Introduction
Evolution, adaptation, and origin of birds the biological concept The scientific question of within which larger group of animals birds evolved has traditionally been called the "origin of ".Evolution, adaptation, and origin of birds the biological concept The scientific question of within which larger group of animals birds evolved has traditionally been called the "origin of ".
The present scientific consensus is that birds are a group of maniraptoran theropod dinosaurs that originated during the Mesozoic .The present scientific consensus is that birds are a group of maniraptoran theropod dinosaurs that originated during the Mesozoic .
A close relationship between birds and dinosaurs was first proposed in the nineteenth century after the discovery of the primitive bird Archaeopteryx in .A close relationship between birds and dinosaurs was first proposed in the nineteenth century after the discovery of the primitive bird Archaeopteryx in .
Birds and extinct non avian dinosaurs share many unique skeletal .Birds and extinct non avian dinosaurs share many unique skeletal .
Moreover, fossils of more than thirty species of non avian dinosaur with preserved feathers have been .Moreover, fossils of more than thirty species of non avian dinosaur with preserved feathers have been .
There are even very small dinosaurs, such as Microraptor and Anchiornis, which have long, vaned arm and leg feathers forming .There are even very small dinosaurs, such as Microraptor and Anchiornis, which have long, vaned arm and leg feathers forming .
The Jurassic basal avialan Pedopenna also shows these long foot .The Jurassic basal avialan Pedopenna also shows these long foot .
Paleontologist Lawrence Witmer concluded in 2009 that this evidence is sufficient to demonstrate that avian evolution went through a four winged .Paleontologist Lawrence Witmer concluded in 2009 that this evidence is sufficient to demonstrate that avian evolution went through a four winged .
In 1860, a fossilized feather was discovered in Germany's Late Jurassic Solnhofen .In 1860, a fossilized feather was discovered in Germany's Late Jurassic Solnhofen .
Christian Erich Hermann von Meyer described this feather as Archaeopteryx lithographica the next .Christian Erich Hermann von Meyer described this feather as Archaeopteryx lithographica the next .
Richard Owen described a nearly complete skeleton in 1863, recognizing it as a bird despite many features reminiscent of reptiles, including clawed forelimbs and a long, bony .Richard Owen described a nearly complete skeleton in 1863, recognizing it as a bird despite many features reminiscent of reptiles, including clawed forelimbs and a long, bony .
Biologist Thomas Henry Huxley, known as "Darwin's Bulldog" for his tenacious support of the new theory of evolution by means of natural selection, almost immediately seized upon Archaeopteryx as a transitional fossil between birds and .Biologist Thomas Henry Huxley, known as "Darwin's Bulldog" for his tenacious support of the new theory of evolution by means of natural selection, almost immediately seized upon Archaeopteryx as a transitional fossil between birds and .
Starting in 1868, and following earlier suggestions by Carl Gegenbaur, and Edward Drinker Cope, Huxley made detailed comparisons of Archaeopteryx with various prehistoric reptiles and found that it was most similar to dinosaurs like Hypsilophodon and .Starting in 1868, and following earlier suggestions by Carl Gegenbaur, and Edward Drinker Cope, Huxley made detailed comparisons of Archaeopteryx with various prehistoric reptiles and found that it was most similar to dinosaurs like Hypsilophodon and .
The discovery in the late 1870s of the iconic "Berlin specimen" of Archaeopteryx, complete with a set of reptilian teeth, provided further .The discovery in the late 1870s of the iconic "Berlin specimen" of Archaeopteryx, complete with a set of reptilian teeth, provided further .
Like Cope, Huxley proposed an evolutionary relationship between birds and .Like Cope, Huxley proposed an evolutionary relationship between birds and .
Although Huxley was opposed by the very influential Owen, his conclusions were accepted by many biologists, including Baron Franz Nopcsa, while others, notably Harry Seeley, argued that the similarities were due to convergent .Although Huxley was opposed by the very influential Owen, his conclusions were accepted by many biologists, including Baron Franz Nopcsa, while others, notably Harry Seeley, argued that the similarities were due to convergent .
Heilmann and the thecodont hypothesis
A turning point came in the early twentieth century with the writings of Gerhard Heilmann of .A turning point came in the early twentieth century with the writings of Gerhard Heilmann of .
An artist by trade, Heilmann had a scholarly interest in birds and from 1913 to 1916, expanding on earlier work by Othenio Abel, published the results of his research in several parts, dealing with the anatomy, embryology, behavior, paleontology, and evolution of .An artist by trade, Heilmann had a scholarly interest in birds and from 1913 to 1916, expanding on earlier work by Othenio Abel, published the results of his research in several parts, dealing with the anatomy, embryology, behavior, paleontology, and evolution of .
His work, originally written in Danish as Vor Nuvaerende Viden om Fuglenes Afstamning, was compiled, translated into English, and published in 1926 as The Origin of .His work, originally written in Danish as Vor Nuvaerende Viden om Fuglenes Afstamning, was compiled, translated into English, and published in 1926 as The Origin of .
Like Huxley, Heilmann compared Archaeopteryx and other birds to an exhaustive list of prehistoric reptiles, and also came to the conclusion that theropod dinosaurs like Compsognathus were the most .Like Huxley, Heilmann compared Archaeopteryx and other birds to an exhaustive list of prehistoric reptiles, and also came to the conclusion that theropod dinosaurs like Compsognathus were the most .
