order violated the second law of .The Russian biochemist Boris Belousov had run experiments with similar results, but was unable to publish them because scientists thought at that time that creating visible order violated the second law of .
The modern synthesis of the early 20th century
In the so called modern synthesis of the early 20th century, between 1918 and 1930 Ronald Fisher brought together Darwin's theory of evolution, with its insistence on natural selection, heredity, and variation, and Gregor Mendel's laws of genetics into a coherent structure for evolutionary .In the so called modern synthesis of the early 20th century, between 1918 and 1930 Ronald Fisher brought together Darwin's theory of evolution, with its insistence on natural selection, heredity, and variation, and Gregor Mendel's laws of genetics into a coherent structure for evolutionary .
Biologists assumed that an organism was a straightforward reflection of its component genes: the genes coded for proteins, which built the organism's .Biologists assumed that an organism was a straightforward reflection of its component genes: the genes coded for proteins, which built the organism's .
Biochemical pathways (and, they supposed, new species) evolved through mutations in these .Biochemical pathways (and, they supposed, new species) evolved through mutations in these .
It was a simple, clear and nearly comprehensive picture: but it did not explain .It was a simple, clear and nearly comprehensive picture: but it did not explain .
Sean B. Carroll has commented that had evo devo's insights been available, embryology would certainly have played a central role in the .Sean B. Carroll has commented that had evo devo's insights been available, embryology would certainly have played a central role in the .
by showing that evolution could occur by heterochrony, such as in the retention of juvenile features in the .by showing that evolution could occur by heterochrony, such as in the retention of juvenile features in the .
However, despite de Beer, the modern synthesis largely ignored embryonic development to explain the form of organisms, since population genetics appeared to be an adequate explanation of how forms .However, despite de Beer, the modern synthesis largely ignored embryonic development to explain the form of organisms, since population genetics appeared to be an adequate explanation of how forms .
The lac operon
In 1961, Jacques Monod, Jean Pierre Changeux and François Jacob discovered the lac operon in the bacterium Escherichia .In 1961, Jacques Monod, Jean Pierre Changeux and François Jacob discovered the lac operon in the bacterium Escherichia .
It was a cluster of genes, arranged in a feedback control loop so that its products would only be made when "switched on" by an environmental .It was a cluster of genes, arranged in a feedback control loop so that its products would only be made when "switched on" by an environmental .
One of these products was an enzyme that splits a sugar, lactose; and lactose itself was the stimulus that switched the genes .One of these products was an enzyme that splits a sugar, lactose; and lactose itself was the stimulus that switched the genes .
This was a revelation, as it showed for the first time that genes, even in organisms as small as a bacterium, are subject to precise .This was a revelation, as it showed for the first time that genes, even in organisms as small as a bacterium, are subject to precise .
The implication was that many other genes were also elaborately .The implication was that many other genes were also elaborately .
The birth of evo-devo and a second synthesis
In 1977, a revolution in thinking about evolution and developmental biology began, with the arrival of recombinant DNA technology in genetics, the book Ontogeny and Phylogeny by Stephen J. Gould and the paper "Evolution and Tinkering" by François .In 1977, a revolution in thinking about evolution and developmental biology began, with the arrival of recombinant DNA technology in genetics, the book Ontogeny and Phylogeny by Stephen J. Gould and the paper "Evolution and Tinkering" by François .
Gould laid to rest Haeckel's interpretation of evolutionary embryology, while Jacob set out an alternative .Gould laid to rest Haeckel's interpretation of evolutionary embryology, while Jacob set out an alternative .
at last including embryology as well as molecular genetics, phylogeny, and evolutionary biology to form evo .at last including embryology as well as molecular genetics, phylogeny, and evolutionary biology to form evo .
In 1978, Edward B. Lewis discovered homeotic genes that regulate embryonic development in Drosophila fruit flies, which like all insects are arthropods, one of the major phyla of invertebrate .In 1978, Edward B. Lewis discovered homeotic genes that regulate embryonic development in Drosophila fruit flies, which like all insects are arthropods, one of the major phyla of invertebrate .
