Introduction

Book by Stephen Jay Gould Ontogeny and Phylogeny is a 1977 book on evolution by Stephen Jay Gould, in which the author explores the relationship between embryonic development (ontogeny) and biological evolution ).Book by Stephen Jay Gould Ontogeny and Phylogeny is a 1977 book on evolution by Stephen Jay Gould, in which the author explores the relationship between embryonic development (ontogeny) and biological evolution ).

Unlike his many popular books of essays, it was a technical book, and over the following decades it was influential in stimulating research into heterochrony (changes in the timing of embryonic development), which had been neglected since Ernst Haeckel's theory that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny had been largely .Unlike his many popular books of essays, it was a technical book, and over the following decades it was influential in stimulating research into heterochrony (changes in the timing of embryonic development), which had been neglected since Ernst Haeckel's theory that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny had been largely .

This helped to create the field of evolutionary developmental .This helped to create the field of evolutionary developmental .

Context

Ontogeny and Phylogeny is Stephen Jay Gould's first technical .Ontogeny and Phylogeny is Stephen Jay Gould's first technical .

He wrote that Ernst Mayr had suggested in passing that he write a book on .He wrote that Ernst Mayr had suggested in passing that he write a book on .

Gould stated he "only began it as a practice run to learn the style of lengthy exposition before embarking on my magnum opus about ."Gould stated he "only began it as a practice run to learn the style of lengthy exposition before embarking on my magnum opus about ."

This later work was published in 2002 as The Structure of Evolutionary .This later work was published in 2002 as The Structure of Evolutionary .

Publication

The book was published in 1977 by Belknap Press of Harvard University .The book was published in 1977 by Belknap Press of Harvard University .

Summary

The first half of the book explores Ernst Haeckel's biogenetic law (recapitulation)—the discredited idea that embryonic developmental stages replay the evolutionary transitions of adult forms of an organism's past descendants—and how this idea influenced thinking in biology, theology, and .The first half of the book explores Ernst Haeckel's biogenetic law (recapitulation)—the discredited idea that embryonic developmental stages replay the evolutionary transitions of adult forms of an organism's past descendants—and how this idea influenced thinking in biology, theology, and .

Gould begins with the ancient Greek philosopher Anaximander, showing that the ideas formed a tradition leading to the French naturalist Charles .Gould begins with the ancient Greek philosopher Anaximander, showing that the ideas formed a tradition leading to the French naturalist Charles .

Gould describes the recapitulationists in the 19th century, from the German Lorenz Oken and Johann Friedrich Meckel to the French Étienne .Gould describes the recapitulationists in the 19th century, from the German Lorenz Oken and Johann Friedrich Meckel to the French Étienne .

The book examines the criticism of the theory by the Baltic German Karl Ernst von Baer and the Swiss American Louis Agassiz, and relates 19th century phylogeny to Charles Darwin's 1859 theory of evolution, Haeckel's approach, and neo .The book examines the criticism of the theory by the Baltic German Karl Ernst von Baer and the Swiss American Louis Agassiz, and relates 19th century phylogeny to Charles Darwin's 1859 theory of evolution, Haeckel's approach, and neo .

A chapter examines the pervasive influence of recapitulationism on such subjects as criminal anthropology, racism, attitudes to child development and primary schooling, and to Freudian .A chapter examines the pervasive influence of recapitulationism on such subjects as criminal anthropology, racism, attitudes to child development and primary schooling, and to Freudian .

The second half of the book details how modern concepts such as heterochrony (changes in developmental timing) and neoteny (the retardation of developmental expression or growth rates) influence macroevolution (major evolutionary ).The second half of the book details how modern concepts such as heterochrony (changes in developmental timing) and neoteny (the retardation of developmental expression or growth rates) influence macroevolution (major evolutionary ).

Gould examines the ecological and evolutionary significance of heterochrony, with an analysis of its effect on insect metamorphosis and neoteny in .Gould examines the ecological and evolutionary significance of heterochrony, with an analysis of its effect on insect metamorphosis and neoteny in .

He ends by considering theories of neoteny in human evolution, including Louis Bolk's so called fetalization .He ends by considering theories of neoteny in human evolution, including Louis Bolk's so called fetalization .

Contemporary

The herpetologist David .

Wake, in Paleobiology, wrote that the topic was "at once so obviously important and so intrinsically difficult" that few people would tackle .Wake, in Paleobiology, wrote that the topic was "at once so obviously important and so intrinsically difficult" that few people would tackle .

The parallelism that Haeckel noted between ontogeny and phylogeny was, Wake observed, a strong argument for evolution, but hardly anyone dared to discuss .The parallelism that Haeckel noted between ontogeny and phylogeny was, Wake observed, a strong argument for evolution, but hardly anyone dared to discuss .