However, Heilmann noted that birds had clavicles (collar bones) fused to form a bone called the furcula ("wishbone"), and while clavicles were known in more primitive reptiles, they had not yet been recognized in .However, Heilmann noted that birds had clavicles (collar bones) fused to form a bone called the furcula ("wishbone"), and while clavicles were known in more primitive reptiles, they had not yet been recognized in .
Since he was a firm believer in an interpretation of Dollo's law that stated that evolution was not "reversible", Heilmann could not accept that clavicles were lost in dinosaurs and re evolved in .Since he was a firm believer in an interpretation of Dollo's law that stated that evolution was not "reversible", Heilmann could not accept that clavicles were lost in dinosaurs and re evolved in .
He was therefore forced to rule out dinosaurs as bird ancestors and ascribe all of their similarities to convergent .He was therefore forced to rule out dinosaurs as bird ancestors and ascribe all of their similarities to convergent .
Heilmann stated that bird ancestors would instead be found among the more primitive "thecodont" grade of .Heilmann stated that bird ancestors would instead be found among the more primitive "thecodont" grade of .
Heilmann's extremely thorough approach ensured that his book became a classic in the field, and its conclusions on bird origins, as with most other topics, were accepted by nearly all evolutionary biologists for the next four .Heilmann's extremely thorough approach ensured that his book became a classic in the field, and its conclusions on bird origins, as with most other topics, were accepted by nearly all evolutionary biologists for the next four .
Clavicles are relatively delicate bones and therefore in danger of being destroyed or at least damaged beyond .Clavicles are relatively delicate bones and therefore in danger of being destroyed or at least damaged beyond .
Nevertheless, some fossil theropod clavicles had actually been excavated before Heilmann wrote his book, but these had been .Nevertheless, some fossil theropod clavicles had actually been excavated before Heilmann wrote his book, but these had been .
The absence of clavicles in dinosaurs became the orthodox view despite the discovery of clavicles in the primitive theropod Segisaurus in .The absence of clavicles in dinosaurs became the orthodox view despite the discovery of clavicles in the primitive theropod Segisaurus in .
The next report of clavicles in a dinosaur was in a Russian article in .The next report of clavicles in a dinosaur was in a Russian article in .
Contrary to what Heilmann believed, paleontologists now accept that clavicles and in most cases furculae are a standard feature not just of theropods but of saurischian .Contrary to what Heilmann believed, paleontologists now accept that clavicles and in most cases furculae are a standard feature not just of theropods but of saurischian .
Up to late 2007 ossified furculae (i. e. made of bone rather than cartilage) have been found in all types of theropods except the most basal ones, Eoraptor and .Up to late 2007 ossified furculae (i. e. made of bone rather than cartilage) have been found in all types of theropods except the most basal ones, Eoraptor and .
The original report of a furcula in the primitive theropod Segisaurus (1936) was confirmed by a re examination in .The original report of a furcula in the primitive theropod Segisaurus (1936) was confirmed by a re examination in .
Joined, furcula like clavicles have also been found in Massospondylus, an Early Jurassic .Joined, furcula like clavicles have also been found in Massospondylus, an Early Jurassic .
This is called Lateral Digit Reduction (LDR) versus Bilateral Digit Reduction (BDR) (see also ).This is called Lateral Digit Reduction (LDR) versus Bilateral Digit Reduction (BDR) (see also ).
A small minority, known by the acronym BAND (Birds Are Not Dinosaurs), including ornithologists Alan Feduccia and Larry Martin, continues to assert that birds are more closely related to earlier reptiles, such as Longisquama or Euparkeria, than to .A small minority, known by the acronym BAND (Birds Are Not Dinosaurs), including ornithologists Alan Feduccia and Larry Martin, continues to assert that birds are more closely related to earlier reptiles, such as Longisquama or Euparkeria, than to .
Embryological studies of bird developmental biology have raised questions about digit homology in bird and dinosaur .Embryological studies of bird developmental biology have raised questions about digit homology in bird and dinosaur .
However, due to the cogent evidence provided by comparative anatomy and phylogenetics, as well as the dramatic feathered dinosaur fossils from China, the idea that birds are derived dinosaurs, first championed by Huxley and later by Nopcsa and Ostrom, enjoys near unanimous support among today's .However, due to the cogent evidence provided by comparative anatomy and phylogenetics, as well as the dramatic feathered dinosaur fossils from China, the idea that birds are derived dinosaurs, first championed by Huxley and later by Nopcsa and Ostrom, enjoys near unanimous support among today's .
This idea is supported by palaeontological observations, which determine the phalangeal formula 2 3 4 1 X for the last common ancestor of ceratosaurs (including Limusaurus) and tetanurans (including the tridactyl forms with the phalangeal formula 2 3 4 X ).This idea is supported by palaeontological observations, which determine the phalangeal formula 2 3 4 1 X for the last common ancestor of ceratosaurs (including Limusaurus) and tetanurans (including the tridactyl forms with the phalangeal formula 2 3 4 X ).
Some later embryological data support the identification of bird digits as I, II, III as in their theropod .Some later embryological data support the identification of bird digits as I, II, III as in their theropod .