Bill McGinnis quickly discovered homeotic gene sequences, homeoboxes, in animals in other phyla, in vertebrates such as frogs, birds, and mammals; they were later also found in fungi such as yeasts, and in .Bill McGinnis quickly discovered homeotic gene sequences, homeoboxes, in animals in other phyla, in vertebrates such as frogs, birds, and mammals; they were later also found in fungi such as yeasts, and in .
There were evidently strong similarities in the genes that controlled development across all the .There were evidently strong similarities in the genes that controlled development across all the .
In 1980, Christiane Nüsslein Volhard and Eric Wieschaus described gap genes which help to create the segmentation pattern in fruit fly embryos; they and Lewis won a Nobel Prize for their work in .In 1980, Christiane Nüsslein Volhard and Eric Wieschaus described gap genes which help to create the segmentation pattern in fruit fly embryos; they and Lewis won a Nobel Prize for their work in .
Later, more specific similarities were discovered: for example, the Distal less gene was found in 1989 to be involved in the development of appendages or limbs in fruit flies, the fins of fish, the wings of chickens, the parapodia of marine annelid worms, the ampullae and siphons of tunicates, and the tube feet of sea .Later, more specific similarities were discovered: for example, the Distal less gene was found in 1989 to be involved in the development of appendages or limbs in fruit flies, the fins of fish, the wings of chickens, the parapodia of marine annelid worms, the ampullae and siphons of tunicates, and the tube feet of sea .
It was evident that the gene must be ancient, dating back to the last common ancestor of bilateral animals (before the Ediacaran Period, which began some 635 million years ).It was evident that the gene must be ancient, dating back to the last common ancestor of bilateral animals (before the Ediacaran Period, which began some 635 million years ).
Evo devo had started to uncover the ways that all animal bodies were built during .Evo devo had started to uncover the ways that all animal bodies were built during .
Deep homology
Roughly spherical eggs of different animals give rise to unique morphologies, from jellyfish to lobsters, butterflies to .Roughly spherical eggs of different animals give rise to unique morphologies, from jellyfish to lobsters, butterflies to .
Many of these organisms share the same structural genes for bodybuilding proteins like collagen and enzymes, but biologists had expected that each group of animals would have its own rules of .Many of these organisms share the same structural genes for bodybuilding proteins like collagen and enzymes, but biologists had expected that each group of animals would have its own rules of .
The surprise of evo devo is that the shaping of bodies is controlled by a rather small percentage of genes, and that these regulatory genes are ancient, shared by all .The surprise of evo devo is that the shaping of bodies is controlled by a rather small percentage of genes, and that these regulatory genes are ancient, shared by all .
The giraffe does not have a gene for a long neck, any more than the elephant has a gene for a big .The giraffe does not have a gene for a long neck, any more than the elephant has a gene for a big .
Their bodies are patterned by a system of switching which causes development of different features to begin earlier or later, to occur in this or that part of the embryo, and to continue for more or less .Their bodies are patterned by a system of switching which causes development of different features to begin earlier or later, to occur in this or that part of the embryo, and to continue for more or less .
Using such a technique, in 1994 Walter Gehring found that the pax 6 gene, vital for forming the eyes of fruit flies, exactly matches an eye forming gene in mice and .Using such a technique, in 1994 Walter Gehring found that the pax 6 gene, vital for forming the eyes of fruit flies, exactly matches an eye forming gene in mice and .
The same gene was quickly found in many other groups of animals, such as squid, a cephalopod .The same gene was quickly found in many other groups of animals, such as squid, a cephalopod .
Biologists including Ernst Mayr had believed that eyes had arisen in the animal kingdom at least 40 times, as the anatomy of different types of eye varies .Biologists including Ernst Mayr had believed that eyes had arisen in the animal kingdom at least 40 times, as the anatomy of different types of eye varies .