He called the book very good, and predicted that it would set the stage for "endless research", but found it also in a way unsatisfying, using "undigested theory from ecology to explain what is, as yet, .He called the book very good, and predicted that it would set the stage for "endless research", but found it also in a way unsatisfying, using "undigested theory from ecology to explain what is, as yet, .

Summing up, Wake calls the book "erudite, important, provocative, and controversial", but noted that it could have been much .Summing up, Wake calls the book "erudite, important, provocative, and controversial", but noted that it could have been much .

The embryologist Søren Løvtrup, in Systematic Zoology, noted that the book had two objectives, unexceptionably to gain practice, and "more dubious[ly]", to show that "in spite of the collapse of Haeckel's biogenetic law, the subject of parallels between ontogenesis and phylogenesis is still of importance to ".The embryologist Søren Løvtrup, in Systematic Zoology, noted that the book had two objectives, unexceptionably to gain practice, and "more dubious[ly]", to show that "in spite of the collapse of Haeckel's biogenetic law, the subject of parallels between ontogenesis and phylogenesis is still of importance to ".

In Løvtrup's view, this was because Haeckel's law had been refuted except where evolution had by chance happened to add to the end of .In Løvtrup's view, this was because Haeckel's law had been refuted except where evolution had by chance happened to add to the end of .

Gould had little new to report, as people knew half a century earlier that development could be modified at other stages; the book was "a great ."Gould had little new to report, as people knew half a century earlier that development could be modified at other stages; the book was "a great ."

Haeckel could "of course be of historical interest" but Gould had chosen not to research Haeckel's .Haeckel could "of course be of historical interest" but Gould had chosen not to research Haeckel's .

Work on "wrong theories" represented, Løvtrup wrote, "a terrible waste of effort and time, and block[ed] further ."Work on "wrong theories" represented, Løvtrup wrote, "a terrible waste of effort and time, and block[ed] further ."

The bulk of the book was fine, though of no interest to .The bulk of the book was fine, though of no interest to .

But the tenth chapter, "Retardation and Neoteny in Human Evolution", would "mislead a great many people" who would be unable to make an informed judgement about its .But the tenth chapter, "Retardation and Neoteny in Human Evolution", would "mislead a great many people" who would be unable to make an informed judgement about its .

Gould "turns out to be just as much of a teleologist and progressivist as the scholars of previous generations whom he appraises so .Gould "turns out to be just as much of a teleologist and progressivist as the scholars of previous generations whom he appraises so .

He notes that we associate 'cute' features with mammals of higher intelligence, features that show 'the common traits of babyhood: relatively large eyes, short face, smooth features, bulbous .He notes that we associate 'cute' features with mammals of higher intelligence, features that show 'the common traits of babyhood: relatively large eyes, short face, smooth features, bulbous .

The presence of this complex in advanced adult mammals argues for neoteny' (Gould p. )."The presence of this complex in advanced adult mammals argues for neoteny' (Gould p. )."

The zoologist A. J. Cain, in Nature, called it "a superb analysis of the use of ontogenetic analogy, the controversies over ontogeny and phylogeny, and the classification of the different processes observable in comparing different ."The zoologist A. J. Cain, in Nature, called it "a superb analysis of the use of ontogenetic analogy, the controversies over ontogeny and phylogeny, and the classification of the different processes observable in comparing different ."

It was a "massive book", in Cain's view excellently illustrated with often surprising examples, covering both the history and a functional interpretation of .It was a "massive book", in Cain's view excellently illustrated with often surprising examples, covering both the history and a functional interpretation of .

Cain found it refreshing to find someone who had a good word for Ernst Haeckel, and who did not "treat Charles Bonnet as a stupid monomaniac" but who brought out the relationship "between acquired characters and recapitulation in the work of the American neo ".Cain found it refreshing to find someone who had a good word for Ernst Haeckel, and who did not "treat Charles Bonnet as a stupid monomaniac" but who brought out the relationship "between acquired characters and recapitulation in the work of the American neo ".

M. Elizabeth Barnes, in The Embryo Project Encyclopedia, looking back at the book in 2014, writes that it became widely cited in evolutionary and developmental biology, encouraging research on acceleration and retardation of development (forms of heterochrony), and investigation of paedomorphosis in human .M. Elizabeth Barnes, in The Embryo Project Encyclopedia, looking back at the book in 2014, writes that it became widely cited in evolutionary and developmental biology, encouraging research on acceleration and retardation of development (forms of heterochrony), and investigation of paedomorphosis in human .

Barnes notes that "along with other work by Gould, such as 'The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm' [the book] is often credited for influencing the rise of a biological approach called evolutionary developmental biology or evo devo, which worked to integrate evolutionary and developmental ."Barnes notes that "along with other work by Gould, such as 'The Spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian Paradigm' [the book] is often credited for influencing the rise of a biological approach called evolutionary developmental biology or evo devo, which worked to integrate evolutionary and developmental ."