Thermogenic muscle hypothesis
A 2011 publication suggested that selection for the expansion of skeletal muscle, rather than the evolution of flight, was the driving force for the emergence of this .A 2011 publication suggested that selection for the expansion of skeletal muscle, rather than the evolution of flight, was the driving force for the emergence of this .
Muscles became larger in prospectively endothermic saurians, according to this hypothesis, as a response to the loss of the vertebrate mitochondrial uncoupling protein, .Muscles became larger in prospectively endothermic saurians, according to this hypothesis, as a response to the loss of the vertebrate mitochondrial uncoupling protein, .
In mammals, UCP1 functions within brown adipose tissue, which is thermogenic to protect newborns against .In mammals, UCP1 functions within brown adipose tissue, which is thermogenic to protect newborns against .
In modern birds, skeletal muscle serves a similar function and is presumed to have done so in their .In modern birds, skeletal muscle serves a similar function and is presumed to have done so in their .
In this view, bipedality and other avian skeletal alterations were side effects of muscle hyperplasia, with further evolutionary modifications of the forelimbs, including adaptations for flight or swimming, and vestigiality, being secondary consequences of two .In this view, bipedality and other avian skeletal alterations were side effects of muscle hyperplasia, with further evolutionary modifications of the forelimbs, including adaptations for flight or swimming, and vestigiality, being secondary consequences of two .
Phylogeny
Archaeopteryx has historically been considered the first bird, or .Archaeopteryx has historically been considered the first bird, or .
Although newer fossil discoveries filled the gap between theropods and Archaeopteryx, as well as the gap between Archaeopteryx and modern birds, phylogenetic taxonomists, in keeping with tradition, almost always use Archaeopteryx as a specifier to help define .Although newer fossil discoveries filled the gap between theropods and Archaeopteryx, as well as the gap between Archaeopteryx and modern birds, phylogenetic taxonomists, in keeping with tradition, almost always use Archaeopteryx as a specifier to help define .
Aves has more rarely been defined as a crown group consisting only of modern .Aves has more rarely been defined as a crown group consisting only of modern .
Of these, dromaeosaurids and troodontids are usually united in the clade Deinonychosauria, which is a sister group to birds (together forming the node clade Eumaniraptora) within the stem clade .Of these, dromaeosaurids and troodontids are usually united in the clade Deinonychosauria, which is a sister group to birds (together forming the node clade Eumaniraptora) within the stem clade .
Other studies have proposed alternative phylogenies, in which certain groups of dinosaurs usually considered non avian may have evolved from avian .Other studies have proposed alternative phylogenies, in which certain groups of dinosaurs usually considered non avian may have evolved from avian .
For example, a 2002 analysis found that oviraptorosaurs were basal .For example, a 2002 analysis found that oviraptorosaurs were basal .
Alvarezsaurids, known from Asia and the Americas, have been variously classified as basal maniraptorans, paravians, as well as specialized early .Alvarezsaurids, known from Asia and the Americas, have been variously classified as basal maniraptorans, paravians, as well as specialized early .
The genus Rahonavis, originally described as an early bird, has been identified as a non avian dromaeosaurid in several .The genus Rahonavis, originally described as an early bird, has been identified as a non avian dromaeosaurid in several .
Dromaeosaurids and troodontids themselves have also been suggested to lie within Aves rather than just outside .Dromaeosaurids and troodontids themselves have also been suggested to lie within Aves rather than just outside .
Features linking birds and dinosaurs
Many anatomical features are shared by birds and other theropod .Many anatomical features are shared by birds and other theropod .
Feathers
Archaeopteryx, the first good example of a "feathered dinosaur", was discovered in .Archaeopteryx, the first good example of a "feathered dinosaur", was discovered in .
The first specimen was found in the Solnhofen limestone in southern Germany, which is a lagerstätte, a rare and remarkable geological formation known for its superbly detailed .The first specimen was found in the Solnhofen limestone in southern Germany, which is a lagerstätte, a rare and remarkable geological formation known for its superbly detailed .
Archaeopteryx is a transitional fossil, with features clearly intermediate between those of non avian theropod dinosaurs and .Archaeopteryx is a transitional fossil, with features clearly intermediate between those of non avian theropod dinosaurs and .
Discovered just two years after Darwin's seminal Origin of Species, its discovery spurred the nascent debate between proponents of evolutionary biology and .Discovered just two years after Darwin's seminal Origin of Species, its discovery spurred the nascent debate between proponents of evolutionary biology and .
This early bird is so dinosaur like that, without a clear impression of feathers in the surrounding rock, at least one specimen was mistaken for .This early bird is so dinosaur like that, without a clear impression of feathers in the surrounding rock, at least one specimen was mistaken for .
Since the 1990s, a number of additional feathered dinosaurs have been found, providing even stronger evidence of the close relationship between dinosaurs and modern .Since the 1990s, a number of additional feathered dinosaurs have been found, providing even stronger evidence of the close relationship between dinosaurs and modern .
The first of these were initially described as simple filamentous protofeathers, which were reported in dinosaur lineages as primitive as compsognathids and .The first of these were initially described as simple filamentous protofeathers, which were reported in dinosaur lineages as primitive as compsognathids and .
However, feathers indistinguishable from those of modern birds were soon after found in non avialan dinosaurs as .However, feathers indistinguishable from those of modern birds were soon after found in non avialan dinosaurs as .