The evidence of pax 6, however, was that the same genes controlled the development of the eyes of all these animals, suggesting that they all evolved from a common .The evidence of pax 6, however, was that the same genes controlled the development of the eyes of all these animals, suggesting that they all evolved from a common .
This notion was later extended to the evolution of embryogenesis and has caused a radical revision of the meaning of homology in evolutionary .This notion was later extended to the evolution of embryogenesis and has caused a radical revision of the meaning of homology in evolutionary .
Although other toolkit genes are involved in establishing the plant bodyplan, homeobox genes are also found in plants, implying they are common to all .Although other toolkit genes are involved in establishing the plant bodyplan, homeobox genes are also found in plants, implying they are common to all .
The embryo's regulatory networks
The protein products of the regulatory toolkit are reused not by duplication and modification, but by a complex mosaic of pleiotropy, being applied unchanged in many independent developmental processes, giving pattern to many dissimilar body .The protein products of the regulatory toolkit are reused not by duplication and modification, but by a complex mosaic of pleiotropy, being applied unchanged in many independent developmental processes, giving pattern to many dissimilar body .
The Bicoid, Hunchback and Caudal proteins in turn regulate the transcription of gap genes such as giant, knirps, Krüppel, and tailless in a striped pattern, creating the first level of structures that will become .The Bicoid, Hunchback and Caudal proteins in turn regulate the transcription of gap genes such as giant, knirps, Krüppel, and tailless in a striped pattern, creating the first level of structures that will become .
Another process, gastrulation of the embryo, is driven by Myosin II molecular motors, which are not conserved across .Another process, gastrulation of the embryo, is driven by Myosin II molecular motors, which are not conserved across .
The process may have been started by movements of sea water in the environment, later replaced by the evolution of tissue movements in the .The process may have been started by movements of sea water in the environment, later replaced by the evolution of tissue movements in the .
The origins of novelty
Among the more surprising and, perhaps, counterintuitive (from a neo Darwinian viewpoint) results of recent research in evolutionary developmental biology is that the diversity of body plans and morphology in organisms across many phyla are not necessarily reflected in diversity at the level of the sequences of genes, including those of the developmental genetic toolkit and other genes involved in .Among the more surprising and, perhaps, counterintuitive (from a neo Darwinian viewpoint) results of recent research in evolutionary developmental biology is that the diversity of body plans and morphology in organisms across many phyla are not necessarily reflected in diversity at the level of the sequences of genes, including those of the developmental genetic toolkit and other genes involved in .
Indeed, as John Gerhart and Marc Kirschner have noted, there is an apparent paradox: "where we most expect to find variation, we find conservation, a lack of ".Indeed, as John Gerhart and Marc Kirschner have noted, there is an apparent paradox: "where we most expect to find variation, we find conservation, a lack of ".
So, if the observed morphological novelty between different clades does not come from changes in gene sequences (such as by mutation), where does it come ?So, if the observed morphological novelty between different clades does not come from changes in gene sequences (such as by mutation), where does it come ?
Novelty may arise by mutation driven changes in gene .Novelty may arise by mutation driven changes in gene .
Variations in the toolkit
Variations in the toolkit may have produced a large part of the morphological evolution of .Variations in the toolkit may have produced a large part of the morphological evolution of .
The toolkit can drive evolution in two .The toolkit can drive evolution in two .
A toolkit gene can be expressed in a different pattern, as when the beak of Darwin's large ground finch was enlarged by the BMP gene, or when snakes lost their legs as distal less became under expressed or not expressed at all in the places where other reptiles continued to form their .A toolkit gene can be expressed in a different pattern, as when the beak of Darwin's large ground finch was enlarged by the BMP gene, or when snakes lost their legs as distal less became under expressed or not expressed at all in the places where other reptiles continued to form their .