However, a majority of studies have concluded that feathered dinosaurs are in fact dinosaurs, and that the simpler filaments of unquestionable theropods represent simple .However, a majority of studies have concluded that feathered dinosaurs are in fact dinosaurs, and that the simpler filaments of unquestionable theropods represent simple .
Some researchers have demonstrated the presence of color bearing melanin in the structures —which would be expected in feathers but not collagen .Some researchers have demonstrated the presence of color bearing melanin in the structures —which would be expected in feathers but not collagen .
Others have demonstrated, using studies of modern bird decomposition, that even advanced feathers appear filamentous when subjected to the crushing forces experienced during fossilization, and that the supposed "protofeathers" may have been more complex than previously .Others have demonstrated, using studies of modern bird decomposition, that even advanced feathers appear filamentous when subjected to the crushing forces experienced during fossilization, and that the supposed "protofeathers" may have been more complex than previously .
Detailed examination of the "protofeathers" of Sinosauropteryx prima showed that individual feathers consisted of a central quill (rachis) with thinner barbs branching off from it, similar to but more primitive in structure than modern bird .Detailed examination of the "protofeathers" of Sinosauropteryx prima showed that individual feathers consisted of a central quill (rachis) with thinner barbs branching off from it, similar to but more primitive in structure than modern bird .
The 2022 description of branched feathers in the pterosaur Tupandactylus provides strong evidence that "pycnofibers" are not actually a distinct integument unrelated to origin of .The 2022 description of branched feathers in the pterosaur Tupandactylus provides strong evidence that "pycnofibers" are not actually a distinct integument unrelated to origin of .
The most parsimonious scenario is the presence of feathers in the last common ancestor of pterosaurs and dinosaurs already in the Early .The most parsimonious scenario is the presence of feathers in the last common ancestor of pterosaurs and dinosaurs already in the Early .
Tupandactylus's melanosomes indicate visual signalling was an important factor in the evolution of .Tupandactylus's melanosomes indicate visual signalling was an important factor in the evolution of .
Skeleton
Because feathers are often associated with birds, feathered dinosaurs are often touted as the "missing link" between birds and other .Because feathers are often associated with birds, feathered dinosaurs are often touted as the "missing link" between birds and other .
However, the multiple skeletal features also shared by the two groups represent the more important proof for .However, the multiple skeletal features also shared by the two groups represent the more important proof for .
Comparisons of bird and dinosaur skeletons, as well as cladistic analysis, strengthens the case for the link, particularly for a branch of theropods called .Comparisons of bird and dinosaur skeletons, as well as cladistic analysis, strengthens the case for the link, particularly for a branch of theropods called .
Skeletal similarities include the skull, tooth build, neck, uncinate processes on the ribs, an open hip socket, a retroverted long pubis, flexible wrist (semi lunate carpal), long arms, three fingered hand, general pectoral girdle, shoulder blade, furcula, and breast .Skeletal similarities include the skull, tooth build, neck, uncinate processes on the ribs, an open hip socket, a retroverted long pubis, flexible wrist (semi lunate carpal), long arms, three fingered hand, general pectoral girdle, shoulder blade, furcula, and breast .
Almost all skeletal traits of Archaeopteryx can be found in non avian .Almost all skeletal traits of Archaeopteryx can be found in non avian .
A study comparing embryonic, juvenile and adult archosaur skulls concluded that bird skulls are derived from those of theropod dinosaurs by progenesis, a type of paedomorphic heterochrony, which resulted in retention of juvenile characteristics of their .A study comparing embryonic, juvenile and adult archosaur skulls concluded that bird skulls are derived from those of theropod dinosaurs by progenesis, a type of paedomorphic heterochrony, which resulted in retention of juvenile characteristics of their .
Lungs
Large meat eating dinosaurs had a complex system of air sacs similar to those found in modern birds, according to an investigation led by Patrick M. O'Connor of Ohio .Large meat eating dinosaurs had a complex system of air sacs similar to those found in modern birds, according to an investigation led by Patrick M. O'Connor of Ohio .
In theropod dinosaurs (carnivores that walked on two legs and had birdlike feet) flexible soft tissue air sacs likely pumped air through the stiff lungs, as is the case in .In theropod dinosaurs (carnivores that walked on two legs and had birdlike feet) flexible soft tissue air sacs likely pumped air through the stiff lungs, as is the case in .
"What was once formally considered unique to birds was present in some form in the ancestors of birds", O'Connor ."What was once formally considered unique to birds was present in some form in the ancestors of birds", O'Connor .
Heart
Computed tomography (CT) scans conducted in 2000 of the chest cavity of a specimen of the ornithopod Thescelosaurus found the apparent remnants of a complex four chambered heart, much like those found in today's mammals and .Computed tomography (CT) scans conducted in 2000 of the chest cavity of a specimen of the ornithopod Thescelosaurus found the apparent remnants of a complex four chambered heart, much like those found in today's mammals and .
The idea is controversial within the scientific community, criticised for being bad anatomical science or simply wishful thinking, It is also not very surprising as crocodilians also possess four chambered .The idea is controversial within the scientific community, criticised for being bad anatomical science or simply wishful thinking, It is also not very surprising as crocodilians also possess four chambered .
A study published in 2011 applied multiple lines of inquiry to the question of the object's identity, including more advanced CT scanning, histology, X ray diffraction, X ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and scanning electron .A study published in 2011 applied multiple lines of inquiry to the question of the object's identity, including more advanced CT scanning, histology, X ray diffraction, X ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and scanning electron .
From these methods, the authors found that: the object's internal structure does not include chambers but is made up of three unconnected areas of lower density material, and is not comparable to the structure of an ostrich's heart; the "walls" are composed of sedimentary minerals not known to be produced in biological systems, such as goethite, feldspar minerals, quartz, and gypsum, as well as some plant fragments; carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus, chemical elements important to life, were lacking in their samples; and cardiac cellular structures were .From these methods, the authors found that: the object's internal structure does not include chambers but is made up of three unconnected areas of lower density material, and is not comparable to the structure of an ostrich's heart; the "walls" are composed of sedimentary minerals not known to be produced in biological systems, such as goethite, feldspar minerals, quartz, and gypsum, as well as some plant fragments; carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus, chemical elements important to life, were lacking in their samples; and cardiac cellular structures were .
There was one possible patch with animal cellular .There was one possible patch with animal cellular .
The authors found their data supported identification as a concretion of sand from the burial environment, not the heart, with the possibility that isolated areas of tissues were .The authors found their data supported identification as a concretion of sand from the burial environment, not the heart, with the possibility that isolated areas of tissues were .
The question of how this find reflects metabolic rate and dinosaur internal anatomy is moot, though, regardless of the object's .The question of how this find reflects metabolic rate and dinosaur internal anatomy is moot, though, regardless of the object's .
Sleeping posture
Fossils of the troodonts Mei and Sinornithoides demonstrate that the dinosaurs slept like certain modern birds, with their heads tucked under their .Fossils of the troodonts Mei and Sinornithoides demonstrate that the dinosaurs slept like certain modern birds, with their heads tucked under their .
This behavior, which may have helped to keep the head warm, is also characteristic of modern .This behavior, which may have helped to keep the head warm, is also characteristic of modern .
Reproductive biology
When laying eggs, female birds grow a special type of bone in their .When laying eggs, female birds grow a special type of bone in their .
This medullary bone forms as a calcium rich layer inside the hard outer bone, and is used as a calcium source to make .This medullary bone forms as a calcium rich layer inside the hard outer bone, and is used as a calcium source to make .
The presence of endosteally derived bone tissues lining the interior marrow cavities of portions of a Tyrannosaurus rex specimen's hind limb suggested that T. rex used similar reproductive strategies, and revealed that the specimen is .The presence of endosteally derived bone tissues lining the interior marrow cavities of portions of a Tyrannosaurus rex specimen's hind limb suggested that T. rex used similar reproductive strategies, and revealed that the specimen is .
Further research has found medullary bone in the theropod Allosaurus and ornithopod .Further research has found medullary bone in the theropod Allosaurus and ornithopod .
Because the line of dinosaurs that includes Allosaurus and Tyrannosaurus diverged from the line that led to Tenontosaurus very early in the evolution of dinosaurs, this suggests that dinosaurs in general produced medullary .Because the line of dinosaurs that includes Allosaurus and Tyrannosaurus diverged from the line that led to Tenontosaurus very early in the evolution of dinosaurs, this suggests that dinosaurs in general produced medullary .
Brooding and care of young
Several Citipati specimens have been found resting over the eggs in its nest in a position most reminiscent of .Several Citipati specimens have been found resting over the eggs in its nest in a position most reminiscent of .
Numerous dinosaur species, for example Maiasaura, have been found in herds mixing both very young and adult individuals, suggesting rich interactions between .Numerous dinosaur species, for example Maiasaura, have been found in herds mixing both very young and adult individuals, suggesting rich interactions between .
A dinosaur embryo was found without teeth, which suggests some parental care was required to feed the young dinosaur, possibly the adult dinosaur regurgitated food into the young dinosaur's mouth (see ).A dinosaur embryo was found without teeth, which suggests some parental care was required to feed the young dinosaur, possibly the adult dinosaur regurgitated food into the young dinosaur's mouth (see ).
This behaviour is seen in numerous bird species; parent birds regurgitate food into the hatchling's .This behaviour is seen in numerous bird species; parent birds regurgitate food into the hatchling's .
Gizzard stones
Both birds and dinosaurs use gizzard .Both birds and dinosaurs use gizzard .
These stones are swallowed by animals to aid digestion and break down food and hard fibres once they enter the .These stones are swallowed by animals to aid digestion and break down food and hard fibres once they enter the .
When found in association with fossils, gizzard stones are called .When found in association with fossils, gizzard stones are called .
Gizzard stones are also found in some fish (mullets, mud shad, and the gillaroo, a type of trout) and in .Gizzard stones are also found in some fish (mullets, mud shad, and the gillaroo, a type of trout) and in .
Molecular evidence
On several occasions, the extraction of DNA and proteins from Mesozoic dinosaurs fossils has been claimed, allowing for a comparison with .On several occasions, the extraction of DNA and proteins from Mesozoic dinosaurs fossils has been claimed, allowing for a comparison with .
Several proteins have putatively been detected in dinosaur fossils, including .Several proteins have putatively been detected in dinosaur fossils, including .
In 2023, beta protein structures were reported from the feathers of the dinosaur Sinornithosaurus and the early bird .In 2023, beta protein structures were reported from the feathers of the dinosaur Sinornithosaurus and the early bird .
This confirms that ancient feathers had a composition similar to that of modern .This confirms that ancient feathers had a composition similar to that of modern .
Some fossil feathers were reported to have a composition rich in alpha proteins, but fossilization experiments demonstrate that this protein composition is simply an artefact of preservation, because beta sheet protein structures are readily transformed to alpha helices during thermal .Some fossil feathers were reported to have a composition rich in alpha proteins, but fossilization experiments demonstrate that this protein composition is simply an artefact of preservation, because beta sheet protein structures are readily transformed to alpha helices during thermal .
The soft tissue allowed a molecular comparison of cellular anatomy and protein sequencing of collagen tissue published in 2007, both of which indicated that T. rex and birds are more closely related to each other than either is to .The soft tissue allowed a molecular comparison of cellular anatomy and protein sequencing of collagen tissue published in 2007, both of which indicated that T. rex and birds are more closely related to each other than either is to .
A second molecular study robustly supported the relationship of birds to dinosaurs, though it did not place birds within Theropoda, as .A second molecular study robustly supported the relationship of birds to dinosaurs, though it did not place birds within Theropoda, as .
This study utilized eight additional collagen sequences extracted from a femur of the "mummified" Brachylophosaurus canadensis specimen MOR 2598, a .This study utilized eight additional collagen sequences extracted from a femur of the "mummified" Brachylophosaurus canadensis specimen MOR 2598, a .
However, these results have been very .However, these results have been very .
No other peptides of a Mesozoic age have been .No other peptides of a Mesozoic age have been .
In 2008, it was suggested that the presumed soft tissue was in fact a bacterial .In 2008, it was suggested that the presumed soft tissue was in fact a bacterial .
In response, it was argued that these very microfilms protected the soft .In response, it was argued that these very microfilms protected the soft .
Another objection was that the results could have been caused by .Another objection was that the results could have been caused by .
In 2015, under more controlled conditions safeguarding against contamination, the peptides were still .In 2015, under more controlled conditions safeguarding against contamination, the peptides were still .
In 2017, a study found that a peptide was present in the bone of the modern ostrich that was identical to that found in the Tyrannosaurus and Brachylophosaurus specimens, highlighting the danger of a cross .In 2017, a study found that a peptide was present in the bone of the modern ostrich that was identical to that found in the Tyrannosaurus and Brachylophosaurus specimens, highlighting the danger of a cross .
The successful extraction of ancient DNA from dinosaur fossils has been reported on two separate occasions, but upon further inspection and peer review, neither of these reports could be .The successful extraction of ancient DNA from dinosaur fossils has been reported on two separate occasions, but upon further inspection and peer review, neither of these reports could be .
Origin of bird flight
Debates about the origin of bird flight are almost as old as the idea that birds evolved from dinosaurs, which arose soon after the discovery of Archaeopteryx in .Debates about the origin of bird flight are almost as old as the idea that birds evolved from dinosaurs, which arose soon after the discovery of Archaeopteryx in .
Two theories have dominated most of the discussion since then: the cursorial ("from the ground up") theory proposes that birds evolved from small, fast predators that ran on the ground; the arboreal ("from the trees down") theory proposes that powered flight evolved from unpowered gliding by arboreal (tree climbing) .Two theories have dominated most of the discussion since then: the cursorial ("from the ground up") theory proposes that birds evolved from small, fast predators that ran on the ground; the arboreal ("from the trees down") theory proposes that powered flight evolved from unpowered gliding by arboreal (tree climbing) .
A more recent theory, "wing assisted incline running" (WAIR), is a variant of the cursorial theory and proposes that wings developed their aerodynamic functions as a result of the need to run quickly up very steep slopes such as trees, which would help small feathered dinosaurs escape from .A more recent theory, "wing assisted incline running" (WAIR), is a variant of the cursorial theory and proposes that wings developed their aerodynamic functions as a result of the need to run quickly up very steep slopes such as trees, which would help small feathered dinosaurs escape from .
In March 2018, scientists reported that Archaeopteryx was likely capable of flight, but in a manner substantially different from that of modern .In March 2018, scientists reported that Archaeopteryx was likely capable of flight, but in a manner substantially different from that of modern .
Cursorial ("from the ground up") theory
The cursorial theory of the origin of flight was first proposed by Samuel Wendell Williston, and elaborated upon by Baron .The cursorial theory of the origin of flight was first proposed by Samuel Wendell Williston, and elaborated upon by Baron .
This hypothesis proposes that some fast running animals with long tails used their arms to keep their balance while .This hypothesis proposes that some fast running animals with long tails used their arms to keep their balance while .
Modern versions of this theory differ in many details from the Williston Nopcsa version, mainly as a result of discoveries since Nopcsa's .Modern versions of this theory differ in many details from the Williston Nopcsa version, mainly as a result of discoveries since Nopcsa's .
Nopcsa theorized that increasing the surface area of the outstretched arms could have helped small cursorial predators keep their balance, and that the scales of the forearms elongated, evolving into .Nopcsa theorized that increasing the surface area of the outstretched arms could have helped small cursorial predators keep their balance, and that the scales of the forearms elongated, evolving into .
The feathers could also have been used to trap insects or other .The feathers could also have been used to trap insects or other .
Progressively, the animals leapt for longer distances, helped by their evolving .Progressively, the animals leapt for longer distances, helped by their evolving .
Nopcsa also proposed three stages in the evolution of .Nopcsa also proposed three stages in the evolution of .
First, animals developed passive flight, in which developing wing structures served as a sort of .First, animals developed passive flight, in which developing wing structures served as a sort of .
Second, they achieved active flight by flapping the .Second, they achieved active flight by flapping the .
He used Archaeopteryx as an example of this second .He used Archaeopteryx as an example of this second .
Finally, birds gained the ability to .Finally, birds gained the ability to .
While some authors had rejected the homology between feathers and scales due to their different proteins, recent studies provide evidence that those structures do share a common .While some authors had rejected the homology between feathers and scales due to their different proteins, recent studies provide evidence that those structures do share a common .
However, Nopcsa's theory assumes that feathers evolved as part of the evolution of flight, and recent discoveries show that feathers evolved millions of years before .However, Nopcsa's theory assumes that feathers evolved as part of the evolution of flight, and recent discoveries show that feathers evolved millions of years before .
Modern birds are classified as coelurosaurs by nearly all palaeontologists, though not by a few .Modern birds are classified as coelurosaurs by nearly all palaeontologists, though not by a few .
The modern version of the "from the ground up" hypothesis argues that birds' ancestors were small, feathered, ground running predatory dinosaurs (rather like roadrunners in their hunting style) that used their forelimbs for balance while pursuing prey, and that the forelimbs and feathers later evolved in ways that provided gliding and then powered .The modern version of the "from the ground up" hypothesis argues that birds' ancestors were small, feathered, ground running predatory dinosaurs (rather like roadrunners in their hunting style) that used their forelimbs for balance while pursuing prey, and that the forelimbs and feathers later evolved in ways that provided gliding and then powered .
The most widely suggested original functions of feathers include thermal insulation and competitive displays, as in modern .The most widely suggested original functions of feathers include thermal insulation and competitive displays, as in modern .
All of the Archaeopteryx fossils come from marine sediments, and it has been suggested that wings may have helped the birds run over water in the manner of the Jesus Christ Lizard (common ).All of the Archaeopteryx fossils come from marine sediments, and it has been suggested that wings may have helped the birds run over water in the manner of the Jesus Christ Lizard (common ).
Most recent opposition to the "from the ground up" hypothesis attempt to refute the modern version's assumption that birds are modified coelurosaurian .Most recent opposition to the "from the ground up" hypothesis attempt to refute the modern version's assumption that birds are modified coelurosaurian .
The criticism is based on embryological analyses that suggest birds' wings are formed from digits 2, 3, and 4, (corresponding to the index, middle, and ring fingers in .The criticism is based on embryological analyses that suggest birds' wings are formed from digits 2, 3, and 4, (corresponding to the index, middle, and ring fingers in .
The first of a bird's three digits forms the alula, which they use to avoid stalling in low speed flight—for example, when ).The first of a bird's three digits forms the alula, which they use to avoid stalling in low speed flight—for example, when ).
The hands of coelurosaurs, however, are formed by digits 1, 2, and 3 (thumb and first two fingers in ).The hands of coelurosaurs, however, are formed by digits 1, 2, and 3 (thumb and first two fingers in ).
For more information about this subject, see "Digit ".For more information about this subject, see "Digit ".
Fowler et .
(2011) proposed a model explaining how dromaeosaurids may have .(2011) proposed a model explaining how dromaeosaurids may have .
The animal would use its wing as stabilizers while standing on top of its prey eating it alive in the manner of an eagle or a .The animal would use its wing as stabilizers while standing on top of its prey eating it alive in the manner of an eagle or a .
The authors consider this an important addition to the topic of how flapping movements evolved, arguing they likely precede .The authors consider this an important addition to the topic of how flapping movements evolved, arguing they likely precede .
Wing-assisted incline running
The wing assisted incline running (WAIR) hypothesis was prompted by observation of young chukar chicks, and proposes that wings developed their aerodynamic functions as a result of the need to run quickly up very steep slopes such as tree trunks, for example to escape from .The wing assisted incline running (WAIR) hypothesis was prompted by observation of young chukar chicks, and proposes that wings developed their aerodynamic functions as a result of the need to run quickly up very steep slopes such as tree trunks, for example to escape from .
This makes it a specialized type of cursorial ("from the ground up") .This makes it a specialized type of cursorial ("from the ground up") .
Note that in this scenario birds need downforce to give their feet increased .Note that in this scenario birds need downforce to give their feet increased .
But early birds, including Archaeopteryx, lacked the shoulder mechanism by which modern birds' wings produce swift, powerful .But early birds, including Archaeopteryx, lacked the shoulder mechanism by which modern birds' wings produce swift, powerful .
Since the downforce WAIR depends on is generated by upstrokes, it seems that early birds were incapable of .Since the downforce WAIR depends on is generated by upstrokes, it seems that early birds were incapable of .
Because WAIR is a behavioural trait without osteological specializations, the phylogenetic placement of the flight stroke before the divergence of the Neornithes, the group which contains all extant birds, makes it impossible to determine if WAIR is ancestral to the avian flight stroke or derived from .Because WAIR is a behavioural trait without osteological specializations, the phylogenetic placement of the flight stroke before the divergence of the Neornithes, the group which contains all extant birds, makes it impossible to determine if WAIR is ancestral to the avian flight stroke or derived from .
Arboreal ("from the trees down") theory
Most versions of the arboreal hypothesis state that the ancestors of birds were very small dinosaurs that lived in trees, springing from branch to .Most versions of the arboreal hypothesis state that the ancestors of birds were very small dinosaurs that lived in trees, springing from branch to .
This small dinosaur already had feathers, which were co opted by evolution to produce longer, stiffer forms that were useful in aerodynamics, eventually producing .This small dinosaur already had feathers, which were co opted by evolution to produce longer, stiffer forms that were useful in aerodynamics, eventually producing .
Wings would have then evolved and become increasingly refined as devices to give the leaper more control, to parachute, to glide, and to fly in stepwise .Wings would have then evolved and become increasingly refined as devices to give the leaper more control, to parachute, to glide, and to fly in stepwise .
The arboreal hypothesis also notes that, for arboreal animals, aerodynamics are far more energy efficient, since such animals simply fall to achieve minimum gliding .The arboreal hypothesis also notes that, for arboreal animals, aerodynamics are far more energy efficient, since such animals simply fall to achieve minimum gliding .
Several small dinosaurs from the Jurassic or Early Cretaceous, all with feathers, have been interpreted as possibly having arboreal and/or aerodynamic .Several small dinosaurs from the Jurassic or Early Cretaceous, all with feathers, have been interpreted as possibly having arboreal and/or aerodynamic .
These include Scansoriopteryx, Epidexipteryx, Microraptor, Pedopenna, and .These include Scansoriopteryx, Epidexipteryx, Microraptor, Pedopenna, and .
Anchiornis is particularly important to this subject, as it lived at the beginning of the Late Jurassic, long before .Anchiornis is particularly important to this subject, as it lived at the beginning of the Late Jurassic, long before .
Analysis of the proportions of the toe bones of the most primitive birds Archaeopteryx and Confuciusornis, compared to those of living species, suggest that the early species may have lived both on the ground and in .Analysis of the proportions of the toe bones of the most primitive birds Archaeopteryx and Confuciusornis, compared to those of living species, suggest that the early species may have lived both on the ground and in .
One study suggested that the earliest birds and their immediate ancestors did not climb .One study suggested that the earliest birds and their immediate ancestors did not climb .
This study determined that the amount of toe claw curvature of early birds was more like that seen in modern ground foraging birds than in perching .This study determined that the amount of toe claw curvature of early birds was more like that seen in modern ground foraging birds than in perching .
Diminished significance of Archaeopteryx
Archaeopteryx was the first and for a long time the only known feathered Mesozoic .Archaeopteryx was the first and for a long time the only known feathered Mesozoic .
As a result, discussion of the evolution of birds and of bird flight centered on Archaeopteryx at least until the mid .As a result, discussion of the evolution of birds and of bird flight centered on Archaeopteryx at least until the mid .
There has been debate about whether Archaeopteryx could really .There has been debate about whether Archaeopteryx could really .
It appears that Archaeopteryx had the brain structures and inner ear balance sensors that birds use to control their .It appears that Archaeopteryx had the brain structures and inner ear balance sensors that birds use to control their .
Archaeopteryx also had a wing feather arrangement like that of modern birds and similarly asymmetrical flight feathers on its wings and .Archaeopteryx also had a wing feather arrangement like that of modern birds and similarly asymmetrical flight feathers on its wings and .
But Archaeopteryx lacked the shoulder mechanism by which modern birds' wings produce swift, powerful upstrokes (see diagram above of supracoracoideus pulley); this may mean that it and other early birds were incapable of flapping flight and could only .But Archaeopteryx lacked the shoulder mechanism by which modern birds' wings produce swift, powerful upstrokes (see diagram above of supracoracoideus pulley); this may mean that it and other early birds were incapable of flapping flight and could only .
Scansoriopteryx, an arboreal dinosaur that may support the "from the trees down" theory, and Microraptor, an arboreal dinosaur possibly capable of powered flight but, if so, more like a biplane, as it had well developed feathers on its .Scansoriopteryx, an arboreal dinosaur that may support the "from the trees down" theory, and Microraptor, an arboreal dinosaur possibly capable of powered flight but, if so, more like a biplane, as it had well developed feathers on its .
As early as 1915, some scientists argued that the evolution of bird flight may have gone through a four winged (or tetrapteryx) .As early as 1915, some scientists argued that the evolution of bird flight may have gone through a four winged (or tetrapteryx) .
Hartman et .
(2019) found that, because of how basal flying paravians are phylogenetically distributed, flight most likely evolved five times among paravians instead of only .(2019) found that, because of how basal flying paravians are phylogenetically distributed, flight most likely evolved five times among paravians instead of only .
Yi, Archaeopteryx, Rahonavis and Microraptor were thus considered examples of convergent evolution instead of precursors of bird .Yi, Archaeopteryx, Rahonavis and Microraptor were thus considered examples of convergent evolution instead of precursors of bird .