Or, a toolkit gene can acquire a new function, as seen in the many functions of that same gene, distal less, which controls such diverse structures as the mandible in vertebrates, legs and antennae in the fruit fly, and eyespot pattern in butterfly .Or, a toolkit gene can acquire a new function, as seen in the many functions of that same gene, distal less, which controls such diverse structures as the mandible in vertebrates, legs and antennae in the fruit fly, and eyespot pattern in butterfly .
Given that small changes in toolbox genes can cause significant changes in body structures, they have often enabled the same function convergently or in .Given that small changes in toolbox genes can cause significant changes in body structures, they have often enabled the same function convergently or in .
distal less generates wing patterns in the butterflies Heliconius erato and Heliconius melpomene, which are Müllerian .distal less generates wing patterns in the butterflies Heliconius erato and Heliconius melpomene, which are Müllerian .
In so called facilitated variation, their wing patterns arose in different evolutionary events, but are controlled by the same .In so called facilitated variation, their wing patterns arose in different evolutionary events, but are controlled by the same .
Developmental changes can contribute directly to .Developmental changes can contribute directly to .
Consolidation of epigenetic changes
Evolutionary innovation may sometimes begin in Lamarckian style with epigenetic alterations of gene regulation or phenotype generation, subsequently consolidated by changes at the gene .Evolutionary innovation may sometimes begin in Lamarckian style with epigenetic alterations of gene regulation or phenotype generation, subsequently consolidated by changes at the gene .
Epigenetic changes include modification of DNA by reversible methylation, as well as nonprogrammed remoulding of the organism by physical and other environmental effects due to the inherent plasticity of developmental .Epigenetic changes include modification of DNA by reversible methylation, as well as nonprogrammed remoulding of the organism by physical and other environmental effects due to the inherent plasticity of developmental .
The biologists Stuart A. Newman and Gerd B. Müller have suggested that organisms early in the history of multicellular life were more susceptible to this second category of epigenetic determination than are modern organisms, providing a basis for early macroevolutionary .The biologists Stuart A. Newman and Gerd B. Müller have suggested that organisms early in the history of multicellular life were more susceptible to this second category of epigenetic determination than are modern organisms, providing a basis for early macroevolutionary .
Developmental bias
Development in specific lineages can be biased either positively, towards a given trajectory or phenotype,efn|Positive bias is sometimes called developmental .Development in specific lineages can be biased either positively, towards a given trajectory or phenotype,efn|Positive bias is sometimes called developmental .
For example, in the gastropods, the snail type shell is always built as a tube that grows both in length and in diameter; selection has created a wide variety of shell shapes such as flat spirals, cowries and tall turret spirals within these .For example, in the gastropods, the snail type shell is always built as a tube that grows both in length and in diameter; selection has created a wide variety of shell shapes such as flat spirals, cowries and tall turret spirals within these .
Among the centipedes, the Lithobiomorpha always have 15 trunk segments as adults, probably the result of a developmental bias towards an odd number of trunk .Among the centipedes, the Lithobiomorpha always have 15 trunk segments as adults, probably the result of a developmental bias towards an odd number of trunk .
Another centipede order, the Geophilomorpha, the number of segments varies in different species between 27 and 191, but the number is always odd, making this an absolute constraint; almost all the odd numbers in that range are occupied by one or another .Another centipede order, the Geophilomorpha, the number of segments varies in different species between 27 and 191, but the number is always odd, making this an absolute constraint; almost all the odd numbers in that range are occupied by one or another .
Ecological evolutionary developmental biology
Ecological evolutionary developmental biology integrates research from developmental biology and ecology to examine their relationship with evolutionary .Ecological evolutionary developmental biology integrates research from developmental biology and ecology to examine their relationship with evolutionary .
Researchers study concepts and mechanisms such as developmental plasticity, epigenetic inheritance, genetic assimilation, niche construction and .Researchers study concepts and mechanisms such as developmental plasticity, epigenetic inheritance, genetic assimilation, niche construction